This collection of eight papers, edited by Eun-Su Cho, Professor of Philosophy at Seoul National University, focuses on an area of history and culture that has been largely neglected by scholars of religion, namely, the tradition of female Buddhist practice in Korea from the formal introduction of Mahayana Buddhism from Central Asia via China in the fourth century until the present. While it is commonly assumed that the history of monasticism in Korea is only the history of monks, through the examination of historical records and biographical excerpts, these papers show that nuns too have maintained a tradition of religious practice and commitment to Buddhist teaching. In contrast with the Theravada order of fully ordained nuns, which died out in South Asia in the eleventh century, the order of Mahayana nuns in East Asia survived into modern times. Professor Eun-Su Cho suggests this was in large part due to a sixth-century change in the Vinaya precepts that encouraged monastics to work to support themselves instead of depending on the receipt of alms from the lay community. This innovation permitted nuns as well as monks a degree of economic self-sufficiency, allowing them to survive in the event that governmental favour and support was withdrawn.
Buddhism appears to have flourished in Korea from soon after its introduction until the end of the fourteenth century when, in the process of organising the society in accordance with neo-Confucian ideology, the Choson dynasty (1392–1910) initiated a vigorous suppression of Buddhism. While both monks and nuns were treated as outcasts, as women and Buddhists, nuns suffered double oppression. In a society that treated women as the property of their fathers, husbands and sons, laywomen as well as nuns were obliged to largely conceal their religious beliefs and practice. As a result, most female Buddhists lived and died anonymously. Although after colonisation by Japan (1910), Korean Buddhists were permitted more latitude, only after the end of the Korean War (1953) and especially in the final decades of the twentieth century has the bhiksuni sangha achieved a public presence. Nevertheless, academic scholarship in Korea, as in the West, has largely ignored Korean female Buddhist practice, an omission that this volume sets out to rectify.
The scholars whose work is included here have faced many obstacles, notably a scarcity of primary source material. Women's activities in general have been left out of official histories. Although information about Buddhist women may sometimes be gleaned from accounts of the lives of their prominent fathers and spouses, of those lacking ties to remarkable men there is virtually no trace. Given that in a Confucian society women were barred from receiving a classical Chinese education, Korean nuns could not write Chinese in which all ‘serious’ writing was done. Thus autobiographical material is extremely rare. Furthermore monks could not write about nuns since by doing so they would invite accusations of violating the rules of gender separation and hierarchy. The earliest mention by name of a Buddhist woman in an official history dates from the mid-sixth century. Occasional accounts of the outlook and achievements of important nuns appear in stupa and tomb inscriptions dating from the Koryo dynasty (918–1392); but from early in the Choson dynasty until the mid-twentieth century, aside from nuns’ misdeeds noted in government records and donations by aristocratic ladies to monasteries listed in monastic gazetteers, little mention of Buddhist women has been found.
Owing to the Choson dynasty's imposition of an ideology of male primacy on Korean society and their oppression of Buddhism, seclusion in meditation rooms and mountain monasteries became the preferred lifestyle among Buddhist women. Furthermore, despite the steadily increasing freedoms they enjoyed following the Japanese occupation in 1910 and continuing after independence in 1945, they clung to their reclusive lifestyle. During the Purification Movement of the 1950s and 1960s, married monks who, after being introduced during the colonial period, had dominated the Korean sangha, were ousted and in a few cases their monasteries were handed over to nuns. But even though as a result the status of women in the Buddhist community rose rapidly, few nuns left any written record of the largely favourable changes they had experienced.
It appears that nuns socialised over many centuries to submit to, or wherever possible avoid, monks, responded to new opportunities in traditional fashion, namely by becoming as self-sufficient as possible, a strategy that has brought benefits. By establishing numerous meditation centres and doctrinal (education) institutions, their status in the eyes of the general population has been much enhanced and their numbers greatly increased. The bhiksuni sangha now equals the bhiksus’. Nevertheless, they remain inferior to monks. Although in 2003 for the first time a nun was appointed to a prominent position in the central administration of the Chogye order, the largest Buddhist order in Korea, since nuns are still ineligible for most senior positions, they continue to be excluded from making sangha policy.
With its meticulously researched and clearly written overview of the development, survival and renewal in recent decades of the Korean bhiksuni sangha, Korean Nuns and Laywomen: Hidden Histories, Enduring Vitality fills a major gap in East Asian Buddhist history.
