This is a grassroots history of a sophisticated variety – written with verve, replete with an evocative reconstruction of a “lost” world, and made all the more compelling by a concurrent commitment to demonstrating its relevance to national political and demographic trends. From Bible Belt to Sunbelt is a significant addition to the fast-expanding body of literature on the emergence of modern American conservatism. The backdrop to the book will be familiar to scholars of this process: the remarkable transformation of the South and Southwest, which gathered momentum in the decades after World War II, leading to the emergence of the “Sunbelt” – a region defined by rapid economic growth (albeit often “piggy-backing” on massive federal investment), an expanding population, and a vibrant conservative political movement produced by a complex matrix of rising affluence, racial issues, regional culture, religiosity, disputes over the influence of organized labor, and, of course, the tumult of American society and politics in the 1960s and 1970s. Consequently, in the past half-century the Sunbelt has also been the heartland of the Republican right.
Dochuk's book homes in on the epicentre of Sunbelt conservatism – southern California – and in particular on the political implications of a “plain-folk” evangelical ethos, forged largely in the “western South,” but transplanted westward as part of this dramatic regional transformation (so dramatic, in fact, that by the late 1960s California had more southern-born residents than Arkansas). This ethos, Dochuk argues, was grounded in a heritage of frontier individualism, evangelicalism, and populist antagonism towards “elites.” It is the ways in which in these elements informed the region's politics that define the narrative of the book, which spans the period from the Depression to the Reagan presidency and segues between the story of individual participants in this transplantation and the history of religious leaders and organizations, educational institutions (notably including Pepperdine College), and political organizations (from the “Ham and Eggs” movement of the early postwar years to the Republican Party of 1980).
Dochuk devotes greatest attention to evangelical religion – a focus informed by his desire to challenge much of the existing literature on modern conservatism which has purportedly “cordoned off evangelicalism as an interest that nudged politicians and inflected politics only sporadically as a voice of protest from the periphery” (xxii). Rather, he insists, it was at the core of these individuals' worldview, it had obvious implications for social and cultural conservatism, and it provided a framework for coordinated action and for the dissemination of ideas.
Especially illuminating is Dochuk's analysis of the period prior to the 1960s – not least because this section provides a backstory to southern Californian grassroots conservatism which was curiously lacking in Lisa McGirr's otherwise excellent Suburban Warriors (2001). Even as the narrative proceeds and the contours of the Californian right become more familiar (thanks to McGirr, Matthew Dallek, and others), Dochuk's deployment of evangelicalism as an analytical lens ensures that the book maintains a distinctive perspective.
While the book does well to acknowledge the ways in which the development of modern conservatism relates to the activities of business conservatives, regional economic transformation, labor disputes, and the ability of evangelicals to incorporate economic conservatism into their politics, it says relatively little about how they managed to negotiate the deep-rooted contradictions between what might crudely be termed the two wings of conservative thought – economic and social conservatism. Yet the ability to appeal to both simultaneously has been a defining feature of the modern conservative movement's success. In addition, a more explicit effort to position the study in relation to McGirr's earlier work could have served to further tease out a number of critical issues – not least how we might measure the relative significance of evangelicalism and a “plain-folk” ethos to Californian conservatism, when compared with the issues of, for example, rising prosperity and wider socioeconomic shifts (both of which McGirr stressed more forcefully).
