This book, which originated as a dissertation at the Warburg Institute, examines the reception of Pliny's account of architecture during the Italian Renaissance. Vitruvius’ De architectura is the only complete treatise on architecture that survives from the ancient world. But Pliny in his Naturalis historia also included significant treatments of Roman topography, construction materials such as brick and stone, and ornamentation. He further discussed architectural ‘wonders’, dividing them between those in Rome and those in ‘foreign’ lands. Writing in the first century, Pliny based his account on Vitruvius and on other sources, many no longer extant. Peter Fane-Saunders argues that Pliny's comments on architecture profoundly affected Renaissance architectural thought.
This is a valuable study, especially in as much as Pliny's influence on Renaissance architectural theory and practice has been little studied in a field dominated by Vitruvian studies. F.-S. begins with a comparison between Pliny's architectural writings and the De architectura. Pliny admired architecture only if it had utility — this is in contrast to Vitruvius’ interest in magnificence. Pliny also viewed architecture as a part of the wonders of the natural world. F.-S. divides his study of Pliny's influence on architecture into three parts: antiquarian studies, architectural writings and, finally, physical manifestations — both drawings and built structures.
Pliny's writings on architecture gained influence only in the early to mid-fifteenth century, when early humanist antiquarians used his account of Roman architecture in their study of ancient Roman ruins. The first to connect actual structures to Pliny's text was Flavio Biondo, who along with Pliny condemned magnificence. But Biondo also argued for the superiority of Christian Rome over Pliny's pagan city. After Biondo, antiquarians approached Pliny in a variety of ways. Pomponio Leto and members of his academy from the 1460s increasingly joined fragments of texts (including the Naturalis historia) with fragments of ancient ruins. On the other hand, Mario Fabio Calvo (friend of the painter Raphael and student of Roman topography) used Pliny to evoke Rome's lost majesty, rather than as a source for understanding Roman ruins.
Authors of architectural and related treatises mined Pliny extensively. In his foundational treatise, De re aedificatoria, written around 1450, Leon Battista Alberti used Pliny in his discussions of materials such as stones, and in his treatment of the marvels of the ancient world, especially Rome. Alberti ignored Pliny's condemnation of magnificence. For him ornamentation, connected to civic and moral values, occupied an increasingly central place. After Alberti, virtually all of the many authors of architectural treatises and Vitruvian commentaries used Pliny. Antonio Averlino, known as Filarete, used him to describe lost monuments and to develop an image of the ideal patron. Some, such as the author of the Hypnerotomachia Poliphili (the dream book of Poliphilus), probably the Venetian friar Francesco Colonna, found in the Naturalis historia an aid to building imaginary structures. Others, such as the practical-minded builder, Francesco di Giorgio, used him to discuss materials as they might actually behave in real structures.
The philologist Ermalao Barbaro's thorough and highly critical study of Pliny's text, carried out in the 1480s, included the architectural sections. The rich tradition of sixteenth-century Vitruvian studies and commentaries, including those by Giovanni Giocondo, Raphael, Cesare Cesariano, Palladio and Daniele Barbaro all utilised the Naturalis historia. The ancient text provided a portrait of an idealised and lost ancient architecture, including the Mausoleum at Halicarnassus. It functioned as an authority on architecture not discussed by Vitruvius, and as a springboard for the discussion of columns. Taking after his uncle, Ermalao, Daniele Barbaro treated Pliny with sober criticism, while Palladio in his own treatise silently adopted Plinian motifs into his architecture and discussed them without mentioning his name.
The first from Italy to examine Pliny's foreign architectural marvels (or their supposed remains) was Ciriaco d'Ancona during his travels of the 1430s and 40s. Ciriaco carried Pliny with him on trips to the eastern Mediterranean, searching for and identifying (sometimes incorrectly) ancient ruins described in the Naturalis historia.
Studies of material from the Plinian text appeared in numerous drawings. In his Madrid Codex I, Leonardo da Vinci provided a solution to the problem of how the double theatre of Curio described by Pliny might have moved, long a matter of discussion among readers of Pliny. Notable also are the various drawn studies of the Sangallo clan, particularly Antonio da Sangallo the Younger, on structures described by Pliny, especially the Mausoleum at Halicarnassus. Actual structures were also built under the influence of Pliny's descriptions, especially monumental tombs. In the sixteenth century, studies of Pliny in all forms — textual discussion, drawings and built structures — are often intertwined with the study of Vitruvius’ De architectura, which eventually became paramount as the more authoritative text.
Pliny sometimes seems ubiquitous in Renaissance texts of various kinds, from natural history to art and architecture. As a result, modern scholarship in these areas often mentions the Naturalis historia, but without seriously analysing its influence. The study of F.-S., along with other recent studies such as Sarah Blake McHam's Pliny and the Artistic Culture of the Italian Renaissance (2013), goes far in remedying this lack of serious analysis. F.-S.’s thorough, workmanlike study, which at times seems to acquire the encyclopedic quality of its focus, is nevertheless an important contribution which will remain foundational for years to come. Pliny has finally taken his place beside Vitruvius as an essential influence to be reckoned with in the study of Renaissance architecture.
