This is an ambitious book that aims to delineate the evolving configurations of masculinity in China across three millennia of history. In attempting to produce a monograph that is manageable in scope, the author adopts a chronological approach, devoting each of the eight chapters to the analysis of a particular theme within a given dynastic framework. The first chapter examines the Zhou dynasty (1046–256 BCE), exploring the separation of the two sexes with respect to work roles, space, and broader cosmological patterns of thought. Building on this foundation of gender differentiation, the second chapter investigates how the culture of personal and group honor, often expressed through violence and vengeance, structured male behavior in the Han dynasty (206 BCE–220 CE). The third chapter, on the Jin dynasty (265–420 CE), taps into the intersections of religion and masculinity, especially how the introduction of Buddhism in early China confronted prevailing indigenous ideas about proper Chinese manhood by rejecting, appropriating, or transforming them. The fourth chapter, on the Tang dynasty (618–907 CE), presents an intriguing analysis of the ways in which the social construction of masculine norms crucially depended upon, as well as shaped, the real and imagined dynamics of women's lives. The examples included in this chapter, such as chastity narratives, self-mutilation tales, shrew stories, divorce, a Daoist nun craze, and the pursuit of a courtesan career, shed unique light on the complexity of female autonomy within the context of a study centered on men.
The second half of the book addresses the period since the tenth century. The fifth chapter, on the Song dynasty (960–1279 CE), traces the emergence of the literate (wen) man as the exemplar of elite hegemonic masculinity. Borrowing the concept of “cultural capital” from Pierre Bourdieu, the author highlights the role of the civil service examination system (which remained in place for the remainder of imperial history) and its sophisticated institutionalization in solidifying the link between taste and manhood in this period. As a result, aesthetic pursuits, such as tea connoisseurship, calligraphy, and peony admiration, became central to this new cultural icon of masculine virtue. This period also witnessed the rise of tension between elitism and commercialization, which manifested itself in concrete terms as a continual tug-of-war for status between male literati and merchants. The sixth chapter examines the rise of the haohan (“good fellow”) archetype as the exemplar of plebeian masculinity in the Ming dynasty (1368–1644 CE). Hinsch explains that “as wen masculinity was too remote to be relevant to the lives of most men, martial wu manhood idealizing confrontation and violence presented a far more realistic alternative” (p. 111).
The final quarter of the book is concerned with the general theme of modernization. The seventh chapter looks at the messy reconfigurations of normative masculinity in the late Qing-Republican era transition period (circa 1843–1949). China's embarrassing defeats by Western and Japanese powers in the nineteenth century traumatized the nation and feminized Chinese men. In response, Western standards of manhood were quickly domesticated; new visions of iconoclastic intellectual manliness developed based on ardent critiques of Chinese traditional culture; and with the introduction of capitalism in major urban areas of the country, a new middle-class masculinity emerged in tandem with an unprecedented enthusiasm for sports, physical fitness, the nuclear family ideal, and modern Western science and technology. With respect to the spaces of socialization, the transitions were most evident in the decline of tea houses and the growing popularity of the cinema. The final chapter looks at shifting paradigms of gender in the socialist period, such as the communist egalitarian vision of androgyny in the Maoist era, the masculine stereotypes of ethnic minorities, and the material symbols of male success that typified the reform era and beyond.
The author should be commended for synthesizing an enormous body of materials (mostly secondary sources) with considerable breadth in a concise and highly readable book. In light of its ambition and aim, however, the book opens itself up to a number of potential minor criticisms. In terms of chronological coverage, certain key episodes of Chinese history, such as the High Qing period, are left untouched in the analysis. Although the decision to focus on one particular theme in any given chapter is undoubtedly a strategic choice, the book leaves unanswered the question of how some of the themes explored in detail in a single chapter may have changed over time and even overlapped with some of the other themes explored in the context of other epochs. For example, in what ways has the relationship between religion and masculinity shifted across time? How has religion intersected with science or class in the constructions of normative manhood from the late imperial period onward? Given that the Manchus ruled the Qing, what role did ethnic minorities play, if any, in the development of Chinese masculinities before the People's Republic of China? In light of Hinsch's earlier seminal work on male same-sex relations in imperial China, one may have reasonably anticipated some discussions of queer, trans, or even female masculinities, and how these might have challenged the forms of normative manhood around which he structures his chapters. However, these topics are largely absent from the book.
