The Egyptian Revolution of 2011 has spawned an abundance of books, essays, films, and creative projects of all sorts, each trying to answer the question, “What was the revolution about?” Philip Marfleet adds to the growing production of knowledge with this carefully researched and argued book from the perspective of the working class and urban poor, the “unknown soldiers” of the 25 January uprising. This is not the first work from a self-avowed leftist perspective, but it is a highly comprehensive one that offers cogent analysis up to 2016.
Marfleet situates the events of 2011 in a longer historical process of workers’ struggles brought on by free market neoliberal policies. The working classes and urban poor (among others) have been experiencing a slow and painful process of dispossession and loss of collective rights. Marfleet argues that the uprising was a continuation of decades of workers’ protests for, among other things, fair wages and working conditions, an end to corruption and exploitation, and more recently, an end to military imperial exploits in the region.
Among the book's greatest strengths is the detail with which it documents the scale and frequency of strikes and economically driven protests in the lead up to, during, and after the toppling of Hosni Mubarak on 11 February 2011. This wealth of empirical data drawn from organizations such as the Egyptian Center for Economic and Social Rights (ECESR), leaves no doubt that workers were well represented in the protests of 2011. More to the point, it clarifies that the peoples’ demands were not limited to “pro-democracy” issues such as fair elections, due process, and civil liberties. The people also took to the streets with emphatic demands for jobs, fair wages and terms of work, collective bargaining, and job security. These demands will no doubt continue to animate grassroots politics in the foreseeable future.
In the volatile period between 2012–13, for instance, when the country experienced a transition from rule by the military's Supreme Council of the Armed Forces (SCAF) to the Muslim Brotherhood presidency of Mohamed Morsi, between 450 to 800 strikes took place per month. Strikers from Port Said, Ismailia, Cairo, Giza, and Alexandria protested “mismanagement, bullying, corruption and factory closures” and demanded better wages, job security, and holidays (154). In 2013, dock workers, microbus drivers, and rail workers coordinated strikes that effectively disrupted crucial parts of the country's infrastructure. For a brief two-year window after the revolution, another politics seemed possible. That window abruptly closed when the military headed by Abdel Fatah el-Sisi effectively re-seized power and cracked down on, or coopted, revolutionary forces. The horizontal and “leaderless” qualities that served the eighteen-day revolution so well, “quickly become a liability,” as quoted by Maha Abdelrahman in her 2014 book, The Long Revolution (Marfleet 187).
Marfleet does an excellent job of laying out the local, national, and international dynamics of union politics. He poses timely questions about why there has been a sharp decline in worker self-management movements of the type that were common in twentieth century revolutionary movements. The book also critically investigates ways international trade union networks have tried to co-opt local leadership and how the post-revolution workers’ unions consolidated and “quickly became a bureaucratic obstacle” to the effective grassroots organizing that thrived during the revolution (190).
While Marfleet shows a command over working class politics and respect for the voices of local activists, he demonstrates less acuity when it comes to questions about why so many “ordinary Egyptians” rejected and stood up against Muslim Brotherhood rule during the presidency of Mohamed Morsi (2012–13). Instead of trying to understand, from the ground up, why masses of people in Egypt harbored immense distrust and fear of the group, Marfleet resorts to less nuanced explanations about how the military and business community orchestrated dissent. He also draws on an anti-imperialist literature produced from the 1990s about how western powers misrepresented the Brotherhood and other Islamist groups as “fascist.” However, these accounts, produced in a different political context and time, do not explain why Egyptians took to the streets numerous times in 2012 and 2013 to protest Brotherhood rule. Scholars of the Middle East need to retune their analytical tools and frameworks to understand not only the dynamics between the Muslim Brotherhood in relation to the state and global powers, but the Brotherhood in relation to local communities and societies.
Overall, this work is an important contribution to the literature about uprisings in times of advanced neoliberalism. Marfleet writes: “Over three decades global opposition to neo-liberalism has taken a ‘grass-roots turn,’ demonstrating the impatience felt by a vast number of people with agendas for change proposed by social democrats and partisans of Stalinist Communism who long dominated the politics of the left.” (185) The question for now, is if the old politics of the left do not provide a way forward, and Marfleet seems to demonstrate with ample evidence that it does not, how do we retool? This work is part of a vital global conversation about Egypt, workers of all kinds, and the future of progressive politics.
