Elizabeth Özdalga's Late Ottoman Society is the first book in a new series undertaken by SOAS and RoutledgeCurzon that features the latest disciplinary approaches to Middle Eastern studies. It is a result of the The Ottoman Intellectual Heritage Conference, organized by the Swedish Institute in Istanbul in 2001. The editor, a sociology professor at Middle East Technical University, was director of the Swedish Institute at the time. She is well known for her work on Islamic movements in Turkey and Central Asia.
In her preface, Özdalga bemoans the lack of interest among Turkish intellectuals in the social and political problems plaguing their country, for instance, the Kurdish question, the situation of universities, and the function of governmental bodies. Turkish intellectuals, she argues, are reluctant to take positions on such questions. She asks whether it was the same in the past, the key question of the symposium and therefore of this book.
Özdalga claims that the result of the modernization process that began with the proclamation of Tanzimat in 1839 is not only administrative and economic, but it also involves educational institutions and ideologies. Modern intellectuals identified themselves with nationalism. It is not an exaggeration to state that the ideological variety of the late Ottoman period gave shape to the intellectual climate of the early republican era. However, this fact was neglected for a long time, and in order to defend the new regime, only negative aspects of the past were emphasized. Even though it seems contradictory in such historiography, although the classical age (1300–1600) of the Ottoman Empire was glorified, the period of decline was explained away as a result of external more than internal forces. In recent years there have been some attempts to fill the gap.
This book consists of ten articles that aim to more closely examine the intellectual life of the late Ottoman period. The articles can be classified into four topical areas: modernist thinkers, conservative learned men (ulema), education, and printing.
Şükrü Hanioğlu, a well-known historian who has produced several important works on the Union and Progress Party, contributed “Blueprints for a Future Society: Late Ottoman Materialists on Science, Religion, and Art.” He focuses here on Beşir Fuad, Abdullah Cevdet, and Baha Tevfik, and analyzes the influence of French and German materialism on the Ottoman intellectuals. Erik-Jan Zürcher, in “Ottoman Sources of Kemalist Thought,” also focuses on three important Ottoman intellectuals of the transition period—Ahmet Rıza, Ziya Gökalp, and Abdullah Cevdet—and claims that both Young Turk ideology and Kemalism were strongly influenced by French positivism. Ahmet Cevdet Pasha was one of the most important late-Ottoman intellectuals who affected modern Turkey in other aspects. In “Whom Did Ahmed Cevdet Represent?” Christoph Neumann emphasizes that even though Cevdet was not a nationalist in the present sense, his way of venerating the concept of the state still has a significant effect on modern Turkish political culture.
İsmail Kara is a well-known scholar of Islamic mysticism and Islamism during the late Ottoman period. In “Turban and Fez: Ulama as Opposition,” he analyzes the situation of the Ottoman learned men in 1886. It is well known that in that year the ulema joined in opposition with the Young Turks against Sultan Abdülhamit II. The ulema did not represent a homogenous group. Many supported Abdülhamit and his policies. However, by publishing pamphlets and journal articles, many of those in exile began to cooperate with the opposition. By using religious motifs, they legitimized the opposition. Focusing on the pamphlets they published, Kara claims that as a result of the discussions a group of modern intellectuals emerged from the ulema ranks. Jakob Skovgaard-Petersen, in “Levantine State Muftis: An Ottoman Legacy,” analyzes the situation of learned men in the late Ottoman period from another point of view. Focusing on some important muftis in Beirut and Damascus, he explains the process of introducing modernism to these learned men and how a modern conservative intellectual class emerged after the end of Ottoman rule in those regions, a period of about a century.
Adeeb Khalid, in “Pan-Islamism in Practice: The Rhetoric of Muslim Unity and its Uses,” defines Pan-Islamism as a kind of protonationalism and describes it as a political, as much as a religious, movement. Khalid classifies it and analyzes it in terms of religious fanaticism—as it is understood in today's Europe—Ottoman state policy, and the form of solidarity that binds Muslim elites to each other.
Akşin Somel, in “Christian Community Schools During the Ottoman Reform Period,” studies the process by which educated children of those groups learned about the European Enlightenment, individualism, the idea of progress, and, therefore, about nationalism. He also examines the role of missionary schools in that process. Nathalie Clayer, who is a well-known scholar on Islam in the Balkans, in her article on “Albanian Students of the Mekteb-i Mülkiye: Social Networks and Trends of Thought,” explores the situation of the Albanian graduates of this very important school that helped form late Ottoman-period elites during the reign of Abdülhamit II and especially in the years following the establishment of the Albanian state. According to her research, one half of the Albanian graduates of that important school went to Albania, either after Albania's independence or the dispersion of the Ottoman Empire, while the other half remained in the Ottoman territories and served the Ottomans and, later, the Turkish republic. Clayer also provides biographies of eighty-one Albanian graduates of the Mekteb-i Mülkiye.
Elizabeth B. Frierson's “Women in Late Ottoman Intellectual History” describes a women's periodical, the Hanımlara Mahsus Gazete, published in Istanbul between 1895 and 1909. This periodical survived for a long time by avoiding politics—in an era of strict press control—and by appealing to a women's readership from the middle and upper class. The periodical supported reform movements of the day, especially in the field of women's education and entry into the professions. In this way, the periodical served a preparatory role in the development of women's rights during the republican period.
Johann Strauss's article “‘Kütüp ve Resail'i Mevkute’: Printing and Publishing in a Multi-Ethnic Society,” deals with Ottoman press life, covering published periodicals and books in Turkish, Arabic, Persian, Armenian, Bulgarian, Greek, French, Italian, English, and German after 1880. Strauss stresses that non-Muslims had a dominant role in the press life of Istanbul until the beginning of World War I, and as a result of the imperial culture, those printing activities in different languages affected each other.
Almost all of the articles are based on primary sources and archival materials and highlight the foreign influences, continuity, and interruptions in Turkish cultural and intellectual history during the late Ottoman and early Republican periods. The collection also contains important articles about the intellectual and cultural histories of Albanian, Arab, and Christian communities under the Ottoman umbrella, which shed light on their coexistence and mutual influences within imperial culture. The book is significantly enriched by pictures and documents collected from several libraries and archives. Readers concerned with these subjects should not neglect this book, for which Özdalga is to be greatly congratulated.
