No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 10 February 2005
The Tribute of Blood has already earned an audience among historians of nineteenth and twentieth-century Brazil, who have found in Peter M. Beattie's analysis of military recruitment and enlisted service an innovative and often compelling exploration of a neglected facet of Brazilian history. But the book deserves a wider audience, not least because of Beattie's stated ambition of providing the first book-length study, “that explicitly focuses on impressment and conscription as transatlantic tribute labor systems intricately linked to other labor practices and relations in broader society” (14). Prospective members of such an audience not only stand to learn a great deal about Brazil (indeed, the novice might read The Tribute of Blood as an introduction to the socio-cultural history of Brazil during a “long nineteenth century” of its own). They also might be forced to rethink some of their own assumptions regarding military service in particular and institutional modernization more generally, and draw inspiration from Beattie's impressive command of a wide range of Brazilian sources and his willingness to extend comparisons to and borrow approaches from fields situated at some remove—geographic and otherwise—from his own.
The Tribute of Blood has already earned an audience among historians of nineteenth and twentieth-century Brazil, who have found in Peter M. Beattie's analysis of military recruitment and enlisted service an innovative and often compelling exploration of a neglected facet of Brazilian history. But the book deserves a wider audience, not least because of Beattie's stated ambition of providing the first book-length study, “that explicitly focuses on impressment and conscription as transatlantic tribute labor systems intricately linked to other labor practices and relations in broader society” (14). Prospective members of such an audience not only stand to learn a great deal about Brazil (indeed, the novice might read The Tribute of Blood as an introduction to the socio-cultural history of Brazil during a “long nineteenth century” of its own). They also might be forced to rethink some of their own assumptions regarding military service in particular and institutional modernization more generally, and draw inspiration from Beattie's impressive command of a wide range of Brazilian sources and his willingness to extend comparisons to and borrow approaches from fields situated at some remove—geographic and otherwise—from his own.
Briefly, The Tribute of Blood can be described as a history of the institutional reform of enlisted military service in Brazil. Between the middle of the nineteenth century and the first decades of the twentieth century, the Brazilian Army gradually adopted a system of conscription in order to fill its ranks, ending a longstanding reliance on impressment that had its roots in Portuguese imperial practices. While the distinction between impressment and conscription may seem slight or even meaningless to those unfamiliar with either process, Beattie correctly distinguishes between the two: impressment is “coercive recruitment performed by police or press gangs [who] most often targeted men without property, including vagrants and lawbreakers,” while conscription is the “enrollment of mostly law-abiding ( . . . ) youths from which recruits would be selected for service on the basis of a lottery” (xxi). The transition from impressment to conscription in Brazil demanded and, in turn, fed off of larger changes in the treatment of enlisted men and in the ways enlisted service was depicted and understood. The status of the enlisted man (the praça) had to be improved and the barracks had to be made an honorable social space, akin to the “house,” rather than a dishonorable and potentially dangerous place associated with the “street.” Along the way, the army had to withdraw from its role as Brazil's primary penal institution (as an auxiliary to local law enforcement institutions, as a jailor responsible for the oversight of civilian convicts, and, most importantly, as the primary institutional reservoir for vagrants, non-homicidal criminal offenders, abandoned boys, and other undesirables), while debates over the proper way to fill the enlisted ranks fed into larger, anxiety-ridden discussions of the Brazilian nation, its racially mixed population, and the latter's relationship with the state.
As even this brief description makes clear, Beattie draws upon a range of concepts and approaches in framing the history of enlisted service and military recruitment in Brazil. The idea of a cultural dialectic between the safe, orderly, and honorable “house” and its opposite, the “street,” explored masterfully by anthropologist Roberto DaMatta, is chief among the Brazilian borrowings that figure in The Tribute of Blood (and, as both DaMatta and Beattie have indicated, it is one that can be extended to similarly patrimonial societies across the globe). At the same time, Beattie shows himself to be conversant with various aspects of the English-language historiography on military service the world over, which allows him to extend comparisons as far afield as Russia, Germany, and Japan, putting the lie to the durable assumption, here quoted from Barrington Moore, that the “political problems” of countries like Brazil “are not really comparable to those of larger countries” (although one would of course hasten to add scare quotes around the word “larger” when making comparisons between Brazil and even the largest of European nation-states). Beattie also seeks to contribute to more general discussions of institutional modernization, suggesting, for example, that historians of other societies undertake similar studies of “the sequencing and depth of institutional reform” and thus make possible “a more rigorous comparative history of State building” (151). (See also 14, 267, 270, 272, 284).
International connections are important for Beattie's work in other respects as well. Indeed, such connections are crucial, as nearly all of the reforms that he discusses were of foreign provenance: they did not emerge in response to local needs, (in fact, in the case of the Brazilian Army's withdrawal from its role as a penal institution, military reformers turned their backs on local needs); rather they were inspired from abroad. Seen in this light, one Brazilian officer's declaration that developments in Europe were “eloquently demonstrating to us what the destiny of weak peoples will be” (225) can be read as a self-fulfilling prophecy, albeit one laden with unintended irony.
This point tempts one to draw a further conclusion from The Tribute of Blood. The degree to which conscription came to Brazil as the result of international vogue illustrates the need to privilege cultural factors (and I include all manner of intellectual inspiration under the rubric of the “cultural”) vis-à-vis the political (in the sense of international power politics) and the socioeconomic (including both global and regional political economy) in writing the history of sociopolitical arrangements throughout what one might call, to add still another euphemism to an already crowded field, the “under-dominant world.” A lingering attachment to a more narrowly materialistic view of history may have prevented Beattie from making this point more emphatically (the project from which this book emerged was, after all, originally conceived as a “social history of common Brazilian soldiers” [xv]). But the point remains: the cultural orientation of Brazilian elites, more than any other single factor, determined that Brazil would ultimately adopt conscription (although one cannot add quickly enough, as Beattie would, that the shape and timing of the resulting system owed a great deal to the often-fractious actions and understandings of ordinary men and women of all socioeconomic classes).
The Tribute of Blood is not without its faults. Brazil specialists are sure to take issue with some of Beattie's interpretations and certain readers may choose to pick over other infelicities. But the Brazil specialist might also recognize something interesting—perhaps even something characteristically Brazilian—in Beattie's cannibalistic assimilation of techniques, traditions, and approaches from Brazil, the United States, and elsewhere. It is this borrowing from some of the best of what is around in order to make something new, that should prove of great and lasting interest to the specialist and non-specialist alike.