Tuesday 25 February (London)
I dined with Lady Abercromby alone and heard a great deal from her that was interesting to me. The Queen, when she told her that I had made a speech in support of the Government and the Zulu War,Footnote 684 said, “Oh, but you know it is his war.” This is another indication of the line that Disraeli has taken. He has, I think it is clear, laid the responsibility of the war on me as the result of my annexation of the Transvaal.Footnote 685 Salisbury is, I hear, in much favour with the Queen, and Lady S. is perpetually retailing all sorts of gossip and scandal to the Queen. What is really bad, she tells frequent stories against the Derbys. This is only what I believe she did last summer in London but it is not the less odious.
Thursday 20 March (London)
Some talk with Derby on the Zulu debate on next Friday. He put the case very clearly against Frere.Footnote 686 I told him of my personal difficulty in condemning Frere and he was evidently not surprised. So we parted with an understanding on the subject.
Tuesday 25 March (London)
Zulu debate in the House. I spoke to a thin house as it was close upon 8 o'clock when I began, but a very attentive one. On the whole I was tolerably satisfied when I ended with what I had said and the way of saying it, and Bath and EnfieldFootnote 687 who were there told me that they thought it was quite a good speech, if not better, than they had heard me make. I was about an hour.Footnote 688
Monday 19 May (London)
Derby wrote to propose to come to me to discuss Frere's despatch in yesterday's papers which seems to suggest the abandonment of the Transvaal.Footnote 689 I said I should be happy and he came – to argue strongly that the annexation had been an experiment, that it had failed and that it was desirable to give the Government help in getting rid of the bad bargain. My answer generally was that I felt sure that we should soon hear more fully from Frere in explanation of this despatch; that though I was prepared to accept changes and withdrawal of policy if necessary, yet that I thought this was particularly a case for great caution and for no hurry, and one too in which it is quite fair to let the Government find their own way out of the difficulty in which they have placed themselves or been placed. I afterwards wrote to him again in much the same sense. But it is quite clear to me that it would be a very foolish thing for me at all events to take the initiative. If I must accept the abandonment of the annexation, I am anyhow not the person to propose it.Footnote 690
Tuesday 27 May (London)
I made an enquiry in the House as to the relations of G. Wolseley to the present Lieutenant-Governors of Natal and the Transvaal.Footnote 691 It is clear that he is sent out in a military capacity rather than a civil one though his appointment does two things: supersedes Chelmsford and gives a very decided buffer to Frere. I almost expect Frere now to resign.Footnote 692
I made a short speech on a Malay question afterwards brought forward by Stanley of Alderley.Footnote 693
We dined at the Goschens, met the Gladstones and Childers amongst others.
Friday 27 June (London)
Later I brought up my Armenian case in the House of Lords. ElsieFootnote 694 and Winifred went into the Peeresses’ Gallery to hear. I think my statement was fair enough. Salisbury's reply was in argument very weak, and the ground he took up in the repudiation of all responsibility in Asia Minor was extraordinarily inconsistent with all that was said last year as anything that was ever said in Parliament.Footnote 695 It was a most strange speech, to which MorleyFootnote 696 and Granville both gave a very good answer. What is the meaning of it? Did Salisbury in Cabinet object to the English Protectorate and now, when in difficulty, go back to his old opinions? Disraeli has not been in the House the last two nights. One way or another I think the Government are failing.
Friday 11 July (London)
This evening Mr. Corry met me after the Committee as I was going into the House and asked for a few minutes conversation. He then asked me from Lord Beaconsfield whether I would be willing to undertake the Chairmanship of the Commission moved for the other evening by H. ChaplinFootnote 697 on the agricultural distress, its causes, etc.Footnote 698 I said it was a very large and important matter and must take a little time to consider. I promised an answer by Sunday afternoon.
Tues 15 July (London)
A debate in the House of Lords on the Vivisection billFootnote 699 introduced by Lord Truro.Footnote 700 Beauchamp's tone offended me much and I attacked him rather severely for it.Footnote 701
Friday 25 July (Highclere)
I received a letter from Northcote in answer to my last long recapitulatory communicationFootnote 702 saying that the Government were grateful to me but that they perceived the difference of opinion was wider than they had at first thought and that they would look to some other arrangement.Footnote 703 Northcote's letter was very friendly and I wrote him back a few lines in a very friendly tone saying that I thought the Cabinet were quite right in their decision. And I am also very glad to be spared the work [. . .].
I suspect that they desired more of me than I was prepared to give. In one of his letters Disraeli spoke of the difference of opinion between us not only as to the composition but as to the duties of the Commission. Did this mean that he wished it to be worked in a class and sectional interest?Footnote 704
Oddly enough with this letter of Northcote's came one from Beach, knowing of course of the breakdown of these negotiations, asking me to take the Chair of a smaller Commission to consider the various military and naval stations abroad, their defence, the mode of defence, the way in which the expense should be divided, etc.
Wednesday 30 July (London)
Beach called on me in Bruton Street to communicate with me as to the Colonial Defence Commission of which he wishes me to take the Chair. He was satisfactory in all he said. He proposes to make the Commission one perfectly fair as regards political parties, Childers, Brassey, myself, L. Simmons, Milne, Barkly. I raised some objection to Milne and Barkly, the first as not adequately representing the modern and scientific view of things, the second as not conferring any real strength on us, and I suggested Holland as a very useful addition, to which he agreed. I also said that I must have Jekyll, to which he assented, as Secretary. Subject to all this, I accepted.Footnote 705 I should on the whole have preferred not to have this particular task imposed but I hardly know how to decline.Footnote 706 I seem to live in a vicious circle of Royal Commissions but it cannot be helped.
Friday 8 August (London)
I went up to town by myself.
Beach called on me in Bruton Street to discuss and settle the question of the Colonial Defence Commission. It was agreed that the Commission should consist of myself as Chairman, Childers who has accepted, Brassey, Sir L. Simmons, Sir A. Milne, Sir H. Barkly and Holland, if he will serve, with Jekyll as Secretary. The whole affair passed off in a very quiet and friendly manner. But Beach's manner (I can hardly say why) gives me the notion that he is not on the most perfect terms with his colleagues or some of them.
Afterwards a long conversation with Bath who has just returned from his Bulgarian tour, which is still entirely in his mind. He is very bitter against the Government and especially against Salisbury and said to me that he would support even ArchFootnote 707 if he could damage the Government and take away from them a seat.
Later I urged the case of the India Museum in the House of Lords, but got an unsatisfactory reply from Hardy.Footnote 708 That august body was in extremis, scarcely anybody on the Opposition benches and an appearance of more than usual sleepiness and inactivity.
Thursday 14 August (London)
I went up by myself by an early train and took the Chair at an unofficial and informal meeting of the Colonial Defence Commission at the Colonial Office. We discussed preliminaries and I subsequently talked over the results of our discussion with Beach, who, I am bound to say, improves on acquaintance in business. He is I think straightforward and devoid of all shiftiness and he seems to me to be rather wide in his ideas on political matters, and to think more of what is desirable in a Colonial or Imperial than a party point of view. Jekyll, who is Secretary of the Commission, will take notes of all that passes and I therefore need not record it here.Footnote 709
Thursday 13 November (Pixton)
A very heavy post [. . .]. An important letter from Derby informing me that he had taken his name off the Carlton and giving me his reason, viz. that the “logic of events” in Lancashire had been irresistible and had compelled him to this.Footnote 710 I answered him at some length for it was a letter needing a reply.Footnote 711
Monday 29 December (Pixton)
In view of present events and of future contingencies it may perhaps be well, if only to clear my mind, that I should endeavour to put down very briefly what I conceive my political position to be.
I. The Position
(1) There has been extreme bitterness during the last two years towards me by many of the Cabinet and their supporters. All intercourse has ceased and hardly ever a letter passes. The only members of the Cabinet with whom I seem to be on anything like friendly terms are Sandon and Beach, perhaps Northcote.
(2) As regards political opinion I have long been conscious that I am considerably in advance of all the Government. They might perhaps concede as much as I should but it would be under pressure and not from any conviction. This of itself is not enough to prevent my acting with them. In many Conservative Cabinets there have been individuals by conviction much more Liberal than their colleagues. There are advantages and disadvantages in such conditions which need not be discussed here.
(3) With the general body of the party there is no necessary cause of quarrel. They distrust me and dislike me, but would gladly accept me or anyone else amongst their leaders if it suited party purposes. But a different question arises with regard to the Leaders. I do not trust them politically as regards neither convictions nor sound judgement. But this may be said of many other possible Cabinets and the amount of confidence which I should be ready to place in any conceivable Cabinet would after my past experience be limited. But the worst part of the business is that I cannot trust the most important section of the present Cabinet, personally as men. I think Beach is straightforward and there are some others whose word like his I would accept in all ordinary transactions, but there are some who are absolutely and as I know by experience, are [sic] perpetually intriguing either with or against each other. My offences in their eyes have been great, and after what has passed my political honour and certainly comfort would not be safe unless there were an infusion of some new and purer elements upon which I could count.
(4) But it may be said that there is not enough in this to call for a complete alienation from the party. The answer to this is that the party so far as London politicians and London society are concerned, have completely drawn aside from me. They have endeavoured to mark their displeasure sometimes by personal isolation, sometimes by petty spite. I at least, owe them nothing, and am free to consider my own course of action without the slightest reference to them.
As regards the party generally, the old principles whatever they were worth are gone. The Conservatives have become Tory Democrats avowedly appealing to a combination of the Crown and Populace. What policy they have is flashy and dangerous. They have found out the dangerous secret of appeal to the warlike spirit of the non-tax paying part of the community, and they are such bad financiers that there is a serious risk of permanent mischief.
II.
(1) The question is hardly less difficult when I come to consider my position with the Liberals in office. In a really Radical Government I could have no confidence, or hope, or sympathy. It is very different as regards the Whigs. With them I have always had many friendly relations. Socially and intellectually, there are many bonds of union and much personal kindness has been shown me by many of them, as indeed by many more advanced Liberals when I have been thrown over by my supposed friends. Except in Church questions I probably agree with the Whigs as much as I do with any party and I have indeed some points of sympathy with some of the best of the more advanced Liberals. It may easily become a question how a public man may do most good whether in supporting a Conservative or Liberal Government. Nothing would be more dangerous I believe than a shift of the whole political ballast of property towards the Conservative side. It would be a repetition, but a much more dangerous one, of what occurred in Mr. Pitt's day. There is a strong tendency already in this direction and a risk that the Whig or moderate liberal party should become unduly weakened. It is perhaps possible to render the greatest service to support and so restrain a Liberal Government.
(2) Gladstone may be an important factor in the future political arithmetic. To me he is not a cause of apprehension. There are things I regret and in which I disagree, but I have far more in common with him than with most living statesmen and I am perfectly convinced that the very Radical schemes with which he is credited are wilful misrepresentation or absolute delusions. If I am wrong in this I have no pretence to understand character and am absolutely unfit to do another stroke of public work. My belief is that the Conservative and cautious side of his character largely exceeds the Liberal and the impulsive side. His political errors are those of a generous temperament and an unduly strong morality. His merits are perfect simplicity and truthfulness of character.
III.
(1) What position shall I take up when Parliament meets? Derby having to all intents and purposes, if not openly, joined the opposition, my impression is that it will be wise to retain my present seat, to watch events and not to attack the Government unnecessarily. With the general election change must come. Both parties must declare their policy and it will now be time enough for me to take a more decided course. Morally I feel quite free to act, as I may think best; politically I believe there is a road open to me in either direction.
