This is a carefully researched book with well-designed methods, which presents a detailed and interesting comparison of the Akan communities of Côte d'Ivoire and Ghana. The basic argument of the book is that institutions of informal reciprocity, broadly construed as aid giving among community members for medical or school expenses and the like, differ between these communities, even though they share a common precolonial history and similar material environments. MacLean argues that Ivorians give more and to a narrower set of individuals. Their reciprocity practices are also more hierarchical than that of their Ghanaian counterparts who tend, in turn, to help each other out more among friends.
MacLean suggests that the distinct trajectories of colonial and postcolonial state formation of the two countries largely account for these differences, as they have mediated risks differently for each community. Informal reciprocity arrangements have responded to these divergent policies in different ways. Ivorians, whose state is more centralized, expect more social support from their state and thus focus their informal reciprocity among the family. In Ghana, the decentralized state is seen as a complement of communal efforts at providing welfare, resulting in more diversified patterns of informal reciprocity.
After presenting the cross-country variations in informal reciprocity in quantitative (chapter 2) and qualitative (chapter 3) ways, based on fieldwork in two Ivorian and two Ghanaian villages of the same region, MacLean relates them to differences in administration (chapter 4), service delivery (chapter 5) and agricultural policies (chapter 6). She then discusses their effects on local notions of citizenship (chapter 7), before concluding by offering some general observations based on her study (chapter 8).
Despite its interesting methods, MacLean's book falls short of its own expectations and claims. First, it lacks a compelling research question, arguing for the existence of a paradox where, I would argue, there is none. Second, while it makes a plausible claim about the effects of state trajectories on the features of local African communities, it is not an original one, nor does the book succeed in demonstrating a distinct causal linkage. Finally, its title is misleading, for the book barely touches on complex issues of citizenship and offers no broader inferences relevant to rural Africa as a whole.
The premise of the book—that the institutional variations on both sides of the border are paradoxical—is not particularly compelling. Most Africanist scholars would expect significant cross-country variations, irrespective of shared ethnicity. Paul Nugent's Smugglers, Secessionists and Loyal Citizens on the Ghana-Togo Frontier (2002) has shown that the Ewe astride the Ghana-Togo border feel stronger allegiance to their nation-states than to an Ewe nation; Daniel Posner's Institutions and Ethnic Politics in Africa (2005) demonstrates that political and demographic differences have led the Chewa and Tumbuka to coalesce in Zambia and compete in Malawi; and several Afrobarometer surveys show that public opinion varies largely across African countries (Michael Bratton et al., Public Opinion, Democracy and Market Reform in Africa [2005]). Only the most primordialist of scholars would expect cultural features to remain frozen through 130 years of colonial and postcolonial history. Tellingly, MacLean doesn't cite a single one. She thus tends to oversell her material, repeatedly calling her findings “puzzling” (pp. 7, 12, 13, 49, 99 [twice], 217), “unanticipated” (pp. 12, 14, 232), “surprising” (pp. 63, 65, 94, 95, 99, 166 [twice], 199, 228, 232), or “astonishing” (p. 232), whereas they were none of the above to this reviewer.
While the premise of the book may be less paradoxical than she believes, Informal Institutions and Citizenship in Rural Africa nevertheless offers a solid case study of the impact of national policies on local African communities. At the same time, most of its arguments are confirmatory rather than original. MacLean, for example, claims as one of her main contributions the insight that even weak states can affect local institutions, but Christian Lund (“Precarious Democratization and Local Dynamics in Niger: Micro Politics in Zinder,” Development and Change 32, no. 5 (2001): 845–69; “Bawku Is Still Volatile: Ethno-Political Conflict and State Recognition in North Ghana,” Journal of Modern African Studies 41, no. 4 (2003): 587–610), whose work she does not cite, has already demonstrated such capacity in Ghana and Niger, and Catherine Boone (Political Topographies of the African State: Territorial Authority and Institutional Choice [2003]), whom she does cite, observes it in Côte d'Ivoire. Moreover, while her argument that divergent state formation trajectories account for the transformation of local social capital is plausible, her country dummy does not by itself demonstrate it. As MacLean later discusses, diversification in crop production (cocoa in Côte d'Ivoire versus tomatoes in Ghana) also appears to have a significant effect but might only mildly relate to historical state trajectories. The two communities she studies also differ greatly in the amount of migrants they host, proportionally up to three times more numerous among the Ivorians (p. 45). While the presence of a large migrant minority might affect local bonds of reciprocity (and relates to the historical trajectory of the Ivorian state under former president Félix Houphouët-Boigny), MacLean does not account for it. Both of these variables would also be captured by country effects.
Finally, despite the title's promise of an analysis of citizenship and rural Africa, the book offers very little substantive discussion of citizenship beyond an otherwise very interesting survey of local perceptions of it, and offers no attempt to project findings to the rest of rural Africa (or even the rest of Ghana and Côte d'Ivoire). While a publisher's tendency to broaden the appeal of a title is to be expected (but can still be lamented), the book's lack of a robust discussion of citizenship is problematic given the role that access to citizenship has played in Côte d'Ivoire's recent history of political violence. As a matter of fact, the Akan whom MacLean studies were at the core of the production of the exclusionary ivoirité discourse, yet paradoxically might have eventually tilted the electoral balance on the side of “foreigner” Alassane Ouattara (misspelled as Outtara in the book, p. 224) in the 2010 elections. MacLean cannot of course be held liable for not analyzing the politics of the last few months, but there is nothing in her book that addresses the underlying political variables or helps us make sense of any of these events. Tellingly, the last ten years of Ivorian history are hardly mentioned and no attempt is made to make any inference from the earlier findings on the Ivorian state's trajectory. This could be due in part to the fact that the book is based on fieldwork that took place more than ten years ago (p. 11).
Despite these limitations, MacLean's book's main contribution lies in its original and carefully crafted survey material. Her data and focus group interviews paint a detailed picture of the local communities she studied. It is one that does Côte d'Ivoire no favor. Ivorian familial individualism appears almost dysfunctional, and the weak social fabric of the Ivorian villages gives pause. If MacLean's four villages are representative, the reader will struggle to resist a feeling that Ghana is in much better shape than Côte d'Ivoire, that its people are more adaptive, and its social foundations more conducive to development and democracy.
