Black Protestants, Matthew Harper argues in The End of Days, interpreted their experiences in the postemancipation South through the lens of narrative theology, an approach articulated in the late twentieth century by mostly white scholars such as Stanley Hauerwas. As Harper puts it, this meant that they explained God's work in the world and made ethical choices through “identification with biblical stories, as opposed to constructing a systematic theology of carefully arranged, internally consistent propositional statements” (160). Even though the black male leaders who make up the bulk of Harper's informants would not have known what to make of the anachronistic concept of narrative theology, he makes a convincing case that they nonetheless practiced it. At times, black Protestants read their triumphs and travails into specific biblical stories in typological fashion. At other times, however, they pointed not to one specific narrative but to the broader sweep of divine history—and particularly to its “end,” or eschaton. “Emancipation was the key moment in black Protestants’ eschatology,” Harper suggests; “there they viewed most clearly evidence that a realm of divine justice could descend upon a realm of earthly injustice” (4). Convinced by the miracle of emancipation that God was both actively involved in human events and on their side, black Protestants confronted the turbulent events of the late nineteenth century with unusual resilience.
Harper sets his story in North Carolina, where thriving black religious institutions left a rich documentary record. While he addresses the intersection of religion and politics, it is at the level of the history of ideas rather than of specific institutions, individuals, or policies—so he, therefore, found special value in the sermons, circulars, editorials, and published addresses black Protestant leaders penned in order to shape public opinion. In this regard, the long run of the African Methodist Episcopal Zion newspaper, The Star of Zion, published continuously since 1876, proved especially useful. The Old North State served the book's rhetorical purposes well, for in it dramatic events unfolded that highlighted transformations that occurred more gradually or subtly in other states, most notably the Kirk-Holden War and the Wilmington Massacre. Harper shows how black Protestant leaders explained the divine significance of these and other political developments, re-creating a worldview in which God's sovereign action was the most important storyline.
In the incidents he covers, Harper succeeds admirably in showing how certain black leaders mapped political questions onto religious narratives, though the ubiquity of religious language sometimes makes it difficult to tell what difference it made. When black North Carolinians debated how aggressively to pursue full citizenship at an 1865 Freedmen's Convention, for instance, both moderates and radicals interpreted emancipation as a sign of God's decisive intervention on behalf of black Southerners. “For some, the certainty of victory released them from a sense of urgency and commended a slower, more deferential path of reforms,” Harper explained. “For others, the dramatic intervention of God in emancipation had begun a new era where moderation and gradualism were no longer necessary” (40). Again black Protestants placed God on both sides of the debate running from the late 1870s through the early 1890s about emigration, though the biblical tropes involved were more specific and concrete. Emigration supporters argued that God would provide access to land by leading them out of oppression (Exodus), while those who preferred to stay and fight for rights in North Carolina insisted that God would soon end that state's unjust practices and provide the opportunity for blacks to purchase land (Jubilee). Black Southerners again followed similar theological assumptions to different prudential decisions about what to do in a difficult situation.
In other situations, Harper demonstrates that black, Southern Protestants’ theological convictions shaped their political strategies. This is especially the case in his fresh reading of the “Esther circular,” in which seventeen black legislators in 1870 called for prayer and fasting as a strategy to prevent Republican Governor William Holden's impeachment. Rather than read past the religious references, as most scholars have done, Harper explores what it meant for black Protestants to analogize their situation to that of Jews in Persia. Drawing from well-known parts of the biblical account that are uncited in the circular, he reads the document not as a desperate call to prayer with all other options having failed, but as a veiled threat: “if conservative Democrats continued to use violence to disfranchise African Americans, then the state's black population had the right of armed self-defense, or at least the military protection of others” (58).
On a larger level, Harper more provocatively suggests that black Protestants’ narrative theology made them resilient in the face of repeated setbacks. Instead of a long decline from the euphoria of emancipation to the nadir of Jim Crow, lynching, and disfranchisement in the 1890s, Harper sees persistent optimism grounded in an emancipation-proven narrative of divine favor. None of the painful disappointments of the postwar period—redemption, oppressive land laws, the failure of prohibition, segregation, disfranchisement, lynching, or even the crushing coup d’état in Wilmington—could extinguish black Protestants’ confidence that suffering represented only a temporary setback. In the most daring formulation of this thesis, Harper writes, “For most black Protestant leaders in North Carolina, the turn of the twentieth century was no nadir, only a bump—albeit a sizeable one—on the road to a great preordained destiny. … in the millennial worldview of black Protestant leaders, the reality of emancipation always overshadowed and outweighed the reality of Jim Crow” (131–32). He then contrasts black Southerners’ resilience with the theological crisis white Protestants faced after the horrific events of World Wars I and II, when many of them retreated from the faith or turned to more pessimistic (premillennial) theological positions.
In an interesting irony, the narrative that frame historians place upon the events Harper describes will likely condition their response to his arguments. Many emphasizing the sordid and ongoing nature of white supremacy will see self-delusion and quiescence instead of resilience. Others anticipating the “stone of hope” on which black Americans built the redemptive civil rights movement will see the lineage of that stone more clearly. Regardless of what scholars think, however, Harper has helped resuscitate “black Protestants’ own view of history,” which is a valuable contribution in itself (156).
