Shakespeare's most innovative genre was the history play, because it has no precedent in either classical or medieval tradition. To be sure, the great biblical cycles, extant from northern and eastern England, stage a version of salvation history from Creation to Last Judgment, but no playwright had previously adapted narrative chronicle history to drama in sequential plays that treat a broad segment of England's past.Footnote 1 In making this adaptation, Shakespeare's history plays manifest an implicit idea of history, or at least of history as it played out in a political system headed by a monarch. Secular, political, and open-ended, this idea was a very different idea from the focused teleology of sacred history. Events in the history plays are chosen and implicitly interpreted not by their relationship to God, as in the scriptural cycles, but by fallible human decisions and actions in time. “I wasted time, and now doth time waste me,” observes Shakespeare's Richard II incisively.Footnote 2 Shakespeare directs more attention to time in his history plays than to history, but time and history are inextricably linked, so what his characters say about time implies a great deal about how the plays interpret history.
Richard II's comment about wasting time is appropriate, because Richard II is Shakespeare's most revealing play concerning time and history. Early in the play, the King's uncle, the Duke of York, urges his nephew not to seize the Duchy of Lancaster after the death of the presiding Duke, because doing so would disinherit the King's powerful cousin, Henry Bolingbroke, presently Duke of Hereford and next in line for Lancaster. Though York spells out the commonplaces of legitimate inheritance, his personification emphasizes time, as if succession were an afterthought:
Take Hereford's rights away, and take from Time
His charters and his customary rights;
Let not tomorrow then ensue today;
Be not thyself; for how art thou a king
But by fair sequence and succession?
(2.1.195–99)“Fair sequence and succession” occurs in time, York points out, and Richard's actions therefore strike at the base of his own inheritance by violating time. The conjunction of time and royal succession fits a pattern in the history plays of thematic references to time, which is the matrix of political power, because the powerful act in time—not just to secure an inheritance but also to seize opportunity and to gain political ends.
The centrality of royal succession as a problem in all of Shakespeare's history plays is a complement to contemporary events. He wrote all but one of the history plays in the 1590s, late in the reign of Elizabeth I (1558–1603), who was single, childless, and rapidly aging, and no one knew who would follow her on the throne. In short, her time was running out, and the future felt perilous. She did not name her successor until she was dying, creating uncertainty throughout the nation and intensifying rivalrous jostling at court.Footnote 3 She herself had ascended the throne under dubious and challenging circumstances concerning the succession. Her half brother, Edward, had inherited the throne in 1547 at the age of nine years, despite having two older sisters, because primogeniture strongly favored male succession. The son of a Protestant queen, Jane Seymour, Edward was also a Protestant, and while he was king his advisors took measures to solidify and extend religious reforms introduced late in the reign of his father, Henry VIII. When Edward died unexpectedly in 1553, he was succeeded by his older sister Mary, who did not regard reform as a priority. On the contrary, as a faithful Catholic, Mary tried to undo as much as she could that her father and brother had initiated, but she herself died after a reign of only five years. Her younger sister, Elizabeth, therefore succeeded unexpectedly at the age of twenty-five, and as another Protestant monarch, she determined to reintroduce the reforms of Henry and Edward.
Many people alive in the 1590s could remember the tumultuous sequence of four Tudor monarchs in eleven years at midcentury, especially given the religious tension that accompanied three rapid successions, and those years were common knowledge, even among those who did not remember them. With a childless queen at an advanced age, it was impossible in the 1590s not to be concerned about what might follow her death. To be sure, Shakespeare never depicted events concerning the Tudor succession. The closest he came was Henry VIII, which concludes with a prophetic announcement of a prosperous reign for Henry's newborn daughter, Elizabeth. Still, in Queen Elizabeth's last decade, Shakespeare chose repeatedly to write plays about problematic succession in earlier reigns.
Moreover, Shakespeare's emphasis on the problem of royal succession followed an independent line of political thinking. Tudor political theorists were consistently moralistic and authoritarian, insisting on the necessity for citizens to obey every duly constituted authority, from the local magistrate to the monarch. More important, Shakespeare's implicit analysis of monarchy's principal weakness sets him apart from Machiavelli, the most influential and provocative political thinker of his day. For Machiavelli, the problem of succession is of little or no concern. He acknowledges in passing that hereditary power gives a ruler an advantage (The Prince, chaps. 2 and 19), thereby characteristically subordinating legitimacy to pragmatism, as do Shakespeare's political competitors. But the point about the advantage of heredity is not one of Machiavelli's keener political insights, and while he recognizes that hereditary rulers can govern badly, he never focuses on the transition of monarchical power as a problem in itself, as Shakespeare does in all his history plays.
Like Elizabeth I, four of the kings about whom Shakespeare wrote were childless when they died: Henry VI, Richard III, John, and Richard II (to list them in the order Shakespeare wrote about them). Only Henry IV, Henry V, and Henry VIII left successors, and of the three, Henry V sired a son who was the least fortunate, not only because Henry VI died with no heir but also because he was weak and indecisive, as Shakespeare emphasizes in the Epilogue to Henry V:
Henry the Sixth, in infant bands crowned King
Of France and England, did this king succeed;
Whose state so many had the managing,
That they lost France and made his England bleed,
Which oft our stage hath shown; and, for their sake,
In your fair minds let this acceptance take.
(1–6)“Which oft our stage hath shown” is a rare reference by Shakespeare to his own work, alluding to his first history plays, about the reign of Henry VI.
That reign followed one of the most heroic and successful in English history—at least from the English point of view, because Henry V's principal accomplishment was the conquest of France. No matter how triumphantly Henry reigned, however, he ruled for only nine years, and he died when his son was an infant. Managing the state of Henry VI was therefore necessary from the time he inherited the throne. Shakespeare acknowledges this point implicitly in 1 Henry VI by keeping the king out of the play entirely until the third act. In his first speech, he refers to his “tender years” (1 Henry VI, 3.1.71), and he tries fruitlessly to reconcile his quarreling uncles, Humphrey Duke of Gloucester and Henry Bishop of Winchester, who are the real powers in the kingdom. Later, in a direct confrontation with enemies about the succession, Henry admits to himself, “I know not what to say; my title's weak” (3 Henry VI, 1.1.134).Footnote 4
As Shakespeare scripted events, succession to Henry VI begins ominously with the arrangement for the King's marriage to Margaret of Anjou. The Earl of Suffolk seizes her as a prisoner when he is fighting in France. He is not interested in ransoming her, recognizing that her father, though titled, is poor (5.3.95); rather, he salaciously anticipates a lustful future with her, based on her pleasing appearance, though he is married already (81). He therefore persuades the English court that she should become consort to the King, an outcome that produces his ominous gloating in the play's closing lines: “Margaret shall now be Queen and rule the King; / But I will rule both her, the King, and realm” (5.5.107–8). She reciprocates Suffolk's interest in her, happily accepting the power and prestige of becoming Queen of England while remaining Suffolk's mistress. In 2 Henry VI, Suffolk's death at the hands of pirates puts an end to his affair with the Queen, and in 3 Henry VI, Margaret bears Henry an heir, called Edward, thereby assuring the succession.
But time does not permit. In 3 Henry VI, three brothers from the house of York, having taken up arms against Henry because of his weakness and ineptitude, defeat him and Margaret at the battle of Tewkesbury and stab young Edward viciously to death before killing Henry himself. The succession thus shifts violently from Lancaster, Henry's clan, to York, and the oldest of the three brothers ascends the throne as Edward IV, with two healthy sons. The Yorkist succession soon fails as well, however, in Richard III, when Edward's ambitious younger brother Richard secretly arranges for the murder of his nephews in order to become king himself.Footnote 5 Trying to enhance his political standing, Richard boldly woos Anne, the young widow of the Lancastrian Prince Edward, whom Richard himself had stabbed to death at Tewkesbury. “What though I killed her husband and her father?” he says to himself with unrivaled insouciance, before accosting her (Richard III, 1.1.154). With his marriage and accession to the throne, Richard's luck ends, along with the Yorkist succession: Richard and Anne conceive no heir, and she dies before he is killed at the battle of Bosworth.
Shakespeare's attention to Richard's story in particular had a direct bearing on the problem of the royal succession in the 1590s. Richard had been defeated and killed in 1485 by Henry Tudor, whom Shakespeare identifies in Richard III simply as the Earl of Richmond. He was a Welsh nobleman, with a distant claim to the throne but an uncontestable de facto right to it because he had successfully defeated the reigning king.Footnote 6 More than a hundred years later, Henry's granddaughter, Elizabeth (named for her paternal grandmother), was on the throne when Shakespeare wrote Richard III, and the playwright not surprisingly emphasized Henry's piety and hope for the future in the speech he gives to Richmond, celebrating his victory over the last Plantagenet king:
Oh, now let Richmond and Elizabeth,
The true succeeders of each royal house,
By God's fair ordinance conjoin together!
And let their heirs, God, if thy will be so,
Enrich the time to come with smooth-faced peace,
With smiling plenty, and fair prosperous days!
(5.5.29–34)The sequence of plays about Henry VI and Richard III was Shakespeare's closest flirtation with contemporary events until much later, several years after the death of Elizabeth I, when he wrote Henry VIII. When he first turned to English history again after Richard III, he wrote about the early thirteenth century, in King John, and then about the late fourteenth century, in Richard II. Both of those earlier reigns, however, were just as fraught with problems concerning the royal succession as Shakespeare's plays about Henry VI and Richard III. From the beginning of King John, the English king is under intense pressure to accede to the claim of young Arthur, son of his older brother Geoffrey. The pressure is applied in part by Philip II of France, whose ambassador to England, Chatillon, states Arthur's claim in the play's first scene:
Philip of France, in right and true behalf
Of thy deceasèd brother Geoffrey's son,
Arthur Plantagenet, lays most lawful claim
To this fair island…
… … … … … … … …
Desiring thee to lay aside the sword
Which sways usurpingly these several titles,
And put the same into young Arthur's hand,
Thy nephew and right royal sovereign.
(1.1.8–15)Philip's support for Arthur is markedly self-interested: his “lawful claim / To this fair island” is as much for himself as it is for Arthur, the claimant he ostensibly champions. Arthur's claim is technically superior to John's, as Philip argues, but John is de facto king, and John's son Henry ascends the throne at the end of the play, after Arthur's untimely death, when he leaps from the wall of a castle in trying to escape. The royal succession is an open question throughout the play, and it is decided arbitrarily by the course of events.
John's lineal descendants eventually included Richard II, who inherited the throne without challenge from his grandfather Edward III, because Richard's heroic father, Edward the Black Prince, had died in the meantime. Richard began his reign with the problem that he inherited power when he was just ten years old, having lost his father only a year before. Shakespeare begins the story in Richard's young adulthood, with the King still facing competition from powerful uncles who had presided when his minority succession created a vacuum of power. Richard prefers dandified companions, regarded by his elders as mere flatterers. As his uncle York puts it, rather than listening to sage counsel, the King's ear “is stopped with other, flattering sounds” (2.1.17). One of a trio of Richard's friends, a knight called simply Green by Shakespeare, is the first to urge that Richard should invade Ireland (1.4.38). This turns out to be flattery with a fatal twist, because the King leaves his kingdom with his army while his rival, Henry Bolingbroke, lies offshore, waiting for an opportunity to invade and make good his claim to the throne as the successor to Richard's uncle, John of Gaunt (2.1.285–90). Richard rushes back from Ireland to meet the challenge, but again time does not permit. By necessity, Richard returns without his army, and he is too late to prevent the desertion of Welsh allies (2.4; 3.2.64–74). “One day too late, I fear me, noble lord,” laments Salisbury, “Hath clouded all thy happy days on earth” (3.2.67–68). Though Richard is the play's most eloquent and outspoken character, he is defeated by his inability to move in timely fashion in the chess match of power relations. Bolingbroke brilliantly outmaneuvers the King, putting him in a position where he has no power to defend himself, as he acknowledges in a witty though petulant riff on “must” as a defining limiter of royal prerogative:
What must the King do now? Must he submit?
The King shall do it. Must he be deposed?
The King shall be contented. Must he lose
The name of King? I’ God's name, let it go.
(3.3.142–46)Richard's poetry is Shakespeare's invention, and it eloquently sums up the issues that result in Henry IV's succession to Richard II. Yet Henry's forcing Richard to abdicate inevitably breeds resentment and bitterness among Richard's sympathizers, burdening the transition of power with potential trouble for the new king.
That trouble arrives in 1 Henry IV with Shakespeare's most brilliant treatment of succession in all his plays. For the first time, he shifts attention from rivalry for the throne itself to a contest between the heir apparent and an ambitious age-mate, Henry Percy, a nobleman who shares the Prince's Christian name, and who identifies his pushy campaign as an attempt to right the wrong done to Richard II, “that sweet lovely rose,” as Percy calls him (1 Henry IV, 1.3.175). Each of the young competitors is referred to by a distinguishing nickname: “Hal” for the Prince and “Hotspur” for Percy Earl of Northumberland. By focusing on this rivalry, Shakespeare directs attention to the issue of the successor's fitness for royal office, as King Henry emphasizes in a regretful comparison of Percy to the heir apparent:
Yea, there thou mak'st me sad and mak'st me sin
In envy that my Lord Northumberland
Should be the father to so blest a son—
A son who is the theme of honor's tongue,
Amongst a grove, the very straightest plant,
Who is sweet Fortune's minion and her pride,
Whilst I, by looking on the praise of him,
See riot and dishonor stain the brow
Of my young Harry.
(1 Henry IV, 1.1.77–85)The King has a standard of honor in mind for his successor that the Prince conspicuously fails to meet, in his father's opinion.
In a striking contrast to Richard II, in 1 Henry IV Shakespeare divides attention between the royal court and an equally important gathering place, at least for common folk—the tavern.Footnote 7 This is where we first meet the Prince, as if to confirm his father's complaint that Hal is stained by “riot and dishonor.” But the Prince soon informs us that he is not what he appears to be. Though he never mentions Machiavelli, Hal has thoroughly absorbed Machiavelli's principle that appearances are substance when it comes to successful rule.Footnote 8 In the only soliloquy Shakespeare wrote for him, the Prince dismisses “the unyoked humor” of his tavern companions and tellingly compares himself to the sun,
Who doth permit the base contagious clouds
To smother up his beauty from the world,
That when he please again to be himself,
Being wanted, he may be more wondered at,
By breaking through the foul and ugly mists
Of vapors that did seem to strangle him.
(1.2.192–97)He is as self-assured as Richard III and as eloquent as Richard II, outlining a bold strategy for winning by appearing to lose: “By how much better than my word I am / By so much shall I falsify men's hopes” (204–5). Following his father's example of using time effectively, the Prince plans to wait strategically, so that when he eventually reveals his true brilliance and political skill, his pretense to have been a time waster and a tavern haunter will amaze everyone more than if he had conducted himself soberly as the true heir to the throne all along: “I'll so offend to make offense a skill, / Redeeming time when men least think I will” (210–11). No other successor to royal power in a play by Shakespeare pursues such an elaborate and careful strategy for using time, and no other political strategy in Shakespeare suggests the real Machiavelli more strongly than Hal's.
His act is so convincing that his father is completely taken in by it. In a tense confrontation at court, the King scolds his son worriedly, caricaturing his predecessor bitterly in order to compare Prince Henry to him (3.2.60–73). The burden of this rebuke is that Richard was too familiar with commoners, though Shakespeare's play offers no evidence to support this charge;Footnote 9 the King aims it, rather, at the Prince and his known reputation for favoring the tavern over the court. Richard was a “skipping King,” who indulged “shallow jesters” and firecracker wits, “soon kindled and soon burnt.” He “mingled his royalty with capering fools, / Had his great name profanèd with their scorns.” The King acknowledges that courting popular opinion may be sweet, but
being daily swallowed by men's eyes,
They surfeited with honey and began
To loathe the taste of sweetness, whereof a little
More than a little is by much too much.
(70–73)The implication is clear: Hal's undignified camaraderie with social outsiders will make him so familiar to common folk that they will not take him seriously when he succeeds his father on the throne, and he will therefore not be able to govern effectively.
Hal's thinking about the succession is just the reverse of his father's, and in the long run Hal's thinking is vindicated.Footnote 10 In an unguarded moment with Ned Poins, a commoner he has befriended in the tavern, the Prince lets slip the key point of his strategic waiting: “when I am King of England I shall command all the good lads in Eastcheap” (1 Henry IV, 2.4.13–14). His description of how “three or four loggerheads” will address him familiarly as “the king of courtesy… a Corinthian, a lad of mettle, a good boy” would disgust Henry IV, but the future Henry V regards the familiarity of commoners as a political asset. They will be loyal to him when he needs their loyalty—an important point for a king who inherited the throne only because his father had seized it. With the same concern about the succession in mind, the dying Henry IV advises his son, “Be it thy course to busy giddy minds / With foreign quarrels, that action, hence born out, / May waste the memory of the former days” (2 Henry IV, 4.5.212–14). When Hal becomes king, he admonishes the Archbishop of Canterbury to justify a military campaign in France (Henry V, 1.2.9–32), but Shakespeare has convincingly shown Henry V's real motivation for a foreign campaign, namely, the shoring up of his own kingship. In contrast to Richard II, who took his army with him to Ireland, Henry V is advised to leave three quarters of his military force at home when he invades France (1.2.213–16). Judging from his emphasis on “we few, we happy few, we band of brothers” at the battle of Agincourt (4.3.60), he seems to have taken the advice. With a decisive defeat of the French at Agincourt, Henry wins more than a resounding military victory overseas; he wins the security of his throne and unquestioned right to the succession for himself and his heirs.
In short, Henry V redeems time effectively, as he promises to do in his soliloquy; in fact, he uses time more effectively than any other Shakespearean king: planning strategically for his succession, arresting three plotters against him to maximum political advantage, invading France before serious opposition has a chance to develop at home, directing attention from domestic to foreign affairs with his French campaign and purposefully leaving the vast majority of his army in England when he embarks on his overseas adventure. Hal speaks less about time than Richard II does, but Hal practices brilliantly what Richard theorizes. The culmination of Richard's references to time is his meditation in Pomfret Castle, just before he is killed. His thinking is prompted by the failure of a musician he overhears, who is unable to maintain a regular beat: “Ha, ha, keep time! How sour sweet music is, / When time is broke and no proportion kept!” (5.5.42–43). Richard characteristically thinks of himself as soon as he hears the music, realizing that he too has failed to “keep time” and pronouncing his gnomic insight about his wasting time that now wastes him. Impressed by his own aphorism, he imagines himself in an elaborate metaphor as a clock, with a despairing conclusion: “But my time / Runs posting on in Bolingbroke's proud joy, / While I stand fooling here, his jack of the clock” (58–60).
Richard perceives the erosion of his power as a misuse of time, but the idea is not his alone. He had started the play in full control of time, ordering varying times of banishment for Mowbray and Bolingbroke, and eliciting Bolingbroke's admiration of his power: “How long a time lies in one little word! … / such is the breath of kings” (1.3.213–15). Shakespeare oddly telescopes time in Richard II, 2.1, in such a way as to suggest that the initiative has shifted decisively to Bolingbroke, for in the same scene in which we see Gaunt die and Richard seize Lancaster's estates, Northumberland reports that Bolingbroke has already started back from France with an invasion force (2.1.277–88). Though Bolingbroke repeatedly insists that he returns only to reclaim his dukedom, Shakespeare's treatment of time in 2.1 suggests that Bolingbroke had planned the invasion long before Richard seized his lands, especially in view of the detail that he is waiting to disembark only because Richard has not yet departed for Ireland (2.1.290). These are strong indications that Bolingbroke seizes the initiative by taking advantage of Richard's mistakes, including the mistake of expropriating Bolingbroke's estate, because Bolingbroke uses the loss to rationalize an invasion he had put into execution long before Richard violated Lancaster's hereditary right. Using time well is the key to power, in other words, and maintaining power is ultimately more important than legitimacy as the key to the succession.
Though the conception of time and political action in Richard II is thoroughly secular, it is not in Machiavelli, and it too appears to be original with Shakespeare as a political thinker. Shakespeare links timely action and political success by way of contrast in the Queen's confrontation with York's gardeners (3.4).Footnote 11 They speak, in effect, for the playwright, expanding on the play's idea of time and political action by describing it allegorically in relation to their gardening. “All must be even in our government,” admonishes the gardener, ordering his assistant to “Cut off the heads of too-fast-growing sprays / That look too lofty in our commonwealth” (34–36). The gardener's man wonders, in response, why they must maintain their garden, when “our sea-wallèd garden, the whole land, / Is full of weeds,” because its caretaker is less hardworking and effective than the gardeners (43–44). The allegory is obvious, but in case anyone misses the parallel, the gardener spells it out: it is too bad that “the wasteful King” “had not so trimmed and dressed his land / As we this garden” (55–57), using terms that anticipate Richard's own belated recognition about how he had wasted time. At this point in the gardeners' conversation, the Queen, having overheard them, confronts them angrily, berating them, addressing the gardener as “old Adam's likeness, / Set to dress this garden” (3.4.72–73), and demanding to know “What Eve, what serpent, hath suggested thee / To make a second fall of cursèd man” in their report that Richard has been deposed (75–76). Her injection of the biblical analogy is a startling contrast to the gardeners' secular allegory, but they are closer to the truth than she is, in that Richard as a politician was no innocent in a timeless Eden; he was an ineffective player, who misused power and time to his own disadvantage, as mere commoners tending a garden have just recognized in their conversation with each other.
No one seems to learn more ably from Richard's failure than Henry IV's son, who begins his career in Shakespeare's account by promising to redeem time in securing his succession. Though spoken only to the audience, this promise has a context. In effect, it is the Prince's answer to Falstaff's opening inquiry in the same scene, “Now, Hal, what time of day is it, lad?” (1.2.1), and Hal's answer to Falstaff's question strongly hints at the “redemption” he promises at the end of the scene, for he asks Falstaff rhetorically, “What a devil hast thou to do with the time of the day?” (5–6), and adds for emphasis, “I see no reason why thou shouldst be so superfluous to demand the time of the day” (10–12). Careful attention to comments like these makes clear that Hal's decisive rejection of Falstaff at the end of 2 Henry IV should be no surprise. Falstaff lives in a timeless world of endless revelry—a world from which he cannot be removed psychologically, even when he is removed physically, as the Prince discovers when he asks to borrow Falstaff's pistol at the battle of Shrewsbury and finds in the holster a bottle of sack instead of a weapon. “What, is it a time to jest and dally now?” Hal demands, with every indication that he does not find the situation comical: “He throws the bottle at him” (1 Henry IV, 5.3.55, 55 s.d.).
Hal's competition with Hotspur in 1 Henry IV has long been admired for the way it shows Shakespeare's use of a “foil” character (1.3.209), as the playwright adjusts the two men's historical ages to make them equivalent and emphasizes their competition for honor. Close attention to what Hal says, however, reveals that he cares as much about time in this competition as he does about honor, suggesting that he sees honor as acquirable only through the advantageous use of time. As Hal rejects his father's comparison of him to Richard II, Hal vows to defeat Hotspur, “this same child of honor and renown” (3.2.139):
I will call him to so strict account
That he shall render every glory up,
Yea, even the slightest worship of his time,
Or I will tear the reckoning from his heart.
(3.2.149–52)Hal's mention of time is unexpected but revealing; “honor” would be the expected point of contention, in parallel to “glory.”
The Prince's emphasis on time makes sense in light of the way he sees both Falstaff and Hotspur, neither of whom is able to use time effectively the way Hal does. Falstaff cares nothing for it (“What a devil hast thou to do with the time of the day?”) and Hotspur wastes it in wrongheaded and ineffective political action, as Richard II does. The Prince uses a mercantile metaphor in describing Hotspur to Henry IV: “Percy is but my factor, good my lord, / To engross up glorious deeds on my behalf” (147–48). In describing the same strategy later to Hotspur himself, however, Hal uses the gardening imagery of Richard II, making clear the importance of time in his strategy: “And all the budding honors on thy crest / I'll crop to make a garland for my head” (5.4.72–73). In effect, Hal “farms” Hotspur, hoping to profit from the harvest of honor and renown that he will reap as a consequence. Hal's strategy works in the long run, making him the most politically successful of all Shakespeare's kings: he uses time to his advantage in securing his patrimony and his power, and he complements timely action with rhetoric that rivals Richard II's in establishing royal charisma for himself. At the end of Henry V, moreover, when the Chorus describes the King's success as limited, the limitations are those of time: the “small time” Henry V lived (Henry V, Ep. 5) meant that his son was “in infant bands crowned King” (9), and the allusion to the Henry VI plays that we noticed earlier indicates that the crisis of succession started all over again, “which oft our stage hath shown” (13). Even the greatest and most successful king is subject to the same limitation that Hotspur recognizes as he is dying at Hal's hands: “time, that takes survey of all the world, / Must have a stop” (1 Henry IV, 5.4.82–83). Henry V's own untimely death makes his play emphatically open-ended, because the struggle goes on without him, dominated by the continuum of time that he sought, above all things, to control, but that goes on without him in the end.
Though the mechanical clock was a medieval invention, time was a discovery of the Renaissance, as Ricardo Quinones argues, and Shakespeare's sense of time as the critical element in royal succession, as in political decision-making, seems not only to be original with him but also amounts to still another point of distinction between his political thinking and that of Machiavelli.Footnote 12 To be sure, one can find an occasional passage in Machiavelli that mentions the importance of time in terms similar to those that can be inferred from Shakespeare's history plays. In Discourses 1.32, for example, Machiavelli emphasizes the need for planning, which requires a calculating awareness of the future in relation to the present:
Whoever is in power, therefore, whether a civil government or a prince, should consider beforehand what sorts of adverse times are likely to come upon him and what men he may need in times of trouble, and then treat them in just the way he thinks he would need to treat them in an emergency of any kind. He who conducts himself otherwise, whether prince or civil government—but especially a prince—and then believes that when the peril is on him he can in a moment regain men with benefits, deceives himself, because he not merely does not make sure of them but even hastens his own ruin.Footnote 13
Such a passage might well be applied to York and his son in contrast to Henry VI in 3 Henry VI, and it is impossible to prove that Shakespeare did not somehow read it (either in a published Italian edition or in one of several manuscript English translations of Machiavelli that circulated in Elizabethan England) and draw from it the insight that consistently motivates the most careful and successful politicians in his plays, from York in 1 Henry VI to Henry VIII.Footnote 14
Before concluding that he did so, however, one needs to weigh Machiavelli's occasional, almost incidental, references to time with his repetitive and emphatic references to fortune.Footnote 15 Even a casual reader of Machiavelli cannot miss his insistence that the key to political success lies in the prince's ability to make fortune work for him, rather than against him. Complementing chapter 25 of The Prince (“Fortune's Power in Human Affairs and How She Can Be Forestalled”) are innumerable other references.Footnote 16 Hanna Pitkin's careful study concludes that fortune is to virtù in Machiavelli as women are to successful men, as indicated most remarkably in the infamous line that “Fortune is a woman and it is necessary, in order to keep her under, to cuff and maul her.”Footnote 17 Machiavelli habitually links opportunity with fortune, deifying chance as a secular goddess who submits to the belligerent and the successful while consigning the timid to oblivion. Identifying political success with aggressively seized fortune can be related to the ability to act in time, since fortune creates opportunities in time, but Machiavelli does not make that link; he merely emphasizes the importance of controlling fortune.Footnote 18
Shakespeare also refers to fortune, but his conception is different from Machiavelli's, and it is less important in the history plays than time. Occasionally, to be sure, Shakespeare personifies fortune to make a point similar to Machiavelli's. In King John, when Philip the Bastard urges John and Lewis to put their quarrel aside for the moment and turn their joint wrath on Angiers, he points out that they can resume their quarrel again after defeating the city:
Then, in a moment, Fortune shall cull forth
Out of one side her happy minion,
To whom in favor she shall give the day,
And kiss him with a glorious victory.
(2.1.387–94)When Cardinal Wolsey in Henry VIII is caught red-handed in a plot against the king, he continues to believe—mistakenly, it turns out—that his luck will hold, and he can succeed yet again, as he has in the past: “yet I know / A way, if it take right, in spite of fortune / Will bring me off again” (3.2.219–21).
More frequently, however, a more stoic sense of fortune appears in Shakespeare, with very different implications from Machiavelli's equation of fortunate success with aggressively seized opportunity. When Warwick captures King Edward in 3 Henry VI, the King determines to bear the setback bravely: “Though Fortune's malice overthrow my state, / My mind exceeds the compass of her wheel” (4.3.46–47). This sense of fortune, with its allusion to the medieval picture of the goddess Fortune turning a wheel to which people were bound, sometimes rising toward her, sometimes declining away, is more fatalistic than Machiavelli's, though it shares with Machiavelli's idea a cyclical sense of political power and thus contrasts with the linear sense of political timing in Shakespeare's history plays—a sense that is central to his idea that succession is the weakest feature of monarchical government. Nor is King Edward's remark an immature reminiscence in the early histories alone, for it reappears in Henry V, the latest of the Elizabethan history plays, and in Antony and Cleopatra, as late as 1608.Footnote 19
As with time, then, so with fortune: one cannot prove that Shakespeare did not read Machiavelli and absorb his idea, but overall the two analyze political success differently, despite their common political realism, and the moral force of Shakespeare's political realism is more in keeping with humanism and his own dramatic tradition than with Machiavelli.Footnote 20 In any case, where his emphasis on time and his interpretation of politics in the continuum of secular history are concerned, Shakespeare may be more innovative than Machiavelli. Fortuna is a Roman goddess, her influence is cyclical, as the image of the wheel indicates, and the necessity to conquer her is part of Machiavelli's medieval political legacy. Time, on the other hand, is a discovery of the Renaissance, as Quinones argues, and the linearity of time is emphasized in the structure of Shakespeare's history plays. As one would expect of a playwright, Shakespeare's insight about history is inseparable from his sense of dramatic form, and understanding his accomplishment as a writer of plays is therefore imperative to understanding him as a thinker. Unlike Machiavelli, who wrote letters, plays, poems, and political treatises, Shakespeare wrote only plays and poems, so we have no critical reflections on which to draw in interpreting him. Shakespeare's writing needs to be understood in its own terms, both generically and historically, and his implicit political analysis of royal succession makes more sense as an intuitive derivation from the native English dramatic tradition than from Italian political theory.
