Following the 11 September 2001 attacks, President George W. Bush's response set the tone that defined his presidential years. The American public was told that the United States was attacked because it was morally superior: “Western” values of freedom and human rights were under threat by an antagonist “Muslim” civilization that opposed them. Of most importance, critics were discouraged from questioning the context and motives behind the 9/11 attacks. All such explanations were viewed as potentially legitimizing the violent events, and there was a narrow space for debate beyond the dogmas of clashing civilizations. Against this background, Tahir Abass's edited volume Islamic Political Radicalism: A European Perspective makes an important and timely intervention on Islamic radicalism and, to be more specific, on Britain after the July 2005 London attacks.
The editor opens the book by bringing the reader's attention to the historical dimension, in which “over the last two hundred years . . . Islam and Muslims have had to counter the imperial and colonial onslaught” (pp. 4–5). The collective task of the authors is to examine Islamic political radicalism among European-born Muslims in their cultural, economic, social, and political contexts. The book explores often-neglected topics, such as the challenges faced by Muslim migrants to Europe after World War II in the form of racism, prejudice, inhabitancy in alienated neighborhoods, and attendance in poorer schools. Authors also examine the second generation's difficulty in entering labor markets and participating as full citizens in local and national politics, in addition to the persistent intergenerational tensions on issues related to language, marriage, and values.
The book is divided into four parts. In Part I, a critical eye is dedicated to three contested concepts that dominate discourse on Islam and Muslims: terrorism (irhāb), witness (shahīd), and the global Muslim community (umma). Jorgen Nielsen discusses “terrorism” as a subject of analysis and a discourse. He traces the evolution and political usage of the term in both English and Arabic. Edward Lifton seeks to contextualize the attraction of youth to radical Islam from the vantage point of clinical psychology within a political-economy context. He probes the term shahīd, which he associates with honorable self-sacrifice (and not with martyrdom), and compares the concept to similar ones in the Christian tradition and the Sri Lankan independence movement as well as to Japanese Kamikaze conceptions of self-sacrifice. At the same time, he points out that many Muslims view violent acts by radical Islamists as murder (and not self-sacrifice). Ismail Patel understands the term umma to mean having sympathy with co-religionists. This notion exists in many other ethnic communities and faiths, including Christianity and Judaism, yet its presence in Islam is perceived with fear and suspicion. Finally, Patel poses a question in critique of the discrimination faced by Arabs and Muslims: “If . . . we imagine Palestinians as a non-Muslim white people, would we expect the response to the occupation of their land and to injustices and expulsions to be any less than the reaction of Muslim Palestinians?” (p. 43).
In the four chapters of Part II, the authors explore the European context. Sara Silvestri asserts that European perceptions of Islam and Muslims have been largely determined by critical events in the international political arena in the 20th century. Of most importance, she discusses the debate surrounding Turkey's inclusion in the European Union and argues that accepting Turkey as part of Europe would mean that Islamism could be a legitimate political actor in E.U. politics. Haris Aziz contributes a timely chapter dealing with anti-Semitism among radical Islamists, emphasizing the important position Jews hold within the Islamic tradition and the many historical examples of coexistence between the two religious communities. He asserts that “Muslims engaging in anti-Semitic discourse are contradicting Islamic values” (p. 72). Galina Yemelianova's chapter brings us back to the question of definitions. She makes an excellent and concise presentation on the diverse Islamic practices and ideologies in ex-Soviet Central Asia by looking at the tensions and competition among them (particularly those between Wahhabis and Sufis). Alok Mukhopadhyay's chapter would have made an excellent introduction to the volume because it covers essential background information. It also stresses the importance of education and textbooks for mainstream European societies and Muslim communities to promote understanding between them and to realize their shared future in Europe.
Earlier in the book, Abbas argues that 7 July 2005 (7/7) shifted race politics in Britain by placing Islam and Muslims under “sharp focus” (p. 8). Britain held Muslims responsible for crime, education, unemployment, and social tensions in the country, as well as for international terrorism and violence. Part III is a rejoinder to these claims and offers excellent theoretically oriented discussions of the multifaceted aspects of the British context with an eye on the 7/7 London attacks. Daud Abdullah starts this part of the book with the effects of Zionism and Israel on the radical politicization of British Muslims. Gabrielle Marranci provides an in-depth case study of Scottish Muslims and their understanding of justice and social morality as they encounter discrimination and negotiate their identities in Scotland. Sadek Hamid presents the case of Hizb al-Tahrir and its ideological background, goals, and activities in Britain. It is noteworthy that those responsible for the 7/7 attacks were British Muslims with a connection to the city of Bradford, to which two chapters are dedicated. Marie Macey critically examines the way in which Islam is constructed as an ethnic component of Pakistani identity in Britain and discusses the way Muslims feel they are being attacked because of their adherence to Islam. Gurchathen Sanghera and Suruchi Thapar-Bjorkert's chapter discusses the reaction of Bradford Muslims to Islamophobia through the lens of gender. Indeed, an interesting debate on the meaning and challenges of masculinity among Muslim youth emerges in this chapter, a topic discussed in Abbas's chapter as well. Akil Awan examines radicalism in the context of increased religiosity on a personal, group, and transnational level.
Part IV discusses various aspects of British policy in the aftermath of the 7/7 attacks. It is notable that following 7/7, Prime Minister Tony Blair echoed George W. Bush in interpreting the attacks as a threat to “our way of life.” Salma Yaqoob's final chapter highlights the fact that many British Muslims believed that the attacks were a response to the atrocities conducted in Iraq. It is also notable that, long before the occurrence of the attacks, British government reports attributed the rise of Islamic radicalism in Britain to the war. The book closes with the remark that the radicalization of some European Muslims is due to global injustices and makes an urgent plea for change in European foreign policy toward the global Muslim community.
The book successfully brings to the foreground the conditions and reasons for the radicalization of Muslims and has few shortcomings. Although the book focuses on radicalism, the reader is left without a sense of what “radical” or “moderate” means. Both are relative and manipulated terms. The term “radicalism” is only examined in the chapters by Spalek and Yemelianova, the latter of whom explores different Islamic theological interpretations of political ideologies. Furthermore, the book does not thoroughly address the agency and inner dynamics within the Muslim communities in question. Muslims are largely represented as reacting to alienation, imperialism, colonialism, or other forms of state violence as they search for identity, meaning, and belonging. Muslim youth are portrayed as vulnerable to exploitation by a few radical Islamists. It is therefore commendable that Mukhopadhyay calls on Muslims to take responsibility for challenging radical Islamists and their claims to represent Islam and Muslims in Europe and elsewhere.
In discussing radical trends among European Muslims, it would have been helpful for the authors to mention alternative Muslim reactions to “radicalism,” especially because many Muslims are well integrated into European political, economic, social, and cultural life. One wonders about Muslims who are active in fighting discrimination and injustice without resorting to radicalism and those who challenge radicalism from within their communities. While the authors argue that European foreign policies have been violent and unjust, Makhopadhyay points out that the largest antiwar demonstration in European history took place in 2003, just before the U.S.–British invasion of Iraq. Muslims therefore are not alone in seeking just and equitable alternatives to the status quo in Europe, a fact that deserved attention in the book.
The book's primary contribution is in transcending the orientalist tendency to focus on Islamic theology as the source of radical Islam, instead approaching the debate from the perspective of political economy, history, and international politics. The book therefore challenges the methods by which Islam and Muslims have been understood and represented by the general public. With an activist tone, the authors take to task mainstream discourses on Islam and Muslims through a critical multidisciplinary approach that serves as a valuable source for policymakers and an introductory survey for students. By employing historical and social scientific analyses, the book allows for a grounded understanding of the experiences of radical segments of Europe's Muslim population in a human and humanistic way.
