The title of Alan Read's latest book consciously echoes Rosalind Krauss's 1979 essay on works of sculpture that challenge the perceived limits of the medium. Read makes a related claim about theatre, examining its potentially troubling annexation of its near-cognate, performance. The title might also refer to the wide-ranging areas of human endeavor that this book of theatre criticism considers, from psychoanalysis to animal husbandry. The subtitle, “Seven Approaches to Performance,” should sound familiar, in that the book is a reemplotment of Richard Southern's 1962 Seven Ages of Theatre. Readers may recall Southern's delightful illustrations of play spaces and theatrical conventions from around the world and across many different time periods. Fifty years on, Read's book offers a thorough if idiosyncratic survey of performance-inflected theatrical practice, though strangely confined here to London. The seven chapters, or “approaches,” helpfully link theatre and performance to archaeology, anthropology, theology, economics, legal studies, sociology, and political theory, all the while pursuing special questions of audience and community. Read argues that “the order and history of [theatre] is irritated and disturbed by the electricity of [performance]” (xx).
Within each of his chapters, Read captures something unique and illuminating about theatre/performance in a specific mode. Chapter 1, “Pre-Historical & Archaeological,” opens with ca. 40,000 b.c.e. cave paintings only to arrive finally at the ceramic tile of the Young Vic Theatre through the interesting idea of a “Ceramic Age” (17). In Chapter 2, “Pastoral & Anthropological,” an open-air performance of Oedipus Rex in 429 b.c.e. Athens takes us away from London only to return us to it—using the idea of the movement of animals by a human herder, known since the early twentieth century by the delightful term “transhumance.” In Chapter 3, “Theological & Historical,” Read reads the 2011–12 Occupy London OWS solidarity action in the churchyard of St. Paul's Cathedral alongside a historical account of the Strand that begins in 1613. In the process, he offers an exacting and perspicacious account of the several hundred years of history sedimented in that place. Further stops (points of departure, really) occur in 1720, 1889, 1974, and 2012.
Especially commendable is Chapter 4, “Digital & Technological,” which wonderfully clasps and unclasps Jonathan Pryce's hands, the laying on of hands, and handicrafts in service of exploring the precariousness of persons. It moves back and forth from a biblical story about healing to Diderot's Paradox of the Actor, to terra-cotta bas-relief images in a French cathedral (in Diderot's hometown) that have lost their hands, to an actor whose hands undermine his otherwise successful portrayal of Lear in a 2012 production at the Almeida. Juxtaposing these unexpected elements can create new and invigorating syntheses of the already known, unless the elements are not heterogeneous enough to have the desired, destabilizing impact. Where Read does employ arcane linkages, they aren't always productively implausible. That is, associations are in the end revealed to be little short of essential, rendering the book oddly more staid than it feels while reading. Accompanying the text are thirty-four fascinating and at times disturbing images by Beryl Robinson that exhort us to “look differently” (254). Robinson transforms objects, performers, and architectures into ghostly and indistinct line drawings that look a little like the results of a strange Photoshop procedure. This technique has a leveling effect that unifies Robinson's disparate material but also encourages me to consider whether a similar dynamic is at work in Read's text: that Theatre in the Expanded Field is less collage and more collation.
Alongside theatrical events, Read draws on a range of personal experiences, from 1980s community building in the Docklands to a stretch in public relations and community outreach at the Institute of Contemporary Arts in the 1990s, to a more recent extended period of immersion in academia, first at the University of Roehampton and now at King's College. Whereas the author's previous books, Theatre, Intimacy & Engagement: The Last Human Venue (2008) and Theatre & Everyday Life: An Ethics of Performance (1993), might be said to explore community formation and maintenance, Theatre in the Expanded Field suggests that “community” is almost certainly not the best word for this area of research. Read points us in the direction of terms and ideas from Giorgio Agamben, Jean-Luc Nancy, Jacques Rancière, Paul Virilio, and the latest import, Roberto Esposito, whose idea of immunity versus community has become irreplaceable since the 2011 publication in English of his 2002 book Immunitas. In the end, we are convinced: theatre is a problem, but it is our problem. Performance rubs up against theatre to make it more engrossing and less satisfying, more like torture, and less like a ratification of the status quo. Indeed, “our willingness to enter the contract of performance stems from a genetic preference for immunity from involvement. That is what going to the theatre is all about. It is not a pathology, is not a disease of outmoded theatre; it is theatre” (193).
Read utilizes an impressive array of sources. Interestingly, the bibliography features a list of “Primary and Production Sources,” a somewhat new convention of which I am wholly in favor: not only promoting productions to the same rank as monographs but also making a handy reference for the scope of a work. A quick glance corroborates the impression that this book is undeniably about theatre and performance in a very specific geographic region serviced by Transport for London, with a few important exceptions. The variety and quality of these items can only leave me to rue Britannia. Never have I felt like such an unwanted guest at the London theatre banquet as I did while reading this book. This exclusion is doubly debilitating since the theatrical examples in Theatre in the Expanded Field travel from present to past and back again in a circuit that passes through London in Read's footsteps. Which is to say, the book is not so inviting as it might seem, though it is a series of very tempting irritations and missed connections, and to Read's mind that is a good thing: the best outcome of considering performance practices alongside and within theatre.
