Even today the word ‘tropics’ brings to mind a set of significations for Western tourists: bright sunshine, lush vegetation, the need for vaccinations and the challenges of cross-cultural communication. Historians of science can now benefit from a more sophisticated and careful exploration of the genesis of ideas of tropicality. The two books under review significantly alter the perspectives derived from such theorists as Michel Foucault and Edward Said. Instead of seeing the emergence of a tropical view as a simple imposition of European ideas and institutions, through such technologies as the travel journal and photography, these books suggest that the idea of the tropics emerged out of the restless work of Europeans in immediate contact with the climate, people, natural history and topography of regions astride the equator. The creation of the tropics was a subjective process, which was linked to the intellectual formation of colonials in the field. It was unexpected and unpredictable, for the environment itself could play a part in unsettling European ideas and identities.
There is no intention here, however, to deny the power of the European imagination. David Arnold is particularly keen to stress this. For him the tropics were invented in order to legitimize colonial rule, even as rule over nature became a model for rule over Indians. In the period he studies, which witnessed the dramatic expansion of the territories under the East India Company's control, Arnold's natural historians and botanists were as much on the move as the armies of the regime, and their tenuous connections to the state mirrored the insecure status of colonialism. Yet this way of locking tropicality to colonialism is balanced out by other theoretical approaches, especially in Felix Driver and Luciana Martins's stimulating edited volume. Key buzzwords are ‘hybridity’, ‘contestation’, ‘boundaries’ and ‘contact zones’. The edited volume has three sections: ‘Voyages’, ‘Mappings’ and ‘Sites’. Throughout, the authors attempt to show how representations of tropicality circulated across space. Peter Hulme, for instance, carefully analyses the islands of Tahiti and Dominica as connected in a discourse of the tropics, exemplified by Captain Bligh's successful transportation of breadfruit from the Pacific to the Caribbean. The most persistent similarity in the portrayal of these islands pertained to the spontaneous generation of their natural bounty, and the implication that their residents could live an idle life of plenty. Despite the links between these two ‘sites’, both islands were positioned in opposite places in a dichotomous discourse on peaceableness and savagery. Dominica was inhabited by the cannibalistic Caribs, who were quite unlike their neighbours, the welcoming Arawaks on Hispaniola; Tahiti, however, was home to noble islanders, quite unlike the menacing Melanesians to the west. Tropicality was thus contradictory.
One of the delights of these books is the absorbing portraits they contain of men of science who were ‘on the spot’, to use a phrase which Claudio Greppi dissects for us in another essay. Greppi urges that the late eighteenth century saw the emergence of a privileged position for the traveller; the genre of landscape art was fused with experience derived by artists who voyaged in the company of surveyors, astronomers and meteorologists. By the early nineteenth century, men who traversed the far-flung reaches of empires felt they possessed a measure of authority which set them above metropolitan theorizers. Driver and Martins's very telling example of this trend is William Burchell, who travelled in Brazil, St Helena and South Africa. An illustration of his ‘African Waggon’ (1820) depicted many instruments crammed into a tight space together with the unmistakable British flag. This wagon was ‘not just a mobile laboratory … but an instrument itself, the rotations of its wheels providing a means of calculating the distances traveled’ (p. 68). Burchell's engravings of natural-historical specimens trumpeted ‘on-the-spot’ experience. For instance, his illustration ‘Group of plaintains from nature’ (1807) includes drops of the plaintain's juice made to stain the page, and annotated, ‘not blood but drops of Plantain juice’. Driver and Martins place Burchell in a class of collectors who tried to improve themselves, in the face of enormous challenges, and even in the midst of death in the tropics.
Arnold's well-crafted book can also be read as a biographical dictionary of science in early nineteenth-century India. Nevertheless, for him, the figure who comes to epitomize how India was cast into the discourse of the tropics is Joseph Hooker, who travelled to the Himalayas in the late 1840s. There, Hooker was struck by the presence of ‘tropical’ plants, and stretched the stock of tropical images that he had grown up with to encompass this region. Arnold notes how Hooker sought for Humboldtian language. Indeed, Alexander von Humboldt was the model for many of the individuals who come to view in these two books. The fabulous picture that Michael Dettlebach provides in the edited volume of Humboldt as self-experimenter is especially helpful in theorizing the relationship between a career in the field and attitudes to the body and reason. On one occasion Humboldt insisted on travelling on foot, rather than being carried by porters, and experimented on mosquito venom by pricking himself and then rubbing ground-up mosquitoes into his wounds. Since on-the-spot experience was privileged by travelling naturalists and utilized to define their identities and even the physicality of their bodies, life stories can thus reveal a great deal about attitudes to the tropics.
The way these authors deal with language is particularly praiseworthy. In the early chapters of his book, which analyse the birth pangs of a tropical view, Arnold attends to ideologies such as romanticism, improvement and orientalism. He begins by investigating images of violent and speedy death which were attached to India, for instance through medical topographies and exaggerated concern with sati (widow-burning). This empire of affect gripped middle-class men who resided in India, who wrote in nostalgic and isolated terms to their mothers, wives and sisters at home of the natural history of the subcontinent. Those with botanical interests sought to bring death under leash by studying nature. The ease with which Arnold studies language is especially clear in his dissection of romanticism; in travellers' attention to ruins, jungles, wastelands and historicism, they saw the land through the guise of romantic traditions. Yet, Arnold urges, romanticism gave way at times to improvement, and efforts to introduce efficient agriculture. It was from this context that India was tropicalized.
Given the subtlety of the argument that these authors propose, and the familiarity of the older and simple argument that Europeans othered the rest of the world, it comes as no surprise that different authors sometimes fail to keep their balance. Sometimes there is more emphasis on the bringing of images from Europe to the field and the power of the centre, whilst at other times the mediation and circulation of ideas of the tropics and the recalibration of the metropole in the light of tropical visions is emphasized more strongly. But why, one wonders, has none of these authors paid serious attention to non-European traditions and sources concerned with topography and vegetation? As Denis Cosgrove notes in his astute conclusion to the edited volume, ‘we risk perpetuating the silencing of voices speaking from within tropical space’ (p. 198).
