The volume under review represents the proceedings of a conference which was shared by archaeologists working under the umbrella of the Tiber Valley Project of the British School at Rome and researchers from the University of Perugia in February 2004. As pointed out by the editors in their introduction (11 f.), the main point of this collaboration was to compare and contrast the results of recent fieldwork conducted in both the middle and upper river valleys. This undertaking has — at least in this reviewer's opinion — resulted in an, on the whole, important book which certainly succeeds in shedding new light on the wider region's socio-economic history throughout antiquity. The editors decided to publish both those contributions that were delivered in the form of research papers (15–344 on the upper Tiber valley; 417–836 on the middle valley respectively) and those represented by posters at the conference (345–416 and 837–952 respectively). Even though this decision must have considerably increased the size and price of the volume, it is, nevertheless, completely justified, in that many of the original posters dealt with preliminary results of field projects or detailed ceramic studies, and thus considerably add to the volume's value as a contribution to central Italian archaeology.
Regionalism in Italy has many dimensions, and the Tiber valley illustrates this fact in a (not so small) microcosm: not only does the river link a metropolis with its hinterland (to borrow N. Morley's phrase) and cut through a series of diverse ecologies along its course; but it also forms a boundary between several (and, over time, shifting) historical regions, amongst which Etruria and Umbria stand out most prominently. The latter point is duly emphasized by the contributions of S. Stopponi (‘La media valle del Tevere fra Etruschi e Umbri’, 15–44) and S. Sisani (‘Dirimens Tiberis? I confini tra Etruria e Umbria’, 45–86), both of which implicitly raise the pertinent question of how accurate and helpful these and (by extension) comparable ethno-historical definitions of regionalism are in the study of ancient Italy. As the work of the Tiber Valley Project in the middle valley has brought to our attention, this and related, culture-historical questions can, of course, be satisfactorily addressed only with chronological resolution of the archaeological evidence, which appears to be increasingly diverse even along the Tiber. Therefore, it is refreshing that three of the papers in the first two sections of the volume address crucial aspects of the production of material culture in the upper valley (J. U. Sáez, ‘Fundiary property and brick production in the high Tiber valley’, 123–42; R. Esteve, ‘Le produzioni ceramiche di epoca repubblicana nell'alta valle del Tevere’, 143–88; A. M. Poveda Navarro, ‘Commercialización de terra sigillata imperial en el alto valle del Tiber. La evidencia de Colle Plinio (S. Giustino, PG): sigilla y formas nuevas’, 189–214), even if it will take many years yet to bring our knowledge of these materials up to anything approaching our familiarity (thanks to the South Etruria Survey and Tiber Valley Project) with the materials produced downstream. Turning to the consumption of material culture in the latter area, of course, we cannot do without more of such detailed work on the productive activities that went on upstream. These, as is increasingly clear, accounted for a significant factor of the economy of central Italy, both as far as the City and its suburbium are concerned, and for those consumers living in settlements along the river and its immediate surroundings. For this reason, the other papers dealing with broader aspects of production, consumption and exchange — including the modalities, élite involvement and types of goods produced along and traded down (and maybe also up?) the upper reaches of the Tiber — throw open exciting perspectives for the study of regional archaeology in the Tiber valley and beyond.
The phrase ‘and beyond’ is a deliberate statement here since it ultimately reflects on the potential, fulfilled and unfulfilled, of the volume as a whole: the paper by R. Witcher in the section(s) concerned with the middle river valley (‘The Middle Tiber valley in the Imperial period’, 467–86) is a thought-provoking discussion not only in terms of what the author claims in its title; but it also provides a much-needed discussion of how the results obtained via a range of archaeological routes of enquiry can form part of a new approach towards regionalism — which appears to be even more important in a methodologically diverse volume like this. In this context, Witcher singles out the relevance of some of the ideas expressed by P. Horden and N. Purcell in their The Corrupting Sea (2000), which, as this reviewer would also argue, may provide a stimulating conceptual framework within which to interpret the ever-increasing, new and re-studied regional data sets. As far as the middle Tiber valley is concerned, these are truly impressive, as is well known to anyone vaguely familiar with the publications that continue to come out of the Tiber Valley Project.
The contributions to the second part of the volume once again reinforce the latter point, with chapters on subjects as diverse as ‘Villas, horticulture and irrigation infrastructure’ (A. Wilson, 731–68), late antique burials (V. Fioccho Nicolai, ‘Nuove acquisizioni nell'ambito dell'archeologia funeraria tardoantica nella media valle del Tevere’, 533–59), and the supply of basalt for the construction of roads (S. Black, J. Browning and R. Laurence, ‘From quarry to road: the supply of basalt for road paving in the Tiber valley’, 705–30) — let alone the chronological surveys based (primarily) on ceramic distribution patterns, or the chapters presenting the results of recent fieldwork. (The space available for this review does not allow one to scratch the contents of these contributions even on the surface; many of these, in contrast to the work on the upper valley discussed in more detail above, have already been presented in other publications related to the Tiber Valley Project.)
Following on from this, it is an overall outlook and a uniting theme going beyond the broadly unifying criterion of recent studies in the archaeology of the upper and middle Tiber valley which are critically missing from the volume — with the notable exception of Witcher's paper (see above) and the somewhat deterministic and unconvincing modelling suggested by S. Graham in his contribution (‘The space between: the geography of social networks in the Tiber valley’, 671–86). Yet, as a collection of recent approaches and results, this volume is of crucial importance to anyone working in this part of the world — and this relevance goes far beyond the archaeological community, stretching to historians of the text and students of ancient literature alike. Still, it remains regrettable to note that the editors do not provide an overall introduction, even if this were merely to expand upon the inspired (or so it would seem) Leitmotif of Mercator placidissimus. As it stands, the volume thus remains a collection of excellent papers, geographically coherent yet not pushing all the way to give the reader more than the sum of the individual contributions.
This last criticism notwithstanding, Mercator Placidissimus ought to and, no doubt, will become one of the standard collections of work in the archaeology of central Italy. Some of the editing of, in particular, the contributions in English leaves room for improvement, as do a number of illustrations and maps. However, this cannot in any way be blamed on either the editors or contributors to what is, overall, a highly promising addition to the field.
