In an essay of 1625, Francis Bacon observed that there is no topic ‘less handled, and more worthy to be handled, than th[at] of fame’ (The Essays or Counsels, Civil and Moral, ed. B. Vickers (1999), 132). Plus ça change, plus c'est la même chose. Both the concept of fama itself and the facets of its rich post-classical reception have long fascinated scholars — as attested, for instance, by P. Boitani's Chaucer and the Imaginary World of Fame (1984) — yet there has been a marked twenty-first-century surge of critical interest in this topic. G. Guastella's thoughtful and engaging Word of Mouth represents a significant contribution to a vibrant and rapidly expanding body of classical and medieval fama-scholarship that includes not only P. Hardie's similarly wide-ranging monograph Rumour and Renown: Representations of Fama in Western Literature (2012), but also T. Fenster and D. L. Smail (eds), Fama: The Politics of Talk and Reputation in Medieval Europe (2003), I. Davis and C. Nall (eds), Chaucer and Fame: Reputation and Reception (2015) and S. Kyriakidis (ed.), Libera Fama: An Endless Journey (2016). The majority of these recent works have anchored their analyses in the seminal poetic treatments of Fama by Virgil and Ovid. Word of Mouth turns out to be no exception. Although G.’s introduction opens with an example drawn from post-classical visual culture (i.e. a 1586 engraving by Hendrik Goltzius) and the book comes to the Augustan duo somewhat circuitously, it is Aeneid 4 and Metamorphoses 12 that increasingly emerge as key points of reference as we progress through the ten chapters of this study.
Ch. 1 inventively seeks to historicise issues of space and communication, particularly as crystallised in the imagined flights of Greco-Roman antiquity's divine messengers. In light of the aforementioned uptick of post-millennial interest in fama, it is, perhaps, curious that G. suggests that the ‘image of the flight of words’ as a ‘metaphor has lost most of its appeal’ in our own time (15). Where he submits that the potency of such imagery has been ‘amply eclipsed by the power of digital technology’, it seems equally plausible that the rapidly changing dimensions of our contemporary communicative landscape may be, in fact, fuelling the current aetas Famae in which his own monograph participates (15).
Chs 2, 3 and 4 lay useful conceptual, lexicographical and theoretical groundwork. Ch. 2 unpacks the Latin implications of fama and argues — contra Hardie — that ‘cases where the word fama indicates rumours and those where it refers to renown […] should be kept clearly distinct’ (64). Whereas ch. 3, largely concerned with testimony, distinguishes fama-rumour's ‘tangled mixture of true and false’ from the ‘ordinary, correct form of the transmission of information’ (67), ch. 4 seeks to position this argument in light of recent anthropological and sociological theory. ‘[T]he only feature’, G. avers, ‘that makes ancient rumour transmission different from the contemporary process is that it was exclusively oral/aural’ — a fact that he may too cursorily dismiss as being ‘of minor importance’ since the ‘differences arising from the new possibilities provided by contemporary technology do not change the nature and dynamics of the phenomenon’ (113). Moreover, it is not always entirely clear how G.’s suggestive position in ch. 4 that ‘we are quite justified in applying ideas from some of the most recent theoretical studies — with all due caution — to the context of antiquity’ aligns with what he recurrently highlights elsewhere in this book as the great ‘anthropological distance’ that vitally separates our twenty-first-century communicative contexts from those of the classical world (13, 15, 63).
Aeneid 4 and Metamorphoses 12 begin to make significant appearances in chs 5 and 6, which sit at the book's centre. While ch. 5 opposes the (un)reliability of fama and rumores, which ‘exist in the absence of a concrete possibility of verification or any assumption of responsibility’, with the auctoritas vested in identifiable auctores (139), ch. 6 makes some keen observations about Fama’s physiognomy and habitat as classically conceived. Following from this, ch. 7 shifts focus in two important ways. Firstly, G. begins to tackle fama-renown (the personification of which, he argues, ‘was invented in the Middle Ages’), especially as this concept relates to gloria (186). Secondly, G.’s chronological scope widens at this juncture to address so-called medieval treatments of fama by Boccaccio, Petrarch and others. It is worth noting here that G.’s definition of the ‘medieval’ throughout this study is quite broad, apparently encompassing even the Italian Cinquecento. Ch. 8 continues this line of examination: it presents a fascinating and lavishly illustrated analysis of Fama’s iconographical intersections with Gloria in visual culture. Whereas earlier analyses pointedly segregate fama-rumour from fama-renown, ch. 9 reunites these concepts. Drawing on a wide range of fourteenth-, fifteenth- and sixteenth-century examples, G. contends that ‘[a] complex process of contamination ensured the eventual combination of these figures into a unique image of Fama’ (319). Finally, ch. 10 presents a summative close reading of such ‘contamination’ at work in Chaucer's much-discussed House of Fame.
To briefly conclude, then, the great diversity of sources drawn upon throughout Word of Mouth is a testament to this book's ambitious scope, and G.’s careful interpretations of primary textual and visual sources will, no doubt, provide much fodder for future work in the growing interdisciplinary subfield of fama-studies.
