In October 2011, the exhibition The First Actresses: Nell Gwyn to Sarah Siddons opened at London's National Portrait Gallery; its curator, Gill Perry, edited and coauthored a collection of essays designed to complement it. The book, which shares its title with the exhibition, contains selections from Joseph Roach and Shearer West, both of whom also contributed to the exhibition's catalog essays. Perry's edited collection provides an in-depth look at the symbiotic relationship between art and theatre as manifested in their common fascination with the figure of the actress. Like its subject material, the book results from the collaboration and mutual interests of art and theatre historians. Text and image enjoy equal representation and analysis in this well-researched, interdisciplinary history of the early actresses.
Perry structures the text so that it provides an initial, general introduction to the first actresses, which is later expanded upon in four specialized essays. In her “Introduction: Painting Actresses' Lives,” she articulates the essay authors' goals to “explore the remarkable visibility” of the early actresses and “the ways in which visual and written portraits” contributed to the creation and manipulation of their cultural personae (13). Perry presents these personae as unstable conflations of the actresses' onstage and offstage lives forged by the blurring of reality and fiction, nature and artifice, in which art and theatre both participated. Perry frames the eighteenth century as witnessing “the birth of modern celebrity culture” (13) and encourages a critical comparison between representations of the early actresses and contemporary celebrities (a comparison that recurs throughout the book); she also historicizes the interactive relationship between the visual and dramatic arts best expressed through her discussions of actress portraits and examples of the “theatrical portrait,” a popular eighteenth-century subgenre of portraiture that visually depicted scenes from plays. Perry crafts a concise visual and written introduction that guides the reader—whether expert or novice—through the book, and that establishes the work's central arguments. Her introduction is followed by “The Actresses: A Selection of Biographies,” which pairs portraits and succinct biographies of those actresses paid particular attention by Perry and her coauthors. (In addition to Gwyn and Siddons, this group of actresses includes Frances Abington, Elizabeth Inchbald, and Dorothy Jordan, among others.)
The authorship and foci of the four essays that succeed the biographies and comprise the body of The First Actresses both exhibit and mine the dynamic intersections of art and theatre at the book's core. Though Perry, Joseph Roach, and Shearer West investigate the early actresses from their respective scholarly positions, their work effectively models the interdisciplinarity demanded by the material. Perry and West are both art historians, and Roach is a theatre historian and performance studies theorist; all three have written book-length studies on actors and actresses. Their contributions to The First Actresses reflect their disciplinary approaches.
Perry and West devote more time to the technique and composition of the portraiture and its place in art history, whereas Roach focuses on the celebrity “image” of Nell Gwyn created through her performances as an actress, a royal mistress, and a national icon. Though the essays are shaped by their authors' diverse scholarly and research perspectives, they are not hindered by them. Roach takes seriously the circulation and consumption of Nell Gwyn through portraiture, and Perry and West interweave art and theatre histories in their discussions of critical reception of the figure of the actress. Though the essays are discrete, well written, and stimulating in their own rights, they are strengthened and enriched by their consideration as part of an integrated, collaborative project. Roach's close study of Nell Gwyn foregrounds ideas about image, representation, celebrity, and the body that receive continued investigation in Perry's and West's broader surveys of actress-dancers, aging, and the star system.
In the first essay, “Nell Gwyn and Covent Garden Goddesses,” Roach defines Gwyn as an “image” produced when “the idea of a celebrity—character, life-story and look—circulates in the absence of her person” (64). He uses contemporary jargon, such as “nipple slip” and “pin-up,” to position “Nell,” as she was commonly known, as a Restoration “brand” circulating in public through portraiture, “star-sightings” at the theatre, and her infamous liaisons, most notably with Charles II. Roach proposes Gwyn as a “model for the new professional career of actress-celebrity” (71). The first of Perry's two essays follows: in “Divas, Dancing and the Rage for Music,” she explores the popularity and reception of singing and dancing, two skills often required of the early actresses. Women were both praised and morally condemned for the public display of these talents in performance and portraiture. Using several women's careers as evidence, Perry argues that the eighteenth century generated the first musical divas, a term with contemporary resonances. Shearer West then explores what happens when divas fade in “Beauty, Ageing and the Body Politic.” West cites visual and written criticism directed at the early celebrities as their bodies changed with pregnancy and aging. Her comparative analysis of representations of Sarah Siddons throughout her career effectively illustrates her argument: Siddons, once portrayed as strong and classical, resorted to “air-brushed” effects meant to make her appear youthful despite her advance in years. The second of Perry's essays rounds out this part of the book. In “Star Systems Then and Now,” a rumination on the amateur theatricals that gained popularity in the eighteenth century, she explores the divide between amateur and professional performers through careful analyses of portraiture that expressed the tensions among them, such as James Gillray's 1802 Blowing-up the Pic Nic's;-or-Harlequin Quixote attacking the Puppets. Finally, Perry makes explicit the parallels between the eighteenth-century “commercial culture of consumption” (129) and the contemporary world of film and photograph.
The First Actresses: Nell Gwyn to Sarah Siddons brings together the rich visual and written histories of art and theatre to document the lives and experiences of the early actresses. While it successfully makes a case for the comparison of eighteenth-century celebrity culture and that of the present, at times one might wish for more careful historicization of the differences between then and now. The book's strength lies in its interdisciplinarity and collaborative spirit, which makes it a welcome addition to historical scholarship on art and theatre in the eighteenth century, and on the first actresses.
