John Bell's book American Puppet Modernism proves to be a consistently engaging collection of connected essays tracing and analyzing the development of puppet performance in the United States, from the propagandistic John Stevens's Sioux War Panorama of 1862 to the post–cold war interventionist activity of the Bread and Puppet Theatre. One's initial impression that the book depends largely on a number of previously published pieces (six of the twelve chapters have already appeared in some version) gives way to a conviction that they make up a coherent whole, grounded by a pair of key concerns.
Throughout the book, Bell articulates an undisguised fascination with the material nature of puppets. His last chapter, “Old and New Materials: Wood, Paper, Metal, Plastic, Bone,” recapitulates a basic interest in the near-palpable viability of the subject that sustains him throughout. As in the case of leather shadow puppets found in some traditional societies in China, Java, and Turkey, material that had once been alive (wood, leather, cloth, bone), when fashioned into lifelike human or animal shapes manifests “a kind of reinstallation of soul into once-living matter” (220), achieving an uncanny vitality that carries over to human-made materials like plastic and metal. Behind Bell's explicit focus on the shaping influence of modernism lies a genuine love for the puppet qua puppet.
Reading Bell's description, I remembered the life-size, sailor-suited bunraku puppet representing the son of Cio-Cio-San and Lieutenant Pinkerton in Anthony Minghella's 2005 Metropolitan Opera production of Puccini's Madama Butterfly. The puppet's remarkable presence was created and controlled by three “artists” fully garbed and veiled in black, by virtue of the most subtle, nuanced movements of head, torso, and limbs. Even more remarkably (as seen in the live-HD broadcast), as the puppeteers manipulated their seemingly lifeless charge, their faces (perceptible behind the veils), expressed a species of empathy, emotions exactly corresponding to those they sought to reify in the carved and painted object. Uncanny vitality, indeed. One can understand how Bell has been irresistibly drawn to the subject of puppetry, has found the “soul” in it, and has bolstered his knowledge of its historical length and breadth until it encompasses the aggregate weight of these twelve chapters.
The second concern that shapes the book is Bell's perception of how the subject of puppets and puppetry may be folded into the pervasive changes in culture, society, and art embraced under the sometimes vague category of modernism. Bell is convinced that the development of modernism, beginning in the late nineteenth century in Europe and America, produced a series of decisive and illuminating collisions between more traditional notions of what puppets and their audiences are supposed to be and the emergent realities of modern life. Bell attempts to capture this concept in his perhaps obscure title phrase, “American puppet modernism.” The term is intended to embody a certain oxymoronic clash of perceived opposites peculiar to what was happening in America, to puppets and to society. In the United States, some of the collisions Bell identifies were the result of imported avant-garde European practices, greeted with wide-eyed awe, somewhat in the manner of a Henry Jamesian innocent confronted by a Great European Artist whose name he does not know. As Bell tells the story, enthusiasts like the famous Tony Sarg went abroad to study such phenomena as the techniques of Thomas Holden's marionette company in London and brought them back to New York, eventually going on to train a number of influential American puppeteers of the early twentieth century. Bell unwaveringly pursues his central thematic concern in a series of chapters covering Zuni Shalako puppets, the Little Theatre movement in the Midwest and its links with puppet theatre companies, New York puppet companies and parades there in the 1930s, Gertrude Stein's quintessentially avant-garde puppet play Identity, and the notable technological advances exhibited at the 1936 New York World's Fair by Remo Bufano's puppet theatre. Other chapters discuss special effects and mass media, the American phenomenon of the automobile, custom culture, and its invocation by puppeteers adapting to the shock of unprecedented cultural change. The irresistible impress of modernism on what was once unthinkingly considered a simple, uncomplicated art suitable for children and for those adults content to be described by circus ringmasters as “children of all ages” is, for Bell, the single most distinctive characteristic of puppetry in our age. Simultaneously full of delight and deeper meaning, puppetry is serious business, Bell insists, for adults necessarily cognizant of how it informs, illuminates, and often unsettles their lives. The broad range of subject matter discussed stretches from the early television classic Kukla, Fran and Ollie, which every American of a certain age will remember, back in history to Gordon Craig, Adolphe Appia, and Sigmund Freud, whom only a minority of those Americans of a certain age would recognize.
For all the dispassionate tone of Bell's workmanlike approach and even-handed exposition, one detects his insistence that puppets and puppetry—from diminutive hand puppets to monstrous, helium-inflated pink rubber animals aloft in a Macy's Thanksgiving Day parade—lie, or should lie, near the very epicenter of modernist studies rather than exiled as a minor topic of scholarly concern. Considering how far the tentacles of his subject extend, and how surely he implies that the topics covered by his book are not exhaustive of the subject but merely typical of it, it is difficult to dispute his claim.
