The Guest Author foreword rarely contributes much to a book, but on this occasion, young David Howard has made this reviewer's work much easier. He introduces the authors as previously experienced in producing such texts, indeed, whilst still very junior trainees. His other recommendation is that this is more than just a series of self-test questions, but also, in the detailed answers, a useful revision in itself.
The title indicates the DOHNS candidate as the target audience, but let us not forget the hurdle posed by the first part of the FRCS, later in training. This reviewer, six months ago, sat the latter written quiz and struggled. The final score of 71 per cent, for a 25 year consultant, was reassuring (and would have remained confidential if less so), but four trainees had scored higher in the same exam. There is more to MCQs, and especially EMQs, than pure clinical knowledge, therefore. Wording like ‘generally associated with’, double negatives such as ‘which of the following is not associated with the absence of’ and anything offering a choice of eponymous statistical tests can be daunting, especially when the clock is ticking.
There will always be quibbles. ‘Otitis externa is a recognised cause of facial palsy’ is here given as true, but only because of necrotising otitis externa. ‘Tinnitus is very rare in children’ is given as false, but only as it is under-reported. ‘OAEs cannot be used to diagnose central processing disorders’ is said to be false as, of course, higher pathways are not being tested. True. Mind you, if OAEs are preserved, in a patient with a poor pure tone audiogram, is the diagnosis not suggested? There will always be the ambiguities, however much the academics apply educational theory to question setting in order to test higher order thinking. This book is an excellent resource in preparing for this challenge. The reader will undoubtedly howl ‘That is not fair!’ every few pages, but welcome to the real world of MCQs and EMQs. Try this one. True or false? ‘A study has a type II error if there is a failure to reject the null hypothesis, when the null hypothesis is false.’ I counted six negative words in one sentence, but that is the reality faced.
This book is excellent value, with 178 pages, 150 MCQs and then 50 EMQs, but especially for the detailed discussion of each answer. Invaluable exam preparation, but do not leave it until the London train to the test centre – unless it is a very long journey or volcano dust is affecting the points.
