This book is one of a series on the needs of able pupils: previous titles have looked at Art, PE and Design and Technology. It is introduced by Deborah Eyre of the National Association for Gifted and Talented Youth (NAGTY) and is intended to support teachers in secondary schools who wish to provide more effectively for those pupils designated musically talented. Issues of what is giftedness and who is talented, particularly when associated with music, are contentious and have been interpreted in a number of different ways by education professionals, pupils and parents. Since the introduction of Curriculum 2000 in England, there has been an increased focus on the teaching and learning of able students, leading a number of schools to pioneer strategies for ensuring that the most able students are not neglected. This book examines the rationale for inclusive education for the most able in all subjects and then focuses on how such students may be identified and better supported in their musical education.
In English secondary schools music departments have traditionally tended to ‘do their own thing’ and have nurtured talented and able musicians in whatever ways they can. However, the limitations have often been the size of the music department and the number of teachers who are available to support the wide range of musical interests which students bring with them. So, for example, when a music teacher with a background as a church organist encounters a pupil whose skill and talent is as a heavy metal guitarist, it may be difficult to assess whether or not the pupil is genuinely able, unless specialist help and advice is sought. This situation has been exacerbated in the last 15 years by the massive developments in technology which now allow young people to master concepts which would have been unthinkable in the late 1980s, when many teachers were trained.
This book and the supporting CDRom are designed for practitioners to use, in order to design programmes and support pupils with particular talents or abilities in music. However, one of the questions must be whether traditionally proud music teachers will consult such a useful book? There are probably as many definitions of musical ability as there are music teachers and this diversity is a major strength of the profession; but it is also a weakness, since it can cause teachers to be complacent about their own ability to define and recognise musical ability. This publication uses broad definitions and a wide range of musical exemplification to illustrate different aspects of musical ability which may commonly be found in secondary schools. Additionally it considers the cognitive, creative and other parameters necessary for describing a musically able or talented student.
The Secondary National Strategy for England's music pilot offers a number of suggestions and opportunities for teachers to encourage gifted and talented pupils in secondary schools.Footnote 1 In particular, unit 5, of the pilot music programme, ‘Challenge in Music’ provides an additional view of what may constitute the able musician, but also challenges teachers to understand and recognise ability in its many different representations. The Secondary National Strategy Pilot programme was not complete when this publication went to press, but references to the work of the pilot programme are included. Comparisons with other arts subjects are made including a quotation from an NFER (2000)Footnote 2 report which states that ‘Music was the most problematic and vulnerable art form’. Music teachers in general might be reluctant to acknowledge this to be the case, but in some instances, the genre- or style-specific nature of much music education has led to a fragmented approach where individual pupils’ needs or interests are sometimes threatened. Music teachers should acknowledge the many generic definitions of gifted and talented achievement, to which music education can contribute. Musical activity can educate the emotions, support physical and cognitive development and provide vital creative links between young people, and other generations. Musical performances and compositions are often presented by young people identified as being talented, or able. What constitutes ability in music still needs further defining and examples of musical achievement should continue to be collected in order to allow discussion to achieve a consensus. This publication offers significant, constructive support for teachers, and makes a major contribution to the debate about musical ability. It should be compulsory reading for all Heads of Music and those researching this important aspect of music teaching.
