Although it is not readily apparent from its title, cover or framing, this book is a Festschrift to an academic department in order to celebrate its 50th anniversary. A number of scholars working in or affiliated with the Department of Political and International Studies at the University of Hull have contributed to a book dealing with a variety of state-related activities. The result is a sprawling volume containing thirteen short chapters, including an introductory and a concluding chapter by the editors.
A generous reading of the book would be to find that it covers amazingly large ground in 220 pages. In order of appearance: welfare state retrenchment, problems of welfare state growth, the welfare role of civil society associations, the challenge of diversity and multi-culturalism, the importance of constitutions, the post-war history of the British welfare state, the changing nature of public administration, the dominance of financial capital and the socialisation of risk, ecological modernisation, Brazilian social policies, human rights interventions, European military and defence policies and then finally back to the withering of the welfare state. I failed to come up with a common theme apart from the fact that all chapters to some degree deal with state activities in the Western world.
My favourite piece in this bewildering variety of topics is Bhikhu Parekh's eloquently argued and beautifully written defence of ethnic diversity and multi-cultural policies. Parekh points out that concerns that diversity and multi-culturalism in themselves would undermine the welfare state rest on shaky empirical foundations. Furthermore, such arguments seem to pre-suppose that a strong sense of identity and solidarity in the population is needed to uphold the welfare state. Were this the case, Parekh argues, the welfare state would have been impossible in the first place, since modern societies always and everywhere harbour a wide range of lifestyles and values. Parekh then goes on to outline the contours of a well-functioning multi-cultural welfare state, based on reciprocity and mutual respect rather than on strong identity and similarity. He comes across as a voice of reason and moderation, badly needed in this charged field.
A less generous reading of the book would be to say that it is completely incoherent, that it consists of a sample of stapled-together papers with little joint focus of attention. Several of the chapters have little relation to the title or main framing of the book and there are no cross-references between them.
Volumes like these can sometimes be salvaged by a skilful editor, who might be able to contort an ex-post facto common analytical frame for the book, or at least bring out some common themes or tensions from the chapters. Unfortunately, neither the introductory nor the concluding chapters make any attempt at this. They are self-contained little reflections, without any systematic discussion of the contents of the rest of the volume. Perhaps the task to bring out the common core of the chapters was just impossible, but in my opinion it should at least have been tried.
Since there is clearly a fair degree of tension between the chapters this could have been a theme for the framing of the volume. Not all authors seem to share the editors’ gloomy outlook on the current prospects for the welfare state, or even their underlying scholarly or ideological commitments, and it would have been worthwhile to bring out these tensions in the framing chapters. Or we might have been offered some reflections on the past and current scholarship of the particular department which the volume is set up to celebrate, and how the current volume reflects these intellectual endeavours. I could even have settled with the faintest hint that all these scholars have something more in common than their affiliation to an academic institution located at the Humber estuary. But the readers get nothing of the sort.
Publishers these days seem to view edited volumes with a fair degree of scepticism. Books like this one may be a reason why.
