In March 2007, three hundred workers at a Pascagoula, Mississippi shipyard went on strike to protest inhumane working conditions and the corporate fraud that had brought them to the US from India. Six organizers of the strike were fired, while the others were intimidated into returning to work. Having paid between $15,000 and $20,000 each to a Mumbai labor-recruiting company a year earlier in exchange for permanent jobs, green cards, and the eventual right to bring their families to the US, the men found themselves holders of temporary visas, cramped lodgers in twenty-four-person trailers that cost them each over $1,000 a month in rent, and virtual prisoners of the New Orleans-based corporation, Signal International. Under the terms of the H-2B program by which they entered the country, they were not allowed to find employment with any other company, and would risk deportation if they lost their current jobs. (In some ways these men were luckier than a group of Brazilian workers who had each paid Signal recruiters $6,000, only to find no jobs waiting for them at all in Mississippi and no way to recover their debt.) But with only two prospects facing the Indian workers – returning home to face overwhelming debt or continuing to work as modern-day slaves – they struck back this year with greater effectiveness. With the help of organizations like the Southern Poverty Law Center, the men reported themselves to the US Justice Department as victims of labor trafficking and demanded a federal investigation of Signal International. In March, eighty-nine men walked to the gate of the shipyard carrying signs that, like those carried by African American workers during the 1968 Memphis sanitation strike, stated simply, “I Am a Man.” They gathered at the company's gate to sing “We Shall Overcome” in Hindi, threw their hardhats on the ground, and walked off the job. In New Orleans the next day, they celebrated their freedom at a labor and racial justice festival that featured speeches, plays, and poems in five languages, and that concluded with all of the attendees singing Indian folk songs and dancing to the music of a New Orleans brass band. The following day, they began a nine-day march from New Orleans to Washington, DC. Describing their protest as a nonviolent tribute to Gandhi and Martin Luther King, they passed through landmark cities in the civil rights movement – Jackson, Selma, Atlanta, and Greensboro. In front of the White House, still carrying their “I Am a Man” signs, they tore up their visas and embarked upon a twenty-nine-day hunger strike.
The Signal workers' invocation of the American civil rights movement is not unique on the post-Katrina Gulf Coast. In 2007, thirty Mexican farm workers borrowed $1,000 each (at 20 percent monthly interest) from labor recruiters (or, as they are more commonly called now, “slavecatchers”). Immediately upon arrival in Amite, Louisiana, the owner of Bimbo's Best Produce confiscated the men's passports and put them to work at the rate of less than two dollars an hour. They sought and found support from members of the New Orleans-based Black Alliance for Just Immigration, who told the workers, “As African Americans, we recognize what you're describing and we are with you.”Footnote 1 Hoping that the new Obama administration would be receptive to its argument, the New Orleans Workers' Center for Racial Justice brought federal charges against the company in December 2008.
In 2006, the Alliance and the Southern Poverty Law Center filed a lawsuit on behalf of eighty-two workers from Peru, Bolivia, and the Dominican Republic who had been stranded in New Orleans, charging Decatur Hotels, the owner of fifteen luxury hotels in the city, with violating the Fair Labor Standards Act. The workers had each paid between $3,500 and $5,000 to subcontracted slavecatchers, money that was to have been reimbursed to them within their first week of work, but never was. Although recruiters had promised 40 hours of work a week and all of the overtime the men could handle, twenty-five hours a week ended up being the norm – not enough to live on and certainly not enough to purchase their fares back home. Central to their case is the 1871 Civil Rights Act, also known as the Ku Klux Klan Act, which made federal prosecution of Klan members possible. An attorney supporting the interracial group of workers has repeatedly claimed that “the guest worker program is a continuation of the racial exploitation that began with slavery in this country.” Implicitly connecting contemporary labor struggles in the region to nineteenth-century racial history, she has emphasized that the Decatur protest centers on the rights of “all workers to be afforded decent work opportunities with a living wage in the just reconstruction of the Gulf South.”Footnote 2
It is no doubt inspiring to many to see that the rhetorical strategies of the civil rights movement live on in contemporary transcultural dramas, and it is tempting to believe that the old rhetoric has universal appeal. Certainly, the few journalists who have covered these stories have often deliberately framed them as extensions of iconic moments. For example, Ted Quant's photograph of the Signal workers posted on the New Orleans Indymedia website in March 2008 paid homage to Jim Karales's famous photograph of the Selma to Montgomery march of 21–25 March 1965.Footnote 3 Less inspiring is the realization that another “universal” movement is marching right alongside the workers. Signal International and Decatur Hotels are just two of the countless corporations that have sent subcontracted agents to much of the non-European world promising unlimited riches and permanent residency to those able to pay for their own Middle Passage to international limbo.
With over 50 percent of the descendants of American slaves in forced exile from New Orleans, a new generation of slaves arrives every day to do the work that, according to Decatur's request for H-2B certification, “no one” wants to do (“Black people don't like to work,” a Decatur manager reportedly told worker Luis Chavez).Footnote 4 The global search for cheap labor remains a largely invisible phenomenon in the US; what is visible – a tidal wave of foreign workers “taking” American jobs – becomes a recurrent lament on the airwaves. Exacerbating and complicating anti-immigration sentiment is the H-2B program's requirement that companies prove that American citizens are not available for particular jobs (the “proof” is often simply a claim). As early as September 2005, black residents of Louisiana and Mississippi desperate for employment had been shut out of the reconstruction labor market. Fraudulent labor immigration has pitted both white and black Americans against foreign workers, a highly effective strategy for blocking potential labor unity that makes possible, as investigative reporter Robert Lovato puts it, “every investor's dream of merging Third World wages with First World amenities.”Footnote 5
With the Southeast home to the nation's largest-growing Latino population, the resurgence of nativist groups, including the Klan, is motivating civil rights veterans to join Latino immigrants in a fight against what some now call “Juan Crow.” “We may have come on different ships, [but] we're all in the same damn boat now,” Southern Christian Leadership Conference former head Joseph Lowery has observed.Footnote 6 But an equal number of civil rights veterans have embraced global free trade as an ally of freedom movements. A glossy brochure produced in 2007 by the city of Atlanta and African American Mayor Shirley Franklin to promote its bid to be secretariat of the Free Trade Area of the Americas featured a photograph of Martin Luther King Jr.'s headstone, with its inscription, “Free at last. Free at last. Thank God Almighty I'm free at last.” Interestingly, while immigrants-rights groups have used anti-Klan legislation against corporate slave masters, neoliberals who emphasize the “freedom” in “free” trade did not hesitate to use the Bush Administration's remodeling of the Fugitive Slave Act to chase and jail undocumented foreign workers, many of them victims of corporate slavecatchers in the first place.
The beacon of free trade creates a sunny glow in expanding New South cities like Atlanta and Charlotte. The shadows cast by the shining towers and blinding public relations fall far to the south of these hubs, though, almost out of sight and certainly out of public oversight. As New Orleans figuratively and literally “goes south,” sliding several millimeters closer to South America each year, the darkness of this latest chapter of the southern story creeps along with it. Cloaked in the slogans of economic boosterism, the old drama of bondage, poverty, and protest steals into the southern hemisphere to audition a fresh cast of characters. Latin Americans and Asians who are able to avoid indefinite stays in detention centers worse than Guantánamo find themselves immediate prisoners of globalization, indebted for life to ubiquitous, interconnected, and strangely free-floating companies. In the fabled epicenter of “place” – the Deep South's “deepest” city – they are not just homeless, but placeless. Little wonder that director Paul Chan decided to stage the Classical Theatre of Harlem's open-air production of Waiting for Godot in two of New Orleans's most decimated neighborhoods. Where else, he asked, should a play be performed that takes place on a deserted road and whose first words of dialogue are, “Nothing to be done”?Footnote 7
For all of the insistence by so many New Orleanians and admirers of the city that the “there-ness” of the place is alive and rebounding, no one can ignore the stark fact that this locus of celebrated “southernness” is physically shrinking – and sinking. The urban sprawl typical of most American cities has, in New Orleans, always been constricted by the bodies of water to the north and east of the city, but now land to the south and west of the city is disappearing at the rate of one American football field (a hundred yards) every thirty-eight minutes. Even Old Man River wants to cut his ties to the city, pushing against his flimsy concrete barriers to head west. Shortly after the 1927 flood, civil engineer James Kemper warned Congress that the Atchafalaya River would eventually become the main channel of the Mississippi, “and the river past New Orleans a deteriorating outlet.”Footnote 8
As a number of politicians and advocates of privatization announced within the first week of the 2005 flood, New Orleans offered an ideal opportunity for instituting rapid and radical social and economic change, and, as if to accommodate their wishes, the city's diminishing space and exacerbated isolation from the continent provided a laboratory conveniently removed from mainstream America (a “Third World” region, the media repeatedly emphasized, one that “could not be America”). These factors, however, offered the rest of the world perhaps one of the most concentrated spectacles (at least in the US) of what John Berger has called the “nowhere” of globalized economies.Footnote 9 Across the compacted wasteland are reminders of the communal void: vanished neighborhoods; the loss of collective knowledge within those neighborhoods; miles of fenced-in labor and residential camps; more than 12,000 homeless people, many with jobs, who have been ejected from the poison-filled sweatboxes temporarily provided by the government only to migrate from city parks to interstate overpasses, unable to find affordable housing; the death of the public-school system; violence so routine that murders now get reported in time segments (“Three in nine hours,” the Times-Picayune announced one weekend in May 2008); the wealthy living in gated ghettos (protected by companies like the Israeli-based Instinctive Shooting International); the increasing privatization of community festivals (seen in the heavily armed guards from rival security companies who patrol bleachers of Mardi Gras celebrants, and the private caterers at some Mardi Gras locations who ban food or drink that is not purchased from their own industrial, distinctly non-indigenous selections); and, not least, the diminishing visibility of public government.
For over four years, the words “Katrina,” “storm,” and “natural disaster” have been used to describe a phenomenon that had little to do with the Category 1 hurricane that blew through New Orleans. Broken levees destroyed the city, levees built and supposedly maintained by the US Corps of Engineers. Believing that nationally constructed disasters should be named and blamed, many people in the city have taken to calling the 2005 catastrophe the Federal Flood. From another perspective, however, one most likely shared by Signal International and Decatur Hotels, the crumbling of the levees was anything but a catastrophe. In one of the most stunningly ironic closing acts in any political era, the flood swept away its very creator. The prolonged absence of a national presence in the stricken city during its worst days made semi-official what had been unthinkable to all but the most fervent true believers of conspiracy theory and neoliberal doctrine. But while conspiracy theorists of several persuasions hold that the government merely poses as incompetent in order to execute expert acts of domestic genocide, neoliberals hold a far simpler and more elegant view: the federal government is not incompetent at all; it is irrelevant.
“When large amounts of federal dollars are put in a region,” a litigator at the National Employment Law Project in New York has said, “they come with pretty basic standards: environmental standards, labor standards, community-impact standards. In New Orleans there just weren't any.”Footnote 10 It stands to reason that the victims and survivors of the avoidable deluge be compensated by the perpetrator. Even though lawsuits against the Corps of Engineers have been prohibited since 1928, half a million New Orleanians filed one in 2007. To his sorrow, a US District Court judge found in early 2008 that the federal government had broad immunity from legal liability for failed projects. “When the King can do no wrong,” he wrote, “his subjects suffer the consequences.”Footnote 11 The King, however, is the only the party permitted to issue flood insurance to his subjects. Most Gulf Coast subjects failed to buy federal flood insurance on the advice of their insurance agents; such insurance, the agents claimed, and most contracts seemed to agree, was redundant, for storm and hurricane insurance would cover any conceivable damages houses could suffer in a regional disaster. As a consequence, tens of thousands of residents whose homes were lost received little to no reimbursement, for water driven into houses by 140-mile-an-hour winds constituted flood damage, not wind damage, and only wind damage was covered in most policies.
Despite landmark lawsuits against insurance carriers, the companies made record profits in the two years following the Federal Flood, and helped save the national government hundreds of millions of dollars by recommending that policyholders not buy flood insurance – from the very party that would end up causing the flood. To complete the financial and psychological disaster inflicted on individuals, a relatively small amount of federal recovery funding was allocated to Louisiana, compared to that allocated to its Red State neighbor Mississippi. These funds were administered not through a state agency, but through a “global disaster” corporation outside Washington. The bureaucratic failures of the company quickly became the stuff of outrage and bitter humor within the state, and many residents who qualified for rebuilding or relocation compensation simply gave up on the entire process. Nevertheless, in 2007, the very year in which national newspapers reported that only a small fraction of all state applicants had received even minimal restitution, the company awarded each of its top five CEOs a raise of one million dollars. In 2008, the continued dismal record of the company earned its boss 1·7 million dollars as a performance bonus.
In the vacuum created by the civic abandonment of both government and business, then, to whom exactly is the proclamation “I am a man” directed? Although the decades-old rhetoric may seem charmingly nostalgic and hopelessly anachronistic, its reemergence in New Orleans has as much to do with the city's modern history as with contemporary labor and ethnic injustice.
The unfolding of the post-Brown civil rights movement against the backdrop of the Cold War provided segregationists a nationalist persona they had previously lacked as states-righters. Right-wing whites could now marry anti-integrationism and anticommunism, and, as “patriots,” beat the drum for national, ideological, and racial “purity.” Segregated schools and antimiscegenation laws may not have been as visually compelling as the Berlin Wall or as metaphorically powerful as the Iron Curtain, but they were equally emblematic of the Cold War's rhetorical reliance on the concept of “containment.” If the failure of the Soviet attempt to constrain and control “nature” was definitively captured twenty years ago in images of people flooding through and over the crumbling bricks of the Berlin Wall, the failure of American containment took longer to find its iconic moment.
The rupture of the levees was the fulfillment of Civil War-era dreams of environmental domination. As John Barry has recorded in detail, the politically driven decision by the national government to master the flood-prone Mississippi by corseting it in concrete – setting its course in stone, in other words – allowed planters and speculators to “reclaim” floodplains for profit.Footnote 12 It also ensured the eventual disappearance both of southern Louisiana and of the river's assertion of its power to carve its own path across the continent. Its yearly “self-liberations” into surrounding fields, like most spring rituals, had formerly rejuvenated the rich culture – or agriculture – of its long valley. Now, the river's imprisonment was shared by those who would work the decreasingly rich land. The analogy seems to have been understood on some level by plantation owners, for during the Great Flood of 1927, an act of massive defiance on the part of the river, they tightened their confinement of black sharecroppers and refused to allow them to flee severely inundated and highly productive areas such as Greenville, Mississippi. The exodus of cheap labor would have spelled the end of Deep South profitability.
In 2005, poor African Americans would once again be confined against their will to a disastrously flooded area. In this case, however, the confinement served to expedite an exodus, not prevent one. Herded into the twin concentration camps of the Superdome and the Convention Center, deliberately deprived of food and water (under Homeland Security's documented assumption that “if we feed them, they'll never leave”Footnote 13), the prisoners were dispatched at gunpoint to destinations determined by whatever military arm happened to be commanding planes and buses. Within weeks, the mayor's Bring New Orleans Back Commission recommended a new “footprint” for New Orleans, one that erased a number of primarily black neighborhoods and, in the case of the Lower Ninth Ward, prevented residents from reentering their own houses. As the most influential leader of the commission proclaimed, the city was now “a clean sheet,”Footnote 14 open to new demographics and more profitable ways of conducting business. The century of black labor was over; once forced to stay, now forced to leave, many found themselves as placeless as their replacements in the new century of brown slavery. The decision to hold the April 2008 North American Security and Prosperity Partnership Summit in New Orleans effectively validated this new continental drift. Posters appeared around the city announcing that George W. Bush, Canadian prime minister Stephen Harper, and Mexican president Felipe Calderón were wanted “for grand theft and conspiracy against the peoples of North America” – along with “33 gangsters and co-conspirators from the North American Competitive Council.”
Conspiracy, though, has always been in the air – and the culture – of New Orleans. Yet in the nearly half-century since Jim Garrison's crusade to hold a number of men in the city responsible for the assassination of John F. Kennedy, the notion of antigovernment conspiracies has fallen into the twentieth-century remainder bin. How can one conspire against something that barely seems to exist? “The Mafia is way better equipped to run New Orleans than the United States government!” a hometown character proclaims in the first episode of HBO's post-Katrina series Treme (2010). Hailing the days when gangland boss (and suspected assassination conspirator) Carlos Marcello kept “the mayor and the governor and everybody else in his pocket,” disc jockey Davis McAlary (Steven Zahn) asks his dismissive colleague a question saturated with historical irony: “Do you think the Mob would have dragged ass the way FEMA did – let the little old ladies rot on rooftops?”Footnote 15
Conspiracies against peoples, however, have become entirely possible in a hemisphere where so-called “borderless” economies provoke diasporas and “influxes.” One such conspiracy might just involve the rehabilitation of that rhetorical warhorse “containment.” Even in the aftermath of the 2008 economic crash and a taxpayer rescue of the largest banks in the country, the US continues its advocacy of “free-market” principles, but it is taking few chances that “nature” could reliberate itself as well.
The Mississippi might wash away whatever remains of New Orleans, and the barely bolstered levees will most surely crack once more, but the new generation of “people levees” currently in mass production promises to hold in check the biggest threat to Fortress America. Uncontrolled cultural contaminants, should they survive transit across a two-thousand-mile border fence, will be free at last, free at last to wither and die in overheated detention centers blossoming across southern deserts. Or to hide in abandoned houses along the Gulf Coast. Or to work for charity donations in the frigid northern prairies.
In February 2009, a federal judge dismissed the workers' lawsuit against Decatur Hotels, acting upon a Labor Department statement issued in the final days of the Bush administration. Although a federal appeals court agreed, in the spring of 2010, to rehear the case at an undetermined date, the workers linger in a no-man's-land of destitution, fear, and homesickness. After their long encampment in Washington, twenty-three former Signal workers made their way to Cass County, North Dakota, where, with forged documents, they found construction jobs at an ethanol plant. The day after the plant was constructed, federal agents arrested the men. After serving seventy days in jail, the “Cass 23,” as they have come to be called, were released on the frozen streets of Fargo, where Lutheran and Catholic agencies came to their assistance. In September 2009, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission found “reasonable cause” to believe that Signal International had engaged in discriminatory practices against Indian guest workers; in March 2010, the American Civil Liberties Union joined the Southern Poverty Law Center in a class-action lawsuit against Signal that had been dragging through the federal legal system since 2008. In the six months spanning these events, the twenty-three unemployable men in North Dakota exhausted their allotments from local church agencies while waiting to receive T-visas (visas granted to victims of trafficking), and peace and justice centers issued desperate national appeals for donations. “Most frustrating,” Sister Maris Stella Korb wrote in Fargo's High Plains Reader in late 2009, “is the dismissive silence and interminable waiting that invariably follows any plea for assistance from either government or court officials. Information they [the workers] have been given is that they will not be needed as witnesses in the case of Signal International.”Footnote 16
The culminating dream of freedom envisioned by Martin Luther King at his moment of highest public acclaim in front of the Lincoln Memorial has always carried a contradictory cultural connotation – namely that the uncertain freedom of life would become, finally, the certain freedom of death. It is disheartening but not surprising that these words on a tombstone are now promoting twenty-first-century slavery in Atlanta. But the words of the Memphis movement that King gave his life for are inspiring a renewed abolition movement that extends far beyond the Deep South – to the Canadian border, to Peru, to India. Like the most toxic of oil spills, the moral and environmental catastrophe that was “Katrina” became a global infectant. How ironic, then, that “I Am a Man” was – and is – the assertion of people who sized up – and cleaned up – the unspeakable messes made by others.
