Richard Goldthwaite is the preeminent economic historian of Renaissance Florence. For this volume he has collaborated with musicologist Tim Carter to investigate the life of the Tuscan composer Jacopo Peri (1561–1633), who produced Europe's first surviving opera, Euridice (1600). The discovery of Peri's account books has made it possible to reconstruct his social and economic strategies while helping to delineate the contours of an urban economy that had long been one of the centers of early capitalism. For despite generations of research into the economic history of Florence, the transformations underway at the end of the Renaissance remain poorly studied, particularly in Anglophone historiography.
Orpheus in the Marketplace is divided into six parts: an introduction and a conclusion, meaty chapters on Peri's social, economic, and musical lives, and a chapter on his last years and the fate of his wealth. This book has its amusing vignettes. Yet, Orpheus is not a biography in the traditional sense, but rather a series of targeted inquiries prompted by the account books. They reveal an individual for whom music constituted a relatively minor part of his economic strategy. Peri emerges as a savvy courtier and social climber whose goal of portraying himself as a Florentine nobleman was partially successful; and who, thanks to lucky dowries (Peri married three times) and wise business investments, accumulated an impressive patrimony that put him in the upper tier of the middling ranks. These stories are interesting and well told, but it is Orpheus’ analysis of the economic aspects of musicianship, and the larger investigation of the Florentine marketplace, that will engage readers of this journal.
Goldthwaite has argued for placing artistic production near the center of Renaissance economic life, and it is now common to view, e.g., painters as entrepreneurs in their own right. One might think it easy to extend this model to musicians: not so. Owing to the nature of their art, which was “consumed” at the moment of listening, musicianship was not “collected” the way people collected paintings or objects. Music offered less of a path to accumulating wealth than other arts. And yet, because music left musicians time to pursue other interests—they were needed only for occasional purposes—an enterprising musician could busy himself with the marketplace. Peri's economic activities were typical not of artists but of well-to-do Florentines in general. He made substantial investments in real estate, the city's textile industries, and various credit instruments intended to afford an annuity. The purpose of his economic activity was the construction of a patrimony to transmit to his posterity.
Peri's projects were aided by two developments in late Renaissance Florence: the florescence of the Medici court, which funneled patronage to cultural producers such as Peri (“welfare economics,” as the authors observe on p. 353); and the availability of new forms of government bonds, which provided a safe venue for investment. And that was also the problem with the Florentine economy: a growing gap between the very rich and the very poor, with a new middling class dependent on the patronage of the elite. Investment opportunities in the old forward sectors of the economy, the textile industries, were few. As for his social superiors, land and credit were Peri's best bets.
Broadly, two forces were reshaping the Florentine economy in the decades around 1600. First, the decline of its export industries limited the spigot of new wealth entering the city, although silk garments and other artistic exports remained important. The pie was no longer growing by the late Renaissance. The other force is the spread of a “gusto for things” among the middling and elite classes, who began to fill their homes with a profusion of objects.Footnote 1 A local class of artificers for producing these objects benefited from this form of patronage. Thus, though the urban economy did not apparently grow, it did diversify. While the poor and unskilled had a hard time making ends meet in this economy, those with the skills to satisfy the new demands could do well for themselves.
One wishes that Orpheus took greater pains to contextualize Florence with respect to changes in the Italian and European economies. But it does place Peri into relationship with his local Florentine context. And one point the authors insist upon is that the economic history of Florence during what Eric Cochrane called “the forgotten centuries” awaits its historian. The archival evidence in the form of account books exists. What we lack are the organizing questions. Jacopo Peri's economic biography suggest a few important issues: the relationship between the city economy and its rural hinterland, possible entanglements of the new urban artisans with regional markets, and the effects of court or elite patronage in structuring the local market. One thing is already clear. Regardless of the relative decline of the Tuscan economy, Florence participated in larger transformations in early modern capitalism, from the rise of credit markets, to the embrace of a new world of goods. Not for nothing did Orpheus venture into the marketplace.
