This is an excellent book that will be of great interest to railroad historians. Schneider's detailed history of the demise of the Rock Island is the best account of the perversity of railroad regulation to appear since Albro Martin's classic Enterprise Denied was published in 1971. Martin's book is an overview of the entire industry and was written before the Staggers Act was passed in October of 1980.
Railroads have been part of the landscape of the United States since 1830. People have long had a love-hate relationship with trains. Their expansion before the Civil War was encouraged by state and local government and later by generous land grants from the federal government to build the Illinois Central and later still to build the pacific railroads. By the 1870s railroads were very unpopular but regarded as necessary to the economy. It was not until about 1900 that the network was finally rationalized into a few large systems that were for the most part well run and profitable. Regulation before World War I and then the growth of the highway system in the 1920s followed by the Depression undermined their profitability until World War II.
The Rock Island epitomized this long history. It was first chartered in 1847 and managed to survive until after World War II. It was rebuilt during and after its second bankruptcy from 1936 to 1948 and its future appeared to be bright. However, the Rock Island was eventually undermined by its geography. The Rock Island was a Midwestern railroad that did not reach either the Atlantic or Pacific seaboard. It did have a line down to the Gulf of Mexico through Dallas-Fort Worth to Houston and Galveston but otherwise it was landlocked. It served Chicago, Minneapolis-St. Paul, Des Moines, Kansas City, St. Louis, Denver, Oklahoma City, Little Rock, and numerous other cities. It was vital to farmers in Kansas who depended on the Rock Island to get their grain to market, but by the late 1950s the railroad was in decline. Management began to cut back on maintenance of track and equipment setting off the downward spiral of the railroad. As the physical plant deteriorated the railroad was forced to reduce the speed of its trains which in turn slowed down the delivery of grain and other products to their destinations.
To save itself the Rock Island agreed to a merger with the Union Pacific. The Union Pacific had been rebuilt by Edward Henry Harriman in the 1890s and early 1900s and had an excellent physical plant and was in sound financial condition. The Union Pacific wanted the northern territory of the Rock Island because it would give them easy access to Chicago. It was understood that the Union Pacific would have to spend a substantial sum to upgrade the Rock Island's physical plant. The southern territory of the Rock Island was to be sold off to either the Southern Pacific or the Santa Fe.
The merger proposal went to the ICC in late 1964 and the proposal quickly became a Dickensian Jarndyce v Jarndyce. Rival Midwestern railroads such as the Chicago and North Western intervened to oppose the merger. In the end the Interstate Commerce Commission approved the merger 11 years later after 48,000 pages of testimony and 200,000 pages of evidence. In the meantime the Rock Island slowly bled to death. Its physical plant continued to deteriorate. The ICC refused to let it exit the money-losing passenger train service into Chicago and the federal government refused to help. The Union Pacific finally backed out of the merger given the cost of fixing the now badly deteriorated physical plant and in 1975 the Rock Island was forced to file for its third bankruptcy.
The Rock Island probably should have been liquidated instead of being allowed to continue on for another five years. By 1975 the U.S. railroad system was in turmoil. The failure of the Penn Central in 1970 leading to, in effect, the nationalization of the property and its reorganization at huge expense to the taxpayers as Conrail in 1976 did not put Congress in the mood to form a Conrail of the Midwest. The bankruptcy of the Milwaukee Road in 1977 put further pressure on the Rock Island. Finally, the terrible winters in the late 1970s followed by a strike by two labor unions in 1979 finished off the Rock Island. The bankruptcy judge ordered the liquidation of the Rock Island in January of 1980, too late for the railroad to benefit from the deregulatory provisions of the Staggers Act. The Rock Island was the largest railroad as of 1980 to cease operations.
The story of the Rock Island has a remarkable ending. The liquidation was a great success. The physical plant was sold off for enough money so that the creditors were paid off and the remaining assets transferred to the Chicago Pacific Corporation which became a real estate holding company. It in turn was sold to the Maytag Corporation in 1988 and the remains of the Rock Island passed into history.
There is a clear lesson to be drawn from the history of the Rock Island: The road to regulatory hell is paved with good intentions. The ICC had long outlived its usefulness by the 1960s, but the political will to end it did not appear until after the disasters of the mid to late 1970s. Congress, the railroad labor unions, rivalries among the railroads themselves, all worked against reform. It took the determination of President Jimmy Carter and members of Congress who felt burned by the bankruptcy of the Penn Central, to finally end the ICC and deregulate the railroads.
Railroad deregulation has been a great success. The major Class I railroads are all profitable and the freight railroad system in the United States is the best in the world. Unfortunately, all of this was too late for the Rock Island.
