European merchants and consuls had been part of the commercial and social fabric of Constantinople since Byzantine times. Very few studies, however, have addressed the intricate relationship of commerce and diplomacy that dominated the Mediterranean world and the Levant trade between the Ottomans and their European partners and rivals in a comprehensive manner. Scholars have assumed for a long time that the commercial treaties known as Capitulations (ahdnames) undermined the position of Muslim Ottoman merchants and opened up Ottoman markets to European goods and merchants in a manner that was detrimental to local manufacturers and merchants. This trend only worsened in the 19th century. Van den Boogert's study questions this received wisdom based both on European and Ottoman sources and shows the challenges faced by European merchants in Ottoman markets, notably, in Aleppo and Istanbul.
Ottoman and European archives contain a rich array of documentation regarding the activities of European merchants and consuls and their Ottoman protégés. Yet very few studies have attempted a systematic study of these sources to shed light on commercial encounters between various European nations and Ottoman merchants and authorities. Based on his study of Ottoman registers of foreign nations (ecnebi defterleri), Western consular records, and Ottoman, English, and Dutch archival sources consulted in Istanbul, London, and the Hague, the author argues that although the Capitulations regularized legal and commercial relationships, in practice much depended on economic, social, and political conditions at home and abroad. He emphasizes that although the Capitulations provided a measure of diplomatic immunity to Western nations and their dependents, in practice they were defined as part of the Ottoman legal system. Disputes between Ottoman subjects and European merchants were subject to constant negotiation among European merchants, consuls, and Ottoman officials that often went beyond the stipulations of the Capitulations.
The book is divided into six chapters, each offering several case studies. Chapter 1 frames the history of these relationships in the legal, diplomatic, and commercial encounters among European merchants, their dragomans, protégés, consuls, and local actors. After the conquest of Constantinople, Mehmed II granted commercial privileges to the Florentine and Genoese communities in a charter known as ahdname in Ottoman parlance. These privileges were later extended to other Latin communities in the 15th and 16th centuries. France, England, and Holland received more extensive trading charters (later known as Capitulations) in the 17th and 18th centuries. The change in the balance of power after the Treaty of Carlowitz (1699) led to an increase in the number of most-favored-nation treaties that the Ottoman empire granted to Western European countries (England, the Habsburg Empire, Sweden, France, Tuscany, Denmark, Russia, and Spain) from 1718 to 1782. France received extensive privileges in the renewed treaty of 1740, which became a model charter for other nations. Capitulations could be renewed, amended, and revoked by new Ottoman rulers after a long process of negotiations. Imperial orders could also regulate Capitulations.
Chapter 2 examines the status of Ottoman non-Muslim protégés. The Sublime Porte issued two kinds of berats, or deeds of appointment, to European consuls and vice consuls, dragomans, and protégés that allowed Europeans to live freely and safely in the Levant, own property, trade and travel, and enjoy legal protection. They were exempt from paying bac (transit tax), were subject to lower tariffs, were allowed to practice their religion, consume and produce wine in their houses, and retain Western dress. Ottoman non-Muslim subjects who received berats from the Sublime Porte acted as intermediaries between Ottoman authorities and European residents (consuls and traders) in the empire. They enjoyed European protection and diplomatic immunity and were exempt from cizye (poll tax), and some became European subjects to enjoy full rights. The 18th century saw a proliferation in the sale of berats by European consuls to non-Muslim Ottoman subjects and highest bidders who were sometimes not employees of European consuls. The author argues that despite considerable corruption, these berats were not instruments of European imperialism. The Ottoman treasury was at pains to revoke or regulate them and fought hard to extend its jurisdictions. The Ottoman protégés were not naturalized European subjects, could lose their berats, and always remained Ottoman subjects.
Chapter 3 reexamines the Ottoman avania, which contemporary Europeans and scholars define as undeserved injury, extortion, and unjust demand for monies by Ottoman officials. Van den Boogert provides nine examples of avania from the Dutch and English archives and reaches the conclusion that anyone could be subject to avania and that it was a form of legal settlement for disputes and homicide that involved foreigners and Muslims in shariʿa courts. Avanias were part of the Capitulations rather than a violation of the treaties and meant that foreigners were also under the jurisdiction of the Ottoman kanun and the shariʿa, although they seemed to have an inflated perception of their privileges.
Chapter 4 examines the application of Ottoman law to the division of the estates of European merchants and their protégés who were Ottoman beratli subjects. The Capitulations offered guarantees that Muslim authorities would not confiscate the estates of deceased foreigners, their dragomans, and protégés. However, loans contracted by the deceased had to be paid off before the division of the estate, which often involved Muslim creditors and debtors. Cases involving more than 4,000 akçces were heard in the imperial council. The qadi's jurisdiction prevailed in the negotiation and settlement of these cases and those involving Ottoman wives. Otherwise, the consuls had jurisdiction over the estates of their deceased subjects and their dragomans unless they married Ottoman subjects. An imperial order issued in 1791 declared that Europeans who married Ottoman wives would be considered Ottoman subjects.
In Chapter 5, the author demonstrates that despite the protection of Capitulations, frequent bankruptcies, fraudulent or real, exposed the fragile nature of the Levant trade and the vulnerability of many foreign merchants, who depended heavily on a network of creditors and debtors. The shortage of cash made letters of credit and bail (surety) important instruments of trade. Imprisonment of defaulting debtors at the request of creditors was a common practice according to Islamic law and the Capitulations. Consuls had full jurisdiction over bankrupt subjects and protégés unless Muslim creditors were involved, in which case the qadi got involved. Escape or conversion to Islam was one way of clearing all debts by Western debtors for a long time. As the ample evidence cited in the study shows, the financial losses of a Dutch trader in Istanbul undermined the position of his partners and creditors in Amsterdam, Izmir, and London. Moreover, bankruptcies created a maze of legal and diplomatic disputes that brought the different parties to the qadi's court, the residence of the consuls, and the imperial council. Different parties to the dispute constantly negotiated the terms of the Capitulations in light of Islamic law, local custom, and kanun.
Chapter 6 shows that the Islamic courts and Muslim notables played an important role in arbitration councils; the qadi exercised some jurisdiction in criminal matters that involved Muslim subjects and European traders. The case studies drawn mostly from Aleppo show the limited authority of the consuls and the Capitulations in practice.
The author successfully revises the myopic view held by many scholars regarding the negative impact of Capitulations on Ottoman economy and local traders. He shows that the European traders and their protected protégés were anything but a commercial cast with unquestioned and exclusive privileges denied to local traders. Their privileges were often the subject of constant negotiation between Ottoman authorities and European consuls. Despite the profitable commerce in the sale of berats by European consuls, their number did not exceed 300 by the end of the 18th century. The beratli merchants remained Ottoman subjects and were under the jurisdiction of both European consuls and Ottoman authorities. Only very deft and able protégés could navigate these multiple jurisdictions between Ottoman authorities and European consuls to their advantage.
The author makes an important contribution to the history of Ottoman–European diplomacy and commerce during the 18th century. More research is needed to shed light on the evolution of the relationship between European merchants and Muslim traders in the Ottoman lands. The story of Muslim merchants remains largely untold.
