At first glance, this book, the first from Temple University history professor Jessica Roney, appears to offer little to economic historians. As the title suggests, the book's core concerns colonial political practices and governance structures. Moreover, it includes little information not already found in the extensive secondary literature on colonial Philadelphia's politics, especially the three-volume Lawmaking and Legislators in Pennsylvania (various publishers) authored and edited by Craig Horle, Joe Foster, and others between 1991 and 2005. Moreover, reference to the relevant political economy literature, like James C. Scott's Seeing Like a State (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1999), is almost completely absent, although there is a (seemingly obligatory for historians) nod to the work of German philosopher Jurgen Habermas in the book's “Essay on Sources.”
The one chapter (five) that directly confronts finance exaggerates its own modest contribution (summing the investments made by various NGOs in colonial Philadelphia) due to the author's ignorance of the recent secondary literature. Indeed, the book cites no business or economic history article or book published in the last 20 years and draws on only a handful of older studies by recognized business and economic historians (such as Thomas Doerflinger, Naomi Lamoreaux, and Ed Perkins). The author's lack of authority in matters business and economic suffuse the discussion, taking forms ranging from wordiness, like where she calls mutual corporations organizations “seen as deriving from motives of mutual assistance” (p. 112), to errors of omission due to a dearth of sufficient macroeconomic or business context, to outright mistakes, like calling the Bank of North America the “Bank of America” (p. 183).
That said, economic historians interested in economic growth would do well to take a close look at this book. Roney is a good historian, so her bias in favor of government, although palpable throughout, does not much interfere with her story, which details the relative economic and political freedom enjoyed by Philadelphians during the first three quarters of the eighteenth century. Of course Philadelphia also became the most economically successful city in North America over that same span despite its physical limitations. Although of much more recent origin than Boston, lacking New York's excellent salt water harbor, and in control of a much smaller and less well endowed hinterland than Annapolis (later Baltimore), by the eve of the Revolution Philadelphia was North America's “great mart” (p. 158), more populous and “flourishing” (p. 158) than any other according to most contemporary observers.
Philadelphia's freedom and its prosperity were not likely coincidental, as this reviewer pointed out in The First Wall Street (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2005). Rather, following the logic of various institutional theories of a freedom-growth nexus (from Adam Smith's claims about the economic stimulus provided by peace, easy taxes, and a tolerable administration of justice to the Fraser Institute's annual Economic Freedom of the World Index), it is likely that Philadelphia's economic freedom drove its relative economic success by attracting and encouraging entrepreneurs—business, financial, and social innovators — like Ben Franklin, Robert Morris, David Rittenhouse, Thomas Willing, and others literally too numerous to mention. Those men (and a few women) helped to keep public policy unobtrusive while they made the city's economy more efficient through a combination of hard work, new businesses (like fire insurance), new business practices (like voluntary association), and technologies (such as the Pennsylvania fireplace). Roney shows, in considerable detail, just how liberal (libertarian in today's parlance) early Philadelphia/Pennsylvania was. Its franchise was wider than that of any other colony and its famed religious toleration was very real, and very unusual for the time. Perhaps most importantly, economic and political activities were tolerated unless they were explicitly illegal.
That allowed early Philadelphians to establish numerous churches and also a wide range of nondenominational NGOs that fulfilled what in most times and places would be considered public goods: care for the aged and indigent, diplomacy with foreign nations, fire fighting, and even private militias that protected the city (which retained the pacifism inherited from its Quaker origins until the end of the colonial period) from angry backwoodsmen, disgruntled Indians, marauding privateers, and eventually (though not always successfully) Redcoats. Although most associations received some public funding, Philadelphia's NGOs were not akin to French tax farms but rather were spontaneous, voluntary associations of like-minded citizens typically funded in large part by donations and endowment earnings.
Most importantly, Governed deftly details why Philadelphia became, and remained, so liberal. The story is complex but ultimately boils down to competition between disparate centers of power: London authorities (themselves riven by the distinct interests of the King, Commons, and bureaucracy), the Proprietors (William Penn and his descendants), governors (who often pursued their individual interests), the provincial assembly, and city and county governments. The earliest associations thrived because they enjoyed the backing of most Pennsylvanians and at least one of those governments, typically because they appeared to weaken governmental rivals. Building on the early precedents, later NGOs maintained their right to function based on widespread public support (e.g., the private militia that formed to stop the Paxton Boy's march on Philadelphia) or the backing of a government (e.g., the Assembly's support for the Corporation for the Relief of the Poor).
In short, Governed by a Spirit of Opposition breaks little new ground in political or business/economic/financial history and does not even keep pace with the relevant secondary literatures. It does, however, afford economic historians interested in the institutional causes of economic growth a detailed summary of the extent and causes of colonial Philadelphia's relatively strong commitment to economic and political freedom.
