In this book, Oskar Verkaaik examines the Muhajir Quami Mahaz (MQM), later known as the Muttehida Quami Mahaz, a highly charged and significant political movement and party in southern Pakistan during the late 1980s and early 1990s. Verkaaik's assertion is that a close reading of this movement reveals the multiplicity and difference not only in politics in the Muslim world but also in the articulations and understandings of Islam and “Muslimness.” Thus, the MQM separates itself from a straightforward, universalistic reading of Islam and bases its politics on a combination of the universal and the particular, the latter being grounded in a politics of ethnicity. Verkaaik argues that this development is predicated on the historical context in Pakistan and is incomprehensible without taking local factors into account. Insofar as the MQM hopes to capture power, it initially adopts its own particular version of a mystic Islam, at odds with mainstream Islamic parties and the state, both of which favor a universalist Islam as a mechanism designed to negate challenges to their respective hegemonies.
The author does not, however, see either the state or the MQM as fixed and unchanging but, rather, as evolving institutions, acting and reacting to a variety of forces on the ground. This helps the reader understand the MQM's collaboration with the state as well as its opposition to it. It is in tracing a politics of difference that Verkaaik makes his most significant contribution: like the state, the MQM is constantly shifting and heterogeneous. This aspect constitutes the real strength of the work. Through a close examination of a neighborhood in Hyderabad, the second largest city in the southern province of Sindh, he points to both the urban character of this movement (in opposition to the rural base of the Sindhi ethnic movement) and to the dominant role played in it by urban male youth. Through this prism, Verkaaik is able to demonstrate that it is these youth's exuberance and irreverence–what he calls fun–that form the basis of their participation and involvement, rather than any a priori ideology. Such an emphasis on fun constitutes a radical departure not only from the mainstream Islamic parties (which frown on fun), but also from the older generation within the party itself. Verkaaik links this emphasis on an ethnography of emotions with a class analysis wherein he suggests that fun represents a politics of the underclass, the displaced, and the dispossessed within the migrant community. However, this fun slides over into violence at key junctures, which Verkaaik discusses at length, and enables its proponents to displace their opponents within the party, who belong to a more privileged strata of the immigrant community (the “salariat” in Hamza Alavi's terms, i.e., the educated middle class). This class difference is articulated through the body and hypermasculinity, both of which are recast in modern forms attendant upon globalization and not on conventionally available body practices (an example being karate instead of kushti, the streamlined athletic body instead of the heavy wrestler).
In reading this text, I found myself fascinated by the nuanced tracing out of the process by which the MQM is transformed into a potent political force, which is reliant on violence. The sources the author uses–historical materials (including biographies, texts by various political figures, and newspaper accounts) and the close ethnographic exposure to Pakka Qila, the neighborhood where Veraaik conducted his ethnography–provide the reader with a sophisticated understanding of this movement that to many outside observers has been marked and noted simply in terms of its flagrant violence and coercive tactics. Without condoning its excesses, Verkaaik enables us to see beyond this surface impression, in the best ethnographic tradition.
Thus, this book furthers our understanding of the complexity–indeed the “vexity”–of politics in the Muslim world. It calls into question a singular reading of Islam and Muslim politics and illustrates the variegated forms that emerge through a process that is informed by local and global forces. It also makes a very important link between sentiments and class, showing that the material and ideational are inextricably linked–and that politics itself need not be guided by political ideology but rather by a sense of irreverence and transgression, which is generative of a politics not already constituted by leaders, party platforms, and the like. The links among the MQM, its internal differentiation, and its relation to the state again enable us as readers to see the state and politics not as givens but in terms of process, as being “performed,” thereby emphasizing agency and the possibility for change. By emphasizing the space of gender in this process, Verkaaik makes a fresh theoretical and empirical contribution to the now considerable literature on gender and violence. Finally, for students of the Pakistani political scene, the author provides rich insights into the multifaceted character of a political movement that has had a devastating impact on urban life in the major cities of the southern part of the country and allows us to think beyond the sensational coverage of the violence itself.
