The recent literature on income inequality in the United States is paying increased attention to the role of politics and policy in shaping market outcomes. The argument is that government action has changed the market in ways that have produced rising inequality, and this has motivated scholars to study how changes in national partisan power and public policy shape the pretax pretransfer income distribution (Jacob Hacker and Paul Pierson, Winner Take All Politics, 2010; Nathan J. Kelly, The Politics of Income Inequality in the United States, 2009). Oren Levin-Waldman's Wage Policy, Income Distribution, and Democratic Theory contributes to this literature by providing a discussion of wage policy—defined as policies designed to bolster wages—as a specific mechanism for government's effect on market inequality.
The book puts forward both a normative and empirical defense of wage policy, with a particular focus on the minimum wage and the encouragement of unionization. The early chapters focus on the normative portion of the argument. The main premise is that wage policies are compatible with and, in fact, demanded by at least some modern conceptions of democratic theory. The key point is that low wages and economic inequality generate hurdles to full and equal participation in democratic society: “Any policy that opens up the framework so that individuals have access and can have the opportunity to participate is then in keeping with democratic theory” (p 47). There follows a historical discussion of the origins of wage policy in the United States, the main arguments that have been made in support of wage floors, and the ways in which opponents of an active wage policy have in large part successfully maintained what the author refers to as a punitive wage policy that provides few protections for workers.
The later chapters present quantitative evidence on the origins of the new living-wage movement and the effect of wage policy beyond the poor and working class. Here, the author endeavors to show that recent agitation for living wages is rooted in a failure of wage policy and that wage policy should be viewed as a middle-class issue with implications for the well-being of individuals and families in the middle of the income distribution.
The primary contribution of this book is that it presents a coherent, well-written, and quite readable defense of government intervention to increase wages in the United States. Readers who are interested in a normal science approach to policy analysis should look elsewhere, but those who want a clear normative argument with empirical analysis in support of the normative claims will find the book useful. Given its accessibility, it would be appropriate for undergraduate courses in which the inclusion of an ideologically left perspective on political economy and labor market policy is desired. Scholars of American public policy will likely find the historical discussion of wage policy in the United States to be the most useful portion. The most interesting empirical contribution is the result suggesting that minimum wage increases produce dramatic income-enhancing effects for the middle class, not just those directly benefiting from increases in the wage floor. Overall, the book provides a substantial amount of fodder for politicians and pundits looking for arguments in favor of increasing the minimum wage.
While this book has notable strengths, I do see a number of shortcomings. Its argument is apparently intended to convince opponents of an active wage policy that such policies should be enacted on both normative and empirical grounds. However, given the deep ideological disagreements that exist regarding state intervention in the economy, it is doubtful that serious opponents of the policies advocated here will be convinced on the normative front since the argument is rooted in conceptions of democracy not typically embraced by opponents of wage policy. This may be more a critique of the current state of the policy debate than this book in particular, but the argument is clearly left-leaning and is most likely to be embraced by politicians and citizens predisposed toward the conclusions presented.
My largest critique relates to the empirical analysis in Chapters 5 and 6. Chapter 5 presents an analysis of the adoption of living wage laws in American cities. The argument tested here is that “the living wage movement … [has] been a response to the collapse of the federal minimum wage” (p. 108). Several explanatory variables are considered in a logit model of living-wage law adoption, including education, union density, age, unemployment, and income inequality. The variables included in these models are sensible, and are certainly indirectly connected to the specific theoretical argument made in the chapter, but it is curious that more direct measures of the deterioration of the federal minimum wage were not included. For instance, some states in which these cities are located had previously adopted their own minimum wage higher than the federal minimum, and the federal minimum might have been closer to a living wage in some cities than others based on differential cost of living in each city. It would have been useful to consider such theoretically relevant variables in the analysis. Additionally, all of the originally continuous explanatory variables are coded dichotomously, and the author does not provide a convincing rationale for this choice. Finally, alternative explanations for the adoption of living-wage laws, such as mass partisanship and ideology (which could be measured indirectly using presidential election results, congressional election results, or congressional roll-call behavior), are not sufficiently considered.
Chapter 6 focuses on two questions: What are the income effects of minimum wage increases in the middle portion of the income distribution, and are there adverse effects of the minimum wage on employment levels? The answer to the first question relies on a bivariate time-series analysis of wage levels at various points in the income distribution and the minimum wage. Clearly, the correlation between minimum wage increases and income levels is high and positive, but basic alternative explanations for rising wages, such as productivity and economic growth, are not considered. The author acknowledges this omission, but these factors could have been readily included in a multivariate time-series framework. The second question relies on an analysis of several years of individual-level US Census data, with employment status as the dependent variable. This portion of the analysis suffers from many of the same issues raised with the analysis in Chapter 5: Some of the coding choices are not sufficiently defended, and the connection between the key explanatory variable (relating to the minimum wage) and the core hypothesis being tested needs additional discussion.
These quibbles notwithstanding, this book makes a useful contribution to the normative and empirical literature on labor policy in the United States. Those interested in the history of wage policy, the political hurdles that stand in the way of its adoption, and the key arguments in favor of a more active wage policy should find it quite interesting and useful.
