The history of science is embarking on a global turn. The Renaissance, the Enlightenment, the Industrial Revolution and Darwinism are all being placed into a global framework. What is more, these turning points in the European historical narrative are being contextualized within other senses of chronology and space, and so decentred from their mythic status as events in the birth of modern science.
This encyclopedia serves as a good marker of the changing status of the global in histories of science. Its first edition, published in 1997, consisted of one volume and about six hundred articles. We now have a vastly expanded overview, two volumes and about a thousand entries. In an intriguing assessment, editor Helaine Selin, who is science librarian at Hampshire College, Amherst, notes that this new edition embodies a shift from ‘advocacy to analysis’ (vol. 1, p. i). The advocacy was needed the first time around in order to overcome Eurocentrism. But awareness of Eurocentrism is now far more widespread in science studies, opening up possibilities for a more careful tracing of the global history of science in its many-varied hues.
One of the most praiseworthy achievements of this encyclopedia is the broad definition of science, technology and medicine employed. The volumes contain entries ranging from breadmaking to origami, and from magic squares to irrigation systems. The rationale for casting such a wide net was clearly set out in the first edition. To do otherwise is to risk recapitulating the traditional hegemony of the classificatory systems of the West; above all, Western differentiations regarding science, medicine and technology. Another advantage of such an approach is that it allows the value of the ‘intellectual property’ of Asians, Africans and Latin Americans to be recognized. Reading through at random presents a refreshing corrective to intuitive senses of logic, universalism and standardization long associated with Europe. Following the entry on ‘logic’, for example, what emerges is how something too often understood as the distinctive property of Western science arose from a process of exchange with, and Christianization of, traditions borrowed from elsewhere, including Asian traditions of logic.
Nevertheless, there is a problem, suggested in the very title of this encyclopedia, and pointing to a major concern about the conceptualization of this enterprise. Why the term ‘non-Western’? This might have been useful at a time when there was more fulsome sympathy with the postcolonial project of provincializing Europe. But it has outlived its usefulness. For one thing, it creates the monolithic types ‘East’ and ‘West’ – terms which appear in a good number of entries here. More generally, it leads to an unhelpful typology of knowledge systems, sometimes at the East–West level, but more commonly involving more discrete regions. The entries on ‘ethnobotany’ illustrate the worry well: we have the ethnobotany of Alaska, the Aztecs, China, Ethiopia, the Incas, India, the Malay region, Mesoamerica, Native North America, the Pacific, Pakistan and South America. On what basis have these geographic categories been chosen? Some of them are dubious frameworks for long-run historicist analysis as they are modern national terms. Others are regions which are difficult to bound. Yet others are regions that have been bounded by colonialism. A further liability of ‘non-Western’ is the way its usage tends either to exclude Europe or to let it creep in by the back door, through such entry titles as ‘colonialism and science’.
Perhaps the underlying problem here is that the global history of science is a field which, so far as its analytic terms are concerned, is still in its infancy. Debates are still rife about the pros and cons of using ‘indigenous knowledge’ or even ‘science’. Then again, an encyclopedia organized into geographic units might be thought to call into question the very premises of a global history. Maybe these volumes are best understood as contributing not to ‘global history’, but to the making of the global into the history of the local. The entry on ‘local knowledge’, for instance, by David Turnbull, seeks to present all sciences as assemblages of local practices which are then globalized. The problems with such an approach are duly noted; for if the local is foregrounded, does it not create grounds for dogmatic cultural chauvinism and nationalism? Turnbull concludes by urging the need to attend to the dialectic between the local and the global. But this straddling of the global and the local is difficult to exemplify in an encyclopedia which has such a highly compartmentalized sense of space.
To keep up with the global turn in the history of the sciences, a reference work like this one will need regular revision. It would be helpful if, in the next edition, Europe was cut to size and included alongside other regions. There may be room, too, for some editorial reflection on the uncertain genre of the encyclopedia. Here, for example, we find lots of straightforward descriptive entries, covering biographies and themes and so on, but among these are a number of quite sophisticated historiographic pieces – effectively mini-journal articles. This unevenness makes for an element of luck in finding the most helpful entries. It is useful, then, that the encyclopedia is available in digital form; indeed, this format may well overtake the hard-copy version as the most valuable to scholars.
In bringing together a truly international and distinguished band of contributors, Selin has done the field of history of science a great service. It is rather unusual to want to read an encyclopedia from cover to cover, but those who dip into this one will have their curiosity aroused for much more. Those looking for research topics, meanwhile, will find a rich diversity of areas awaiting further exploration. Let us hope that a new edition will need to be released very soon, and that the digital version will be updated regularly.
