Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-tnkh4 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T03:47:07.048Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Intermittent modal coupling in screeching underexpanded circular twin jets

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 January 2021

G. Bell*
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering, Laboratory of Turbulence Research in Aerospace and Combustion, Monash University, Melbourne, Victoria 3800, Australia
J. Cluts
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering, Gas Dynamics and Turbulence Laboratory, Aerospace Research Center, The Ohio State University, Columbus, OH 43235, USA
M. Samimy
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering, Gas Dynamics and Turbulence Laboratory, Aerospace Research Center, The Ohio State University, Columbus, OH 43235, USA
J. Soria
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering, Laboratory of Turbulence Research in Aerospace and Combustion, Monash University, Melbourne, Victoria 3800, Australia
D. Edgington-Mitchell
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering, Laboratory of Turbulence Research in Aerospace and Combustion, Monash University, Melbourne, Victoria 3800, Australia
*
†Email address for correspondence: graham.bell@monash.edu

Abstract

In this article the erratic coupling that can occur in screeching supersonic twin jets is characterised. Non-stationary acoustic analysis is used to investigate the temporal behaviour of the coupling phenomena. The results show that where the phase between the jets is time varying, the screech tone experiences interruptions. The interruptions are either correlated and experienced by both jets or are anti-correlated and only by one. During the anti-correlated interruption, the uninterrupted jet screeches as an isolated jet. The instantaneous velocity field shows that for the majority of snapshots during an acoustic interruption, the jets do not exhibit a coupled oscillation. When the jets are uninterrupted, they are oscillating in either a coupled symmetric or anti-symmetric mode. This behaviour manifests at a condition between two operating points characterised by different coupling modes. It suggests the interruptions arise due to a competition between two global modes of the flow. Despite the existence of multiple acoustic tones in the region where these modes are competing, analysis of the individual jets reveals energetic structures with only a single wavelength. It is found that jets whose own oscillation is characterised by a single wavelength can, through coupling either symmetrically or anti-symmetrically about their symmetry plane, produce different acoustic tones. These findings are consistent across three experimental facilities. The observed modes are a function of the jet spacing and nozzle pressure, therefore future studies investigating other spacings must recharacterise the encountered coupled modes. This article provides the signatures to characterise the behaviour for future studies.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Schematic of the acoustic set-up, adapted from Knast et al. (2018).

Figure 1

Figure 2.Experimental PIV set-up.

Figure 2

Figure 3.Waterfall plot of PSD for $s/D=3$. Data from Knast et al. (2018). The high-intensity narrow-band lines indicate screech tones. Discontinuous frequency changes in the screech tone indicate a change of twin-jet mode.

Figure 3

Figure 4.Cross power spectral density results between opposing microphones from the experiments performed in Knast et al. (2018). (a) Waterfall combination plot of cross-spectral density coherence. (b) Waterfall combination plot of cross-spectral density phase given that coherence${\geqslant }0.7$.

Figure 4

Figure 5.Coherence vs. NPR marked with processes where acoustic temporal information is examined with the bandpass Hilbert technique.

Figure 5

Figure 6.Joint probability density functions of phase and amplitude as a function of $\mathrm {NPR}$ for processes 1, 2 and 3. Colour bars represent histogram probability density. The histogram is normalised such that the sum of the probabilities for a given pressure ratio is 1 and the units are 1/degree and 1/dB for phase and amplitude respectively. (a) Process 1 phase. (b) Process1 amplitude. (c) Process 2 phase. (d) Process 2 amplitude. (e) Process 3 phase. (f) Process 3 amplitude.

Figure 6

Table 1.The letters N/W correspond to narrowly/widely statistically distributed, respectively, 0 and 180 correspond to observed centre of the phase distribution and UC corresponds to an uncentred distribution.

Figure 7

Figure 7.Percentage of acoustic interruptions detected within the Hilbert amplitude acoustic signals across NPR for each process.

Figure 8

Figure 8.Distribution of interruption duration and coupling duration histograms across processes 1 and 2. Colour bars represent histogram probability density. The histograms are normalised such that the sum of the probabilities is 1 for a given NPR and the units are 1/screech cycle. (a,b) Process 1. (c,d) Process 2.

Figure 9

Figure 9.Bandpass Hilbert amplitude joint histograms for various NPRs. Horizontal axis represents microphone 1 in dB, vertical axis represents microphone 2 in dB. $P_1$, $P_2$, $P_3$ represent processes 1, 2 and 3 respectively. (a) $P_1$$\textrm {NPR}=2.75$. (b) $P_2$$\textrm {NPR}=2.75$. (c) $P_3$$\textrm {NPR}=2.75$. (d) $P_1$$\textrm {NPR}=3.20$. (e) $P_2$$\textrm {NPR}=3.20$. (f) $P_3$$\textrm {NPR}=3.20$. (g) $P_1$$\textrm {NPR}=3.85$. (h) $P_2$$\textrm {NPR}=3.85$. (i) $P_3$$\textrm {NPR}=3.85$. (j) $P_1$$\textrm {NPR}=4.30$. (k) $P_2$$\textrm {NPR}=4.30$. (l) $P_3$$\textrm {NPR}=4.30$. (m) $P_1$$\textrm {NPR}=4.60$. (n) $P_2$$\textrm {NPR}=4.60$. (o) $P_3$$\textrm {NPR}=4.60$.

Figure 10

Figure 10.Joint histograms of bandpass Hilbert amplitude (dB) response between two processes. Axes are for a single microphone in dB. $P_1$, $P_2$, $P_3$ correspond to processes 1, 2 and 3 respectively. $P_1$ vs. $P_2$ corresponds to $P_1$ on the vertical and $P_2$ on the horizontal axes. Colour bars represent histogram probability density. The histogram is normalised such that the sum in a given axis of the probabilities is 1 and the units are 1/dB. (a) $P_1$ vs. $P_2$, $\textrm {NPR}=4.0$. (b) $P_2$ vs. $P_3$, $\textrm {NPR}=5.0$. (c) $P_1$ vs. $P_3$, $\textrm {NPR}=5.0$.

Figure 11

Figure 11.Power spectral density vs. NPR of cases for which the PIV measurements of Bell et al. (2018) were obtained on facility two.

Figure 12

Figure 12.Hilbert bandpass acoustic response for facility two where the PIV experiments were performed. A joint histogram of bandpass Hilbert amplitude (dB) response is shown in (a) at $\mathrm {NPR}=4.6$ between process 1 ($P_1$, vertical axis) and process 3 ($P_3$, horizontal axis). It illustrates the two processes being generally uncorrelated. The colour bar represents histogram probability density and is normalised such that the sum in a given axis of the probabilities is 1 and the units are 1/dB. Panels (b,c) show a sample temporal response of the two processes to illustrate unsteadiness. (a) $P_1$ vs. $P_3$, $\textrm {NPR}=4.6$. (b) Process 1: Hilbert amplitude signal for $\mathrm {NPR}=4.6$. (c) Process 3: Hilbert amplitude signal for $\mathrm {NPR}=4.6$.

Figure 13

Figure 13.POD modes for $\mathrm {NPR} = 5.0$. (a) POD ranked mode kinetic energy (KE) for $\mathrm {NPR} = 5.0$. Dots indicate individual mode specific (sp.) energy contribution. Line shows cumulative specific energy contribution. (b) $\phi _1$. (c) $\phi _2$.

Figure 14

Figure 14.POD modes for $\mathrm {NPR} = 4.6$. (a) POD ranked mode energy for $\mathrm {NPR} = 4.6$. Dots indicate individual mode specific energy contribution. Line shows cumulative specific energy contribution. (b) $\phi _1$. (c) $\phi _2$. (d) $\phi _3$. (e) $\phi _4$.

Figure 15

Figure 15.Upper- and lower-jet subset POD energy for $\mathrm {NPR} = 4.6$. Dots indicate individual mode specific energy contribution. Line shows cumulative specific energy contribution. (a) Lower jet. (b) Upper jet.

Figure 16

Figure 16.Subset POD modes of the lower and upper jets for $\mathrm {NPR} = 4.6$. (a) Upper-jet subset, $\phi _1$. (b) Lower-jet subset, $\phi _1$. (c) Upper-jet subset, $\phi _2$. (d) Lower-jet subset, $\phi _2$.

Figure 17

Figure 17.POD mode coefficient energy distribution against dominant modes for the $\mathrm {NPR} = 4.6$ full-field dataset filtered for when the lower jet modes are strong. Panel (a) shows the POD mode energy coefficient combined with the snapshot selection filter for the high mode amplitudes of the lower jet only. The selective filtering (greater than the 75th percentile of lower-jet mode energy) is shown by white coloured scatter points. The colour bar represents the probability density of the histogram. The histogram is normalised such that the sum of the probabilities for a given pressure ratio is 1. Panel (b) shows a schematic of the four quadrants divided by the dominant mode coefficient levels. Snapshots falling within $Q_1$ have simultaneously low upper- and lower-jet energies. Those falling within $Q_{2/4}$ have high upper-jet energy but low lower-jet energy or vice versa. And snapshots falling within $Q_3$ have high energy in both jets. (c) POD mode energy distribution for POD performed on the full field with the 75th snapshot filter extracting high-energy snapshots, applied to the lower-jet only. Dots indicate individual mode specific energy contribution. Line shows cumulative specific energy contribution.

Figure 18

Figure 18.Leading mode shapes for POD performed on the snapshots above the 75th percentile lower-jet snapshot energy filter (figure 17a). $\mathrm {NPR} = 4.6$. (a) $\phi _1$. (b) $\phi _2$. (c) $\phi _3$. (d) $\phi _4$.

Figure 19

Figure 19.Snapshots and mode distribution for the $\mathrm {NPR} = 4.6$ full-field dataset filtered for when both the lower and upper jets are strong. (a) Shows the POD mode energy coefficients combined with snapshot selection filter for the high mode amplitudes of both the lower and upper jets. The colour bar represents the probability density of the histogram. The histogram is normalised such that the sum of the probabilities is 1. (b) Shows the POD mode energy distribution for the POD performed on the full field with the 75th snapshot filter applied to both the lower and upper jets. Dots indicate individual mode specific energy contribution. The solid line shows the cumulative specific energy.

Figure 20

Figure 20.Leading mode shapes for POD performed on the snapshots above the 75th percentile lower-jet and upper-jet snapshot energy filter (figure 19a). $\mathrm {NPR} = 4.6$. (a) Mode 1. (b) Mode 2. (c) Mode 3. (d) Mode 4.

Figure 21

Table 2.Verification of correspondence between POD modes and screech tones.

Figure 22

Figure 21.Temporal POD coefficients for $\mathrm {NPR}=4.6$ performed on only the high-energy snapshots of the lower and upper jet. The amplitudes of the first and second mode pairs are shown to illustrate their general mutual exclusivity.

Figure 23

Figure 22.Illustration of the interruption detection process, which was used to characterise the duration and frequency of the acoustic interruptions experienced at some NPRs. Figures show process amplitude vs. time. Process amplitude is derived from the bandpass Hilbert technique used to isolate the transient behaviour of the individual processes present in the acoustic spectra. The black horizontal line indicates the signal mean. The red horizontal line indicates the signal mean $-$5 dB. Interruptions are detected where the acoustic signal dips below the red line threshold. (a) Process 1: Hilbert amplitude signal for $\mathrm {NPR}=2.60$; characterised by unsteady coupling, interruptions. (b) Process 1: Hilbert amplitude signal for $\mathrm {NPR}=3.20$; characterised by steady coupling, no interruptions detected. (c) Process 1: Hilbert amplitude signal for $\mathrm {NPR}=4.30$; characterised by unsteady coupling and acoustic interruption events, many interruption instances detected.

Figure 24

Figure 23.Varying the dB threshold to demonstrate insensitive interruption detection dependence. (a) $\mu$$-4$ dB. (b) $\mu$$-$5 dB. (c) $\mu$$-$6 dB.

Figure 25

Figure 24.Anechoic opposing microphone measurements performed within the anechoic jet facility at The Ohio State University.

Figure 26

Figure 25.Acoustic spectra results from an analogous twin-jet experiment performed at the Gas Dynamics and Turbulence Laboratory within the Aerospace Research Center at The Ohio State University. Converging twin-jet nozzles at $s/D=3$ spacing exhaust into an anechoic chamber with an opposing microphone array similar to that used in the Monash University experiments. (a) PSD estimate. (b) CPSD coherence. estimate. (c) CPSD phase estimate. (d) Labelled processes from CPSD coherence. Process 1: blue $\circ$, process 2: orange $\diamond$, process 3: green $\square$, process 4: red $\triangle$.

Figure 27

Figure 26.Acoustic process phase and amplitude from the extracted processes from figure 25(d) using the bandpass Hilbert technique on measurements taken at The Ohio State University. Colour bars represent histogram probability density, where the sum of the probabilities for a given pressure ratio is 1 and the units are 1/degree and 1/dB for phase and amplitude respectively. (a) Process 1 phase. (b) Process 1 amplitude. (c) Process 2 phase. (d) Process 2 amplitude. (e) Process 3 phase. (f) Process 3 amplitude. (g) Process 4 phase. (h) Process 4 amplitude.

Figure 28

Figure 27.Standard deviation (sigma symbol) of phase and amplitude response from processes 1, 2 and 3 with distributions presented in figure 6. (a) Process 1 phase. (b) Process 1 amplitude. (c) Process 2 phase. (d) Process 2 amplitude. (e) Process 3 phase. (f) Process 3 amplitude.

Figure 29

Figure 28.Schlieren stills from Knast et al. (2018) showing independent left and right jet oscillations. These figures are supplementary to supplementary movie 2, which depicts time-resolved footage. The snapshots show the two phase extremes of the oscillation cycles. Panels (a) and (b) show the right-jet oscillating while the left does not. The phase cycle is mostly clearly observed by following the spanwise motion of the shock cells. (a) Right-jet oscillates: $\textrm {phase} = 0$. (b) Right-jet oscillates: $\textrm {phase} = 180$. (c) Left-jet oscillates: $\textrm {phase} = 0$. (d) Left-jet oscillates: $\textrm {phase} = 180$.

Figure 30

Figure 29.Schlieren stills from Knast et al. (2018) showing both jets oscillating and neither jet oscillating. See the supplementary movie for the time-resolved footage. (a) Both jets oscillating: $\textrm {phase} =0$. (b) Both jets oscillating: $\textrm {phase} = 180$. (c) Neither jet oscillates.

Bell et al. supplementary movie 1

This video shows the proper orthogonal decomposition reconstruction of the velocity field. The dominant modes are used to provide phase information. The first twenty modes are used to add fluctuation information.

Download Bell et al. supplementary movie 1(Video)
Video 12.2 MB

Bell et al. supplementary movie 2

This video shows time resolved coupling of supersonic twin jets using ultra high speed schlieren photography. Different nozzle pressure ratios are shown. In certain regions, the coupling is shown to be unsteady and interrupted via acoustic and particle image velocimetry. This video shows the this unsteadiness as a qualitative comparison.

Download Bell et al. supplementary movie 2(Video)
Video 11.3 MB