This insightful book is regrettably the last contribution of renowned scholar John M. Rosenfield to the research of Japanese art, as he died while working on the manuscript. This is apparent in a few points where the flow of the writing seems cut or an idea unfinished, but in general the editors, Jerome Silbergeld and Dora C. Y. Ching, did a magnificent job in delivering Rosenfield's work to us. This book continues a longer project of Rosenfield's that re-examined and questioned our understanding of Japanese Buddhist artefacts. Much of the discussion was included in an earlier work published in 2010 “Portraits of Choōgen: The Transformation of Buddhist Art in Early Medieval Japan”, but the current book takes a new angle by delving into the early-modern period. Rosenfield credited the inspiration to deal with early-modern times to Patricia Graham, whose 2007 publication, “Faith and Power in Japanese Buddhist Art, 1600–2005”, invited scholars to rethink the tendency to dismiss early-modern Buddhism as unoriginal and faded. Rosenfield chose to take on this challenge by focusing on the Shingon Buddhism monk Hōzan Tankai (1629-1716), who served as head of Hōzanji Temple for nearly thirty years.
The book follows Tankai's life, from his childhood in a remote but lively village located on the pilgrimage trail to Ise Shrine, through his learning and devotion in various religious centres, to his settlement and final demise in Hōzanji on Mount Ikoma. Three of the six chapters are dedicated to the major phases of Tankai's life, his childhood and early training (Chapter 1), his appointment and activities as Head Priest at Ikoma (Chapter 3), and his eminence as clergyman and artist with connections at the court and shogunate (Chapter 6). The other three chapters continue to follow Tankai's activities, but from a wider perspective that offers more context to the reader. Chapter 2 introduces Mont Ikoma as a religious centre and shows the influence of Tankai's own religious choices on the development of Hōzanji. Many of the artworks discussed in this chapter were not Tankai's creation and are used to recreate the visual context in which Tankai worked as Head Priest. Chapters 5 and 6 are dedicated respectively to sculpture and pictures attributed to Tankai and reflect on their production and function within the broader context of Buddhist art production in early-modern Japan.
Eulogies of Tankai comment on his affinity to art from a young age (p. 40), but he only began to officially produce artworks in his fifties, after he settled in Ikoma and began the restoration of the temple he would soon head. There is a remarkable number of artworks attributed to Tankai. At least 150 finished works (p. 23), ranging from sculptures and paintings to religious implements, and some 200 drawings and sketches kept in Hōzanji (p. 109). As Rosenfield points out, this surprising number of works could not have been created by Tankai alone, especially considering his numerous duties as congregation leader, thus collaboration is expected (pp. 31–33). Tankai's involvement in art production seems to have had various degrees, ranging from hands-on participation to planning and supervision with his signature added as final approval. Some of Tankai's collaborations were long lasting, and Chapter 4 in particular dwells on his long working relationships with certain sculptors.
Tankai was a rather unique example of a high-ranking clergyman who was also a recognised artist, in fact he is the only example of a religious figure of his position to be listed in standard art reference books (p. 26). Through this unique case Rosenfield introduces the reader to the production process of Buddhist artworks in early-modern Japan. Buddhist art of this period is often criticised for being dull and uninspired. Rosenfield, following Graham, challenges this opinion by reminding us that all art needs to be understood in its original context. Buddhist artworks, as functional ritual objects, had to follow a specific iconography in order to fulfil their aim thus originality was not only unnecessary, but at times undesirable. At the same time these ritual objects had to fit with the changing taste of their patrons, and artists often changed the level and style of adornment while keeping the basic iconography. This may seem straightforward enough, yet for a long time early-modern artworks were judged according to anachronistic modern aesthetics or repeatedly compared to earlier ‘classic’ Buddhist art, leaving them unappreciated and scantly researched.
Rosenfield suggests that we appreciate Buddhist art as we would a contemporary performance of Beethoven, in his words: “The pianist, who is not Beethoven, performs (and interprets) the composition conceived by Beethoven centuries earlier, and we judge the pianist's intelligence, clarity of execution, and emotional power (p. 91)”. The instruments and social context of Beethoven times have altered, but his music continues to touch and excite new audiences. Similarly, early-modern, and later Buddhist art can be seen as ‘variation on a theme’, performing (and interpreting) the centuries old iconography to fit with changing tastes. This metaphor can be useful for other genera of painting in early-modern Japan as well. Several scholars, including Timon Screech, Brenda Jordan, Victoria Weston and Karen Gerhart, already pointed out that the renown Kano School, for example, also emphasised the continuation of tradition, favouring ‘variations on a theme’ over novel expression. The later artists of this school suffered from an image of a decaying line because they adhered to principles that differ from what we came to expect.
Rosenfield had a way with words and a rare talent to write texts that are both valuable to specialists and approachable to newcomers. This book is no different, making it a delightful and thought provoking read. Tankai's life exemplifies the fact that religious practices did not fade under the Tokugawa regime, far from it, they simply transformed to fit the new conditions, as did art. Since religious art was a part of religious practice, it can be assumed that icons matched the religious thought of the time. Thus when confronted with a lavish artefact, made of the richest materials and in expert hands, we can only assume that the design followed the original intention of the patrons and try to understand it in its own contemporary context. This profound and observant book is a reminder of how much more there is to learn.
