In her latest work Jacky Bratton continues her mission to reinterrogate and reshape the prevailing perceptions of nineteenth-century theatre and theatre history. In New Readings in Theatre History (2003) she set out to ask ‘present-minded questions’ of the past while refusing ‘to give present-minded answers’ (p. 14) about how theatre history was constructed, transmitted and coopted in the pursuit of legislation and the establishment of theatrical and literary boundaries. In The Making of the West End Stage Bratton uses the methodologies developed in her earlier book to rewrite the picture of the mid-nineteenth-century theatre scene, revealing a world in which women play a prominent role off- as well as onstage. Considering all of the components that made the West End – industry, shopping, transport, competing tourist attractions, the press, literary Bohemians and the theatrical profession – she presents us with a beautifully controlled and composed history. It is an exemplary piece of historiographical scholarship, wide-ranging, engaging, generous to other scholars, imaginative in its approach and rigorous in its interrogation of sources and received conventions. Not content, for example, to note the oft-talked about anti-theatrical prejudice paraded in the Victorian press, Bratton notes that ‘the very proliferation and endless repetition of these journalistic jeremiads might suggest to us that they were not succeeding in their aim of suppressing or changing the theatre’ (p. 6), and in doing so prompts us to challenge the lazy conclusions often drawn from remaining evidence.
The book is divided into two parts: ‘Mapping’ and ‘Making’. The first establishes the contexts and conditions in which theatre was made, by surveying the streets, the press and the self-perception of Victorian theatre workers. Drawing on Michel de Certeau's notion of ‘walking the city’, the book begins by describing the journeys of an imaginary woman and man through the nascent West End before walking us through the leading theatrical paper of the time, The Era, and carefully unpicking the vagaries of the profession. The Making of the West End Stage considers the work itself; the rise of alternative theatrical forms; and the creators, producers and performers who shaped it.
As a historian of twentieth- and twenty-first-century theatre I value this book for providing a critical approach for thinking about and through performance in another era in which there was an abundance of performance types, London was being rebuilt and the boundaries about what constituted entertainment were being questioned. As a curator of archives and artefacts of the type studied by Bratton and her peers I appreciate how difficult, slow and painstaking it is to build up such a detailed, wide-ranging and compelling picture of the time. It is a pleasure to see them put to such foundational and inspirational use. In New Readings, Bratton praised Joseph Roach's Cities of the Dead: Circum-atlantic Performance for showing that ‘the subject of performance, if adequately theorised and imaginatively extended, offers wonderfully suggestive ways of dealing with its own absences’ (p. 7). The Making of the West End Stage is another inspiring example of this approach.
