— In Gordon v. State Bar of California, the Disability Rights, Education, and Defense Fund (“DREDF”) and Legal Aid at Work sued the State Bar of California (“State Bar”) and the National Conference of Bar Examiners (“NCBE”) in federal court in the United States District Court’s Northern District of California.Footnote 1 Plaintiffs moved for a preliminary injunction to stop the State Bar from mandating in person testing for Kara Gordon, Isabel Callejo-Brighton, and John Doe, test takers with disabilities who were approved for testing accommodations by the State Bar.Footnote 2 The court denied the motion because Plaintiffs were not likely to succeed on the merits of the claims and had not established irreparable harm.Footnote 3
I. BACKGROUND
Plaintiffs were law school graduates, and each has one or more disabilities.Footnote 4 Kara Gordon is diagnosed with a dural tear, leading to “migraines, eye pain, blurred and double vision, nausea, photophobia, and periodic cognition issues while sitting upright.”Footnote 5 Isabel Callejo-Brighton has “Stage 4 endometriosis, irritable bowel syndrome, small intestinal bacterial overgrowth, a neurodevelopmental disorder, and an anxiety disorder related to her medical conditions.”Footnote 6 She has constant pain in her abdomen and pelvis, as well as complications with her bladder and bowel function.Footnote 7 “John Doe is diagnosed with ADHD, generalized anxiety disorder, trichotillomania, and dysthymic disorder (persistent depressive disorder).”Footnote 8 All three individuals are persons with disabilities under both the Americans with Disabilities Act and Californian antidiscrimination laws.Footnote 9
Due to their own underlying medical conditions, as well as those of others in their domicile, Plaintiffs were at a higher risk of both complications and consequences if they were to become ill with COVID-19.Footnote 10 To ensure both “health and safety during the pandemic, Plaintiffs had to stay within their homes as much as possible and avoid being in close proximity with other individuals who could have been positive for COVID-19 or surfaces contaminated with the virus.”Footnote 11 Families were at risk as well: John Doe lived with his wife, who was pregnant with twins and has severe asthma.Footnote 12 Both John Doe and his wife had an increased risk of developing serious complications should they have contracted COVID-19.Footnote 13
Applicants must pass the California bar exam to practice law in the state of California, which is offered twice a year in July and February.Footnote 14 The State Bar develops the exam, scores it, and decides whether or not to grant requests for reasonable accommodations for those with disabilities.Footnote 15 Here, all Plaintiffs were granted testing accommodations for the October 2020 Bar Exam.Footnote 16 Most years, depending on the nature of the disability, accommodations included things such as: wheelchair access, permission to dictate, extended testing schedules or days, separate testing rooms, and customized examination materials, like examination paper with large print or Braille.Footnote 17 This year, to protect the health and safety of test takers and the general public in light of COVID-19, the California Supreme Court asked the State Bar to offer its examination online for most test takers, asking them to “make every effort possible to administer that examination online with remote and/or electronic proctoring.”Footnote 18
In their motion, Plaintiffs contended that they were likely to “succeed on the merits of their ADA claims because the defendants’ ‘two-tiered system’ facially discriminated against disabled test takers, burdened and disproportionately impacted them, and denied them equal and meaningful access to the exam.”Footnote 19 Plaintiffs alleged that Defendants specifically excluded disabled test takers from the remote administration of the Bar exam in the following cases: if they could not stay in front of the webcam for the entirety of each test section, if they needed a paper iteration of the exam or physical scratch paper, or if they used screen-reading software.Footnote 20 If a test taker were to be granted double testing time, a normal accommodation for test takers with a disability, this meant not being able to leave the view of the web camera for up to three hours.Footnote 21 For some test takers, this was an impossible testing scenario.Footnote 22
Unless the test taker waived the testing accommodations, Defendants required these disabled test takers to travel to and participate in an in-person administration of the bar exam.Footnote 23 Plaintiffs argued that these accommodations, like unscheduled breaks and paper copies of the exam, were necessary for a positive performance on the exam.Footnote 24 If they took the exam remotely without the accommodations, their likelihood of passing the exam was low due to their disabilities. For example, “being upright or looking at a computer for more than two hours exacerbate Kara Gordon’s dural tear and can trigger a migraine.”Footnote 25 In this case, they would have to lie flat for at least half an hour to manage their symptoms, certainly not looking at a computer screen.Footnote 26 Therefore, the scheduled breaks away from the webcam were necessary for them.
Plaintiffs argued that, should the State Bar require them to take an in-person examination, “they would be faced with the risk of disruptive fear and anxiety associated with the risk of COVID-19 exposure during the exam, interfering with their ability to perform at their true ability.”Footnote 27 These risks were due directly to Plaintiffs’ disabilities, and the State Bar did not impose them on Plaintiffs’ nondisabled peers.Footnote 28 Both the Department of Public Health and the CDC have said that people with underlying health conditions are more likely to have serious outcomes from COVID-19, including hospitalization and death.Footnote 29
Plaintiffs proposed a system where those who needed bathroom breaks during test sessions “could scan the bathroom at the beginning of the test day to prove the absence of unauthorized material, announce their need for a break on camera, take the laptop to the bathroom and leave it outside … and collect the laptop upon leaving.”Footnote 30 If a test taker with a disability needed a paper exam, Defendant could use a courier or a secure file transfer that the test taker would print in front of a proctor.Footnote 31 Defendant could use Dropbox or ExamSoft for essays typed on a computer or performance tests.Footnote 32 Any part of the examination done by hand “could be sealed in front of the human proctor and returned by courier,” or photographed in front of the proctor and uploaded.Footnote 33
The State Bar opposed the motion, arguing that Plaintiffs were unlikely to succeed on the merits of their claims.Footnote 34 It claimed that the rules governing the in-person examination, including private hotel rooms for each test taker, created safe and equal access to the examination.Footnote 35 It also argued that the accommodations proposed by Plaintiffs would cause them undue burden because they would have to implement new systems in a short time.Footnote 36 Finally, Defendant argued that Plaintiffs did not establish irreparable harm, “given the COVID-19 protocols, the lowering of the passing score for the bar by 50 points, and its establishment of a provisional-licensing program that allows law-school graduates who have not yet passed a bar exam to practice law until June 2022.”Footnote 37
Plaintiffs asked for both injunctive and declaratory relief, including compensatory damages, emergency relief, and attorneys’ fees.Footnote 38 Plaintiffs also asked for “extraordinary relief in order to take the October 2020 California State Bar Examination remotely with their testing accommodations because their post-graduation jobs are contingent on their taking and passing this specific exam.”Footnote 39
II. THE COURT’S DECISION
For the court to grant a preliminary injunction, a movant must demonstrate “(1) a likelihood of success on the merits, (2) a likelihood of irreparable harm that would result if an injunction were not issued, (3) the balance of equities tips in favor of the plaintiff, and (4) an injunction is in the public interest.”Footnote 40
For the ADA Claim against the State Bar, Title II of the ADA prohibits discrimination on the basis of a disability in the activities, programs, and services of any public entity.Footnote 41 Federal regulations require a public entity to “make reasonable modifications in policies, practices, or procedures when the modifications are necessary to avoid discrimination on the basis of disability, unless the public entity can demonstrate that making the modifications would fundamentally alter the nature of the service, program, or activity.”Footnote 42
The court decided that Plaintiffs did not show a likelihood of success on the merits because the State Bar's criteria for remote testing were neutral both facially and as applied.Footnote 43 A facially discriminatory policy must categorically exclude disabled persons from participating in a public program, and here the court determines that Defendant’s remote examination conditions apply to all test takers.Footnote 44 As applied, the court found that most in-person test takers of the bar exam were not disabled.Footnote 45 Seventy percent of test takers with disabilities were approved for remote testing by the State Bar.Footnote 46 While forty-four percent of the in-person test takers were disabled persons with testing accommodations, this number did not “necessarily establish that the State Bar denied the plaintiffs meaningful access to state-provided services.”Footnote 47
The court also held that the accommodations suggested by Plaintiffs would have imposed an undue burden on Defendant and were not feasible to execute before the October exam.Footnote 48 The ADA did not require Defendant “to take any action that it can demonstrate would result in a fundamental alteration in the nature of the service, program, or activity or in undue financial and administrative burden.”Footnote 49 In this case, the State Bar would have to create different procedures for about 100 test takers, some with more than one accommodation, like paper exams and extended time.Footnote 50 Plaintiffs did not “meaningfully challenge the State Bar's evidence about feasibility and implementation, except to say that it is a surmountable problem that the State Bar incurred by ignoring the plaintiffs’ needs.”Footnote 51 In the future, the State Bar might be able to accommodate Plaintiffs, but for the October 2020 bar examination, the Plaintiffs’ proposals would have fundamentally changed and burdened Defendant's exam administration.Footnote 52
Overall, Plaintiffs did not meaningfully challenge the State Bar's evidence that its current protocols are “consistent with best practices, lower the risk of COVID-19 transmission, and allow the State Bar to administer the bar exam safely.”Footnote 53
For Plaintiffs’ ADA Claim against the NCBE, the court found that Plaintiffs did not have standing because the NCBE allowed a remote written examination, and therefore Plaintiffs had no injury fairly traceable to the NCBE that a judicial decision could adequately redress.Footnote 54 The NCBE said it already planned on allowing remote proctoring and paper tests for its examination, and it gave this information to the State Bar.Footnote 55 It contended that “the decision about remote testing thus is the State Bar's decision, and it is not fairly traceable to the NCBE.”Footnote 56 As for the actual ADA claim, the court found that Plaintiffs were unlikely to succeed on the merits “for the same reasons that they are not likely to succeed on the merits of the Title II ADA claim against the State Bar, at least for the October 2020 bar exam.”Footnote 57
On October 2, 2020, the Ninth Circuit denied Plaintiffs’ emergency motion for an injunction pending appeal, closing the door for relief before the October 2020 examination.Footnote 58
III. IMPLICATIONS FOR THE FUTURE
In his declaration of support, Peter Blanck argued that Plaintiffs will likely experience both short-term and longer-term harms, “including to their professional status, employment, earnings, and economic empowerment, and to their physical and mental health and that of their families.”Footnote 59 These harms are the type meant to be avoided by the ADA and the Unruh Civil Rights Act.Footnote 60 The purpose of the Bar Exam is to assess the knowledge and skills of test takers in expectation that lawyers need such knowledge and skills to succeed in their profession. If the exam failed to do this, it has failed its purpose. Here, as Blanck argued, this test could not have scientific validity because it is not measuring concepts that it purports to test.Footnote 61 Therefore, the October 2020 California bar exam was unsuccessful at evaluating whether Plaintiffs and other test takers with disabilities were qualified to pass the examination and work as licensed attorneys.
The court disagreed with this idea, focusing on the nature of the harm to Plaintiffs being speculative.Footnote 62 It stated that the concerns Plaintiffs faced, like poor performance and lost professional opportunities, were no different than the concerns of any in-person test taker. The court was hesitant to burden the State Bar and the NCBE given the speed with which they would be required to adopt these new accommodations.
However, some state bar examiners successfully accommodated test takers with disabilities in their October 2020 examinations.Footnote 63 For example, Beth Karp, a 2020 graduate of the University of Chicago School of Law, could not take the remote exam in Illinois due to her disability, which causes light sensitivity.Footnote 64 “After a disability rights legal group sent a letter on her behalf to the Illinois Board of Admissions to the Bar, she ultimately received approval to take a paper exam remotely in a hotel room by herself and be proctored via Zoom.”Footnote 65 Given the ease with which other State Bars have granted these requests, the California State Bar should have been able to meet the need of test takers with disabilities, and should look to doing so in the future, given that the pandemic will likely continue through at least the next two administrations of the exam.
Despite their decision, the court left the door open for new claims. It often referred to the October Bar exam as an exception.Footnote 66 The undue burden part of the test did most of the heavy lifting for the court, possibly to leave open the door that these accommodations could be adopted if the State Bar and NCBE were given more time.
