It is almost fifty years since Pope John XXIII incorporated the antiquities of the Lateran Palace within the Musei Vaticani. After teaming up with Philipp von Zabern, and under the watchful eye of Georg Daltrop and Hansgeorg Oehler at the Forschungsarchiv für Antike Plastik in Cologne, the Vatican published its first landmark catalogue of the Lateran collection in 1991. Fifteen years after her first volume (Band 1.1, on Roman grave reliefs, altars and urns), Sinn delivers the latest instalment in the series, now said to be in the ‘zweiter konzeptioneller Phase der wissenschaftlichen Erschließung der Skulpturen’ (7). The press might have changed (Reichert Verlag took over in 2004), but there is little difference in tangible quality: the series continues in its flagship yellow-cloth binding, with the paper and finish almost as good as it was in the 1990s.
The book begins with an editorial foreword and a short introduction explaining its rationale. Although S. is responsible for the devil's share of the entries, a host of other authors are brought in to discuss odd monuments or classes — Langner on marble furniture, for example, Busch on stone vessels, and Xagorari-Gleißner on some of the so-called ‘Oriental cultic’ pieces (to name but a few). The catalogue proper then begins on p. 17. It encompasses a motley crew of 197 objects in just over 300 pages. We begin with seventeen ‘original Greek’ statues/reliefs — among them, three fragments from the Parthenon metopes, frieze and pediments, a well-known early Classical acrolith marble head, and a large votive to Asklepios. The second and largest section then deals with ‘Reliefgeschmückte Gattungen römischer Lebenskultur’ (nos 18–168), a sort of scholarly counterpart to the car-boot sale: all sorts of objects are included — from oscilla, masks and lamps, to altars, furniture and reliefs of ‘scenes from daily life’. Two final sections deal with ‘Monumente orientalischer Kulte’ (nos 169–191) and post-Renaissance fakes (so-called ‘neuzeitliche Reliefs’, nos 192–197). A final set of concordances rounds off the volume (including a concordance with Benndorf and Schöne's 1867 catalogue); there is also an abridged index of names and themes.
The volume (like the series) embodies the German catalogue at both its best and worst. What it offers is close, descriptive, analytical engagement, accompanied by a superb album of high-quality photographs (in addition to the 112 plates, 44 drawings are incorporated into the text; just sometimes, the editors have scrimped on photographic size, and some objects go without illustration altogether — e.g. nos 156–162, presumably because these are ‘ohne sichere Gattungzuweisung’). Each entry follows the same tried and tested formula: first comes the information about provenance; then the size, bibliography (although many pieces are published here for the first time), material and extant state; finally, after the lengthy description, we find discussion of date and a deluge of detailed endnotes (no. 38 has a hefty seventy-seven notes attached). It is a conservative presentational mode. But it would be wrong to think questions of social and cultural context are necessarily eclipsed. The majority of the pieces have no recorded provenance: the numerous iconographic and stylistic comparanda therefore construct art-historical ‘contexts’ of their own. Also noteworthy is the art historical interest in Nachleben (as in no. 192, compared to an engraving by Marco Dente da Ravenna, c. 1520). When done well, as here, the catalogue has the potential to take readers in all sorts of new and exciting interpretative directions.
That said, Anglo-Saxon readers will find many of their own intellectual interventions under-represented in the volume. For all the scholarly furore in the Anglophone world, Kopienkritik flourishes here — reflected not only in the book's structure (Greek before Roman), but also in its thematic organization (e.g. section V.A.1, on ‘Kopien nach Originalen des 5. und 4. Jhs. v. Chr.’). What slightly disappoints is less the descriptions than the unstated positivist assumptions that precede them. Just how, for example, are we to distinguish between ‘Themen der Mythologie und sakrale Idealszenen’ (nos 23–37) and ‘Themen der literarischen Bildung’ (no. 38)? Still more problematic is this all-encompassing category of ‘Reliefgeschmückte Gattungen römischer Lebenskultur’ in the first place (a concession to Tonio Hölscher's Roman ‘Bilderwelt’ and ‘Lebenswelt’, perhaps?). My anxiety here is not just about how these ‘Gattungen’ are discussed — how they are organized, sub-organized and sub-sub-organized within ever smaller (and more problematic) taxonomic types. Rather, I should like to know why the objects catalogued in the first part of the book are not labelled ‘Gattungen griechischer Lebenskultur’ in the same way as the Roman artefacts that are subsequently discussed. At stake here are residual assumptions about Greek art in relation to Roman, indebted above all to Winckelmann in the eighteenth century. For all its objective façade, the catalogue is never as value-free as it appears: the very notion of ‘griechische Originalskulptur’ testifies as much.
These larger ideological questions should not detract from the many virtues of the book. The volume will be a must-have for every serious research library, and S. is to be congratulated on carrying out the task with such meticulous aplomb. As the German Classical archaeological tradition knows full well, it is only after formally engaging with an object that we can tackle its various socio-cultural meanings. Anglophone scholarship might diss the genre of the catalogue. But we abandon its formalist rigour at our peril.
