No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 10 June 2004
French historians of France's agricultural past have commonly deployed their erudition and talent to compose geographical tableaux using evidence drawn from the copious legal and administrative documentation of the Old Regime and its nineteenth-century extensions, and only rarely attempt the examination of a restricted class of phenomena across extended periods of time. The aim of the tableaux is reproducing a picture of the total life of a particular place and time. The resulting general history assembled from them, however, tends to be a sequence somewhat of disconnected pictures loosely linked by demographic or socio-political dynamics, giving an overall impression of stasis. The present study by an eminent historian of France's early modern agricultural history tries to correct that impression by looking for signs of movement over six centuries of French rural history. Encyclopedic in scope, the work is a serviceable introduction to the recent literature on that history. Its organizing theme is the tension between the evident stability of agricultural techniques and factor productivity between the twelfth and nineteenth century and the movement impelled by the evolution of markets.
In contrast to the last generation of French rural historians, who explained that tension eclectically in Malthusian and Marxian terms, Jean-Marc Moriceau emphasizes changing commercial opportunities as the dynamic element in the exploitation of France's land endowment. This is a cogent motif, but instead of using it to organize the historical material into a narrative of interaction between markets and agrarian structure, he retreats to the conventional dichotomy of capitalist and traditional culture that inspired social historians in the early decades of the last century. As a result, the reader never learns why, or even how, things happened. Nevertheless, the book contains much new and valuable material. The first part reviews the dating and consequences of deforestation, soil erosion, and climatic variation, recording the punctuated evolution in land use, and the slow transformations of farm layout. The second section reviews the evolution of crop rotations, tools, and the introduction of new crops between the fifteenth and nineteenth century. Much of this material is drawn from the author's monumental study of capitalist farmers in the Île de France between 1400 and 1800 (Les Fermiers de L'Île de France. Paris: Fayard, 1994). Those unfamiliar with that study will be surprised to learn that in size and capitalization the French farms had nothing to envy their English counterparts. The final section studies tenant farmers as a social class through two cases: the exceptionally wealthy Navarre, who first appear as farmers in the Île de France in the fifteenth century and by the eighteenth century were among the wealthiest non-noble families in France, and a family of small-scale winegrowers situated just west of Paris, whose history is tracked from the early seventeenth century to the early twentieth. The family histories are developed from the notarial documentation that makes it possible to track the generation and transmission of wealth across multiple generations. A final chapter reviews the impact of the Revolutionary land redistribution.
Despite the author's superb command of detail and bibliography, the book is nevertheless ultimately disappointing. Bits and pieces of narrative surface in commercial histories of specific farm products, the secular itinerary of representative farm families, and the wrenching displacements caused by the Revolution, but they are not welded into a coherent story linking the whole agricultural past from the twelfth to the mid-nineteenth century. That history could have been built on three themes the book addresses: the evolution of farming technique, the evolution of the market for farm produce, and the evolution of farming organization. Instead, the book asserts what all specialists have long known—that there was movement and that there was diversity in that movement. Much of the book seems to be addressed to graduate students in search of topics for a seminar paper; it lists topics for research but refuses to venture hypotheses or advance arguments. Indeed, the author affects a supercilious attitude towards analytical and especially quantitative history, on the grounds that generalization is impossible without more data geographically arranged and mapped to illustrate the theme of diversity. This is an old-fashioned book stuffed with new facts. Its model is the kind of history advocated by the geographer Vidal de la Blache. One longs for explanation; what one gets is aesthetically arranged description.