During the mid 1990s, Father Peter O’Brien, SJ, donated the musical scores, personal papers, recordings, and correspondence of pianist-arranger-activist Mary Lou Williams (1910–81) to the Institute of Jazz Studies at Rutgers University in Newark. As her former manager and the Executive Director of the Mary Lou Williams Foundation, O’Brien understood the importance of providing access to this vast collection, which chronicles Williams's life and six-decade-long career. Williams's life and music have subsequently garnered significant interest among scholars and musicians, with a notable centenary celebration held in 2010. With the publication of Theodore E. Buehrer's edition of eleven works dating from 1929 to 1968 in the Music of the United States (MUSA) series of scholarly editions (cross listed in A-R Editions Recent Researches in American Music series), research on Williams's music enters a new phase.
During the past several decades, scholarship on Mary Lou Williams has grown considerably. Foundational works included important profiles in the women-based histories produced by Sally Placksin, D. Antoinette Handy, and Linda Dahl.Footnote 1 Seminal interviews with Williams, produced during the 1970s and 1980s through the Jazz Oral History ProjectFootnote 2 and the Oral History of American Music project at Yale University,Footnote 3 as well as recordings on the Folkways and Smithsonian Folkways labels, also warrant recognition.Footnote 4 This earlier phase of scholarship was comprised primarily by “reclamation” texts, which chronicled the larger spectrum of women musicians and their contributions to jazz, a project that framed the first efforts to bring together the different aspects of Williams's biography and to understand her music.
Two major full-length biographical studies—Linda Dahl's Morning Glory and Tammy L. Kernodle's Soul on Soul—were published in 1999 and 2004 respectively.Footnote 5 They played an important role in the movement among several scholars and musicians to expand Williams's place in the larger context of jazz historiography, a project that Williams herself was attempting to shape during the last decade of her life through her work at Duke University.Footnote 6 Most importantly, these two biographies sought to reclaim Williams from the marginal quotations and anecdotes to which she had been relegated, such as the Duke Ellington's scanty but much-quoted comments in his memoir Music Is My Mistress, where he describes Williams as “perpetually contemporary.”Footnote 7 Dahl's and Kernodle's studies, as well as those by scholars such as Gayle Murchison, Charles Pickeral, and Monica Hairston, have extended and strengthened the framework for understanding many aspects of Williams's life, as well as her performance and compositional approaches.Footnote 8
Despite these resources, before MUSA brought out Buehrer's excellent edition, no extensive theoretical discussion of Williams's big band arrangements had been published. Such work is essential if the scope of the scholarship on Williams is to expand to include analytically based consideration of her importance as a composer and arranger. This type of publication is not easy, however, especially when one considers the unique factors, such as the diversity of performance and compositional approaches, that frame Williams's musical legacy. Not only was Williams one of the rare jazz musicians to have played through every era preceding her death in 1981, but she also mastered many of the performance/compositional approaches associated with the different subgenres that emerged during her six-decade career. Unlike in the case of her contemporaries Don Redman, Fletcher Henderson, and Duke Ellington, it is difficult to compartmentalize Williams's style into a list of fixed musical elements and approaches. Although there are certain attributes that have become her “signatures,” it is very difficult to promote the idea of a static Mary Lou Williams style. This issue points to another significant challenge to the study of Williams's music: the size and scope of her output. Consisting of over 300 works, Williams's compositional legacy includes big band arrangements, chamber jazz, symphonic poems, combo arrangements, pop songs, and religious works. There has been some scholarship on her religious works and on some piano works of the 1940s, but Buehrer's work represents the first efforts in addressing the vast catalog of big band arrangements—one of the most central aspects of Williams's compositional personality.
Buehrer's work on this portion of Williams's oeuvre is well known in scholarly circles and among performers. This edition is the culmination of years of work analyzing and transcribing Williams's compositions. His transcriptions have been performed by the North Carolina Jazz Repertory Orchestra and are included in the Essentially Ellington program sponsored by Jazz at Lincoln Center, which is verification of his stature as an expert on this area of Williams's legacy. He states from the outset that the intentions of his work are not to “add Williams to the rank of the ‘exceptional woman,’” but “rather to identify her influence, to demonstrate the originality with which she integrated these influences in her music, and to describe the trajectory of her stylistic evolution” (xix). Whereas Buehrer indeed accomplishes these latter goals, his assertions regarding the gendered readings of Williams as one of jazz's “exceptional women” underscore how her legacy in jazz is intertwined with this historical narrative. Although he focuses on her influences, compositional praxis, and relationship with various jazz milieus, Buehrer can never fully escape the “exceptional woman” narrative as described by a number of jazz scholars. This paradox is not his fault, but reflects the limited methodology used in writing jazz history and teaching the genre in college classrooms. Almost every jazz history textbook published to date positions Williams as one of the only female jazz instrumentalists operating outside of the paradigm of all-girl bands. Predecessors like Sweet Emma Barrett, Lovie Austin, and Lil Hardin Armstrong are rarely discussed; if Hardin is mentioned, the discussion is often limited to her tenure with King Oliver's Creole Jazz Band. These omissions reflect how the theory of the “exceptional woman” frames the context of gender in jazz's historiography. With the emphasis being placed on one representative female musician whose musicianship exceeds the “gendered” expectations of listeners, critics, and fellow musicians, scholars have rationalized the exclusion of other women from the historical context and perpetuated a narrative of invisibility. Footnote 9 My purpose in raising this point is not to debate the validity of Buehrer's intentions or to question his thinking, but to highlight the difficulties he and other scholars have faced when trying to understand women musicians like Williams in the limited musical and cultural scope of jazz historiography—most notably the narrative of the “exceptional woman.” Despite this larger historiographical debate, this edition makes a considerable contribution to the scholarship on Williams and jazz studies in general.
The edition is divided into four sections: 1) Historical and Analytical Essay; 2) Discussion of Methodology and Apparatus Used; 3) Facsimiles of Manuscripts; and 4) Transcriptions of Selected Works. Titled “Mary's Ideas: Big Band Music by Mary Lou Williams,” the historical-analytical essay in Part One involves three different foci. The first addresses the place of women instrumentalists within the larger framework of jazz history. Here Buehrer argues against frameworks based solely on race and gender. He draws on the groundbreaking scholarship of Sherrie Tucker, Nichole Rustin, Ingrid Monson, and David Ake in making an argument for the expansion of historical contexts and the de-gendering of the language of jazz historiography.Footnote 10 This discussion is followed by a biographical study of Williams's geographical and musical trajectory from her hometown of Pittsburgh to Kansas City, the site of her evolution from pianist to arranger. Even though this section draws heavily on previous scholarship on Williams's life, it provides an excellent transition to the analytical discussion of her arranging style.
Buehrer focuses this part of his critical study on three phases of Williams's compositional activity: 1) her early works with Andy Kirk's band (1929–31), which include her earliest attempts at composition; 2) selected works from the late 1930s and 1940s, a period during which her style matured and stretched beyond the conventions associated with the Kansas City style; and 3) works produced during the late 1960s, when Williams shifted back to secular compositions, after spending much of the decade focused on sacred works. Anyone familiar with Williams's music would wonder how Buehrer decided which of her 200 big band arrangements to include in this volume. The author states that he first limited his choices to those pieces that existed in manuscript form. This strategy eliminated arrangements written before 1937 from consideration. So Buehrer shifted his focus to extant recordings of Williams's early works. To remedy the lack of written scores, Buehrer made transcriptions, which serve as the basis of his discussion of her early compositional approaches.
Through detailed charts and numerous musical examples, Buehrer argues effectively that Williams's compositional voice was constantly evolving, drawing in and reflecting on the musical milieus that she encountered before, during, and after her tenure with Kirk's band. What is evident in the analysis of the eleven arrangements selected for this collection is that Williams engaged in intricate and nuanced approaches, reflecting her awareness of the changing context of jazz culture. These changes are reflected in the works represented in the MUSA edition. Buehrer's comparison of different versions of “Messa Stomp” and “Mary's Idea” provides good examples of Williams's process of recomposition in the context of two of her earliest arrangements. “Lonely Moments” and “In the Land of Oo Bla Dee,” two of my personal favorites, reflect the growing influence of art music and bebop on Williams, especially in the use of intricate harmonies and the complex canonic treatment of the melody that appears in the middle of each arrangement.
In addition to these superb transcriptions, this edition also reinforces Ellington's description of Williams as being “perpetually contemporary.” The depth of her intellect and the depth of her musical ear are reflected in each work. The compositions refute the notion that “exceptional women” like Williams worked in isolation away from other creative beings and that the worlds in which they worked had no impact on them. Buehrer demystifies Williams's aura as she moves beyond being the gendered “other” among her male musical contemporaries. His MUSA edition situates Williams as an important compositional voice in twentieth-century jazz and helps strengthen assertions about her contributions to jazz history. He lifts her from “behind the veil” of the bands she wrote for and situates her as belonging to the list of important articulators of American jazz culture. This edition will expand the historical and curricular perspectives of jazz studies and American music.
