The study of the imperial cult has become almost a cult in itself. This hefty volume, containing the proceedings of a congress held at Mérida in May 2006, comprises twenty-nine papers, all but six of which deal with the Hispanic provinces. The tenor of most of them is similar: if a temple has been discovered, it must belong to the imperial cult; if a statue of an emperor or member of his family, its purpose must be religious rather than merely honorific; if a forum or theatre, it must have cultic significance. At the risk of appearing captious or heretical, let me confess that I find much of this ‘cultomania’ unconvincing. Many of the authors’ claims repose on conjecture or presumed associations, without solid evidence.
The lone sober warning comes from W. Trillmich (415–45), who urges caution in interpreting public spaces and buildings as places dedicated to the imperial cult, especially when there are only ruins or remnants of sculptural decoration: ‘donde no hay inscripción, sólo puede haber hipótesis’ (417). A case in point is the two ‘imperial cult’ temples at Emerita Augusta (the hexastyle ‘templo de Diana’, supposedly the colonial temple, and the monumental building in Calle Holguín, supposedly the provincial one), whose identification is unsupported by epigraphic testimony. The former building is dated by J. C. Saquete and J. M. Alvarez Martínez, on architectonic grounds, ‘hacia el cambio de Era, es decir, todavía con Augusto en vida’ (398). Theoretically it could have been dedicated to the deified Julius, or to one of the Augustan virtues — Victoria Augusta, suggest the authors — or, like the Maison Carrée at Nîmes, to the deceased Gaius and Lucius Caesar. But how do we know it does not refer to some other deity favoured by Augustus, such as Apollo, Mars Ultor or Venus Genetrix? The Augustan architect Vitruvius (1.7) prescribes the siting of temples to the various gods: Mercury in the forum, Apollo near the theatre, the Capitoline Triad at the highest point of the city, and so on. Where are these temples at Emerita, and in other Hispanic cities? For instance, J. M. Campos and J. Bermejo conclude that the temple and forum at Turobriga (near modern Aroche) in western Baetica must be ‘manifestaciones de culto imperial’ (258). Yet a local inscription (ILS 5402) records that the priestess Baebia Crinita of Turobriga donated a temple of Apollo and Diana at a cost of 200,000 sesterces. Could this not be the same temple? One should avoid automatically assuming that every temple dominating a plaza belongs to the imperial cult.
The provincial temple at Tarraco, known from literary evidence (Tac., Ann. 1.78), is believed by J. M. Macias et al. to lie on the city's upper terrace, where the cathedral now stands (763–87). Since its presumed architectonic remains are scattered all over the town, this can only be a conjecture. Yet ideally, the provincial temple should lie on the outskirts of the city, to facilitate processions to the theatre. A procession commencing on the upper terrace of Tarraco would have to traverse the urban centre to arrive there. Does this not cast doubt on the temple's putative location? Another puzzling ‘fact’: clipei with the horned head of Jupiter Ammon, like those in the Forum Augustum at Rome, decorate the porticoes of plazas associated by scholars with the colonial cult at Emerita (490–1) but the provincial cult at Tarraco (780). Does no one find this incongruity disturbing? Has one of these been misidentified?
A different problem is the starting date of the provincial cult in the senatorial province of Baetica. While J. González maintains the traditional view that this did not begin before Vespasian (175), A. Ventura argues that a temple and its temenos, discovered in the Calle Morería at Corduba, ‘habrían constituido el recinto de culto imperial de la provincia Baetica consagrado al Divus Augustus’ (231). He bases this conclusion on the remains of decorated mouldings of Luni marble, similar to those on the temple of Mars Ultor in the Forum Augustum at Rome. But the latter is not a temple of the imperial cult. If architectonic analogy is so compelling, should not the Corduba temple be attributed to Mars Ultor? And why should it belong to the provincial, rather than colonial, cult? To enliven matters, J. A. Garriguet argues that another Corduban temple complex, in the Calle Claudio Marcelo, with fragmentary statuary of emperors, is the provincial cult centre and dates to the Julio-Claudian period (316). Thus even the local specialists cannot agree. For what it is worth, there are no inscriptions of provincial priests in Baetica earlier than the Flavians.
Not all the papers deal with temples. Inter alia, D. Fishwick (30–47) analyses the evidence for statuettes or busts of deified emperors that could be carried in religious processions; J.-C. Balty (49–73) examines statues of emperors clothed as Jupiter or Olympian Zeus; E. La Rocca (75–104) considers the artistic representations of thrones and other divine furniture. Finally, J. Edmondson (541–75) presents a third-century inscription from Emerita dedicated to Mars Augustus, containing the surprising and unparalleled formula ‘p(ro) incolumita(te) temp(orum)’. Could we not restore ‘p(ro) incolumitate <i>mp(eratoris)’? A mason's error seems less improbable than the editor's reading.
In short, an interesting volume; but caveat lector!
