Islam Is a Foreign Country is a beautiful, original, and generative book. Zareena Grewal's careful use of analytical categories such as “social citizenship” and “moral geographies” offers a fresh language for discussing Muslim American affairs. The book also expresses palpable love for Islamic tradition. Rather than discarding the problematic notion of tradition, Grewal combines her knowledge of the Islamic religious sciences with critical theory to show how Muslims themselves have defined and debated the limits of orthodoxy and authority. She shows how the discourse of Islamic tradition is embedded in geopolitical battles that put Islam at the center of global politics and war making.
The real protagonists of her story are the American Muslim student-travelers who, for the last century, have journeyed in increasingly larger number to sites in the Muslim Middle East. Situating her late 20th- and 21st-century subjects in the long history of 20th-century Muslims, Grewal first explores the story of interwar converts, most of whom were African American, and shows how they viewed the Muslim world as a transnational Islamic utopia. For them, the idea of the global Muslim community, the umma, represented a powerful critique of the dystopian American nation-state. This moral geography did not always lead to calls for separatism, as Grewal carefully points out. Moorish Science Temple leader Noble Drew Ali, for example, embraced it as a form of both “difference and belonging” (p. 89). In addition, Grewal's use of such categories as dystopia and utopia are never static—she notes, for example, how in his autobiography, “Malcolm X diverges from the moral geography of the U.S. as a dystopia through aspirational language and nostalgic longing for home” (p. 113). Some of this material is old, and one day Islam in America scholars will need to stop recounting this oft-told story, but its recapitulation makes sense in light of Grewal's overall purpose.
Like other scholars of Islam in America, Grewal sees the 1965 Hart–Celler Act, which loosened immigration restrictions on Asians, Africans, and Latin Americans, as a major turning point in the history of American Islam. The influx of many more Asian and African Muslims changed the nature of Islamic institutions, as is well known. But Grewal shows how this event altered the construction of Islam as a form of counter-citizenship in the United States. These new Americans generally lacked formal training in the Islamic religious sciences but assumed religious authority in the powerful Islamic institutions that they created. Articulating a form of Islamic reform, revival, and renewal that emphasized direct encounters with Islamic scriptures, these educators, engineers, and physicians assumed leadership roles that at once depicted America as Medina, a place where they could practice Islam freely without fear of political repression, and as a site of displacement. Unlike African American Muslims in the interwar period or after World War II, immigrant Muslims did not see America as a dystopia, but they did identify its many shortcomings—failings that could be cured by Islamic revival. Many African American Muslims, including Imam W. D. Mohammed, joined them in this quest.
Having established the varied history of Muslim American moral geographies, the book begins to offer its most original insights at the halfway point. Based on years of fieldwork in Amman, Cairo, Damascus, and other places, Grewal reveals the impact of American Muslim student-travelers on Muslim American identity and practice. She shows how by the 1990s leaders such as Hamza Yusuf were shifting the locus of religious authority away from the immigrant reformers toward those who sought formal training in the Islamic traditions of Qurʾan recitation, Islamic law, and Islamic spirituality, or Sufism. For many of these seekers, true Islam was to be found in the past. American Muslim religious leaders and scholars such as Zaid Shakir, Sherman Jackson, and Amina Wadud similarly discovered the archive of “genuine” Islamic tradition, and encouraged others to seek religious knowledge by traveling to various educational centers in the Muslim world. This embrace of tradition challenged the very structure of authority among Muslim Americans, whose congregations frequently were and continue to be organized around the authority of professional immigrant leaders. Grewal's exploration of this key moment of transition in the American Islamic experience should change how Islam in America is understood in the academy. She convincingly shows the existence and impact of this shift in Muslim American religious authority.
In charting the change, Part 2 of her book follows the journeys of mostly young Muslim Americans of diverse racial and ethnic backgrounds who visit religious experts in North Africa, the Middle East, and South Asia in search of the deep religious knowledge that is needed, according to Grewal, to practice and interpret Islam in the contemporary United States. This is what the reader has been waiting for. We are taken into the madrasas where Muslim Americans struggle to learn the Islamic religious sciences. Grewal's descriptions of what actually goes on at al-Azhar University in Cairo or even more among the semisecret Qubaīsiyāt women's movement in Syria are unforgettable and alone are worth the effort of reading the book—if for no other reason than that American and European readers are offered an image of such places that challenge popular culture stereotypes. But much more than that, Grewal reveals how “debates over the nature of the transmission of traditions across time . . . and across cultural difference . . . generate different moral geographies: some student-travelers embrace the U.S. as home . . . while others are far more ambivalent about the U.S. as a destination” (p. 256). Grewal challenges the categories often applied by other scholars of religion to the ideological orientation of these Muslims, instead analyzing her subjects as formalists, pragmatists, or reformists.
What comes across so strongly as we travel with Grewal from site to site is the depth with which she describes and analyzes the religious practice of her subjects. We can see, hear, and feel what it is like to recite the Qurʾan, perform meritorious prayers at night, and to give up not only food and water but also anger and pride for Ramadan. As I was reading, I was struck by how this kind of deep attention is so infrequently paid to religious practice by other scholars of Islam in America. Grewal shows us something else, how both men and women on their religious journeys seek to conquer the nafs, or the id. Women, she finds, take care in how they describe their submission to God. Grewal argues that assumptions about Islamic misogyny and the liberal insistence that freedom is the ultimate goal of the human experience shape the discourse of religious practice among female Muslims: “‘strong language’ of choice and (religious) freedom constrains the women's representations of their devotional practice” (p. 224). They struggle, she points out, to be included in the male-dominated circles of authoritative, Islamic pedagogy as they simultaneously insist to both Muslims and non-Muslims alike that Islam is not a patriarchal religion, not when practiced in the orthodox way.
A final, powerful chapter and epilogue show how contemporary American Islam is shaped and constituted not only by the efforts of Muslim Americans but also by various non-Muslim institutions, including the media, government, and education. The criminalization of Muslim American support for violent and nonviolent radical, transnational Islamic movements and nationalist resistance movements, such as Ḥamas, led to a quieting or even silencing of Islam as a form of counter-citizenship and radical political critique. But government action was only part of a post-9/11 mediatization of Islam that encouraged, perhaps coerced, Muslim Americans to disavow not only terrorism, but also “fundamentalism” (p. 301). Grewal concludes that Muslim American authoritative leaders of all ideological stripes “aggressively define themselves as American Muslim citizens and as the exceptional umma against a fundamentalist, and even pathological, immigrant Muslim Other” (p. 341). The result, she argues, is the hardening of the us/them binary, of the “ontological distance between the U.S. and the distant, backward, pathological Muslim World” (p. 341). Grewal demonstrates how the American nation has emerged as the object of Muslim American moral imagination in a way that one might have scarcely imagined given the origins of Islam as a counterpublic among Muslims before World War II. Grewal asks whether Muslim Americans will continue to produce religious knowledge in service of the state, censoring not only their views on public policy issues but also domesticating the very foundations of Islamic tradition, including its notions of religious authority and global religious community.
This conclusion shows how the book casts new light on the nature of “America” as well as Islam. Islam is the margin against which key aspects of American political and cultural aspects have been defined after 9/11. A formerly transgressive element—Islam—has been domesticated. Grewal tells us, wistfully, about the workings of powerful state and nonstate institutions in the making of this statist conception of American Islamic identity. But if, for Grewal, the story ends in a tragic key, her own archive of American Islamic tradition suggests a different future not only for Muslim Americans but for all those blinded by myopic national interests. She shines a light on alternate moral geographies, those that find relief in the religious intimacies of Islamic practice and also, most importantly, in the strong critique of empire, racism, and inequality committed in the name of the American nation.
