Editors E. Patrick Johnson and Ramón H. Rivera-Servera write in their introduction to Blacktino Queer Performance that this hybrid anthology of nine performance scripts, each richly supplemented by a critical essay, interview, and production photographs, is intended “to cull the richness of our multiple subjectivities that would allow for the confluences, comparisons, and contradictions therein” (2). To achieve this, the editors introduce blacktino as a reading strategy across “a multiplicity of voices in the act of meaning making” (8). The collection is ultimately successful in the variety of performance pieces it collects and the critical responses to them, which sometimes contradict the artists’ interpretations. Because of this multiplicity and intertextuality, approaching the anthology as a whole may benefit readers more than excerpting individual selections.
The nine performance pieces, all by black and Latina/o queer playwrights and performance artists, represent a great variety of forms and are organized in no particular order, inspiring readers to conduct their own performative intertextual analyses. For instance, Charles Rice-González's I Just Love Andy Gibb is the most traditional play in the anthology, whereas Sharon Bridgforth's The love conjure/blues Text Installation is an abstract performance that combines video and movement with poetic language that “[c]laims the blues as ritual—in concert with Ancient practices and new creations” (22). Dancin’ the Down Low by Jeffrey Q. McCune Jr., a dance piece, and coeditor E. Patrick Johnson's Strange Fruit, a work of solo performance art, take starkly different approaches to gender, sexuality, and race. Johnson's piece and its companion interview and article are particularly illuminating regarding the relationship between artist and scholar.
Most of the performance pieces were presented in brief runs for niche audiences of queer black and Latina/o spectators and might not have been anthologized otherwise. By placing them together here, the editors open them up beyond those original limited audiences and productively complicate their meanings. For example, a gay man in Javier Cardona's dance piece Ah mén justifies his “flower-print briefcase” (260) to a group of threatening straight men by claiming his metrosexuality before they beat him in a choreographed dance. This moment of physical brutality as a means of controlling questionable masculinity is enriched by its echo in Pamela Booker's Seens from the Unexpectedness of Love and its lesbian lovers’ quarrel, staged as a boxing match complete with “sexy ringside ‘babe’” (431). Through boxing choreography, both women take on the roles of aggressor and victim, upending the typical butch–femme binary of many lesbian narratives. Both shows’ use of choreographed movement to represent violence brings them into the same conversation, but they diverge in that the violence comes from different spheres. In Ah mén, the queer body is abused by masculine outsiders threatened by men who behave like women, whereas in Seens, queer bodies abuse themselves as a result of their inner turmoil.
A similar intertextuality occurs across supplementary materials, with the artists and scholars occasionally, and productively, contradicting each other or even their own work. For example, in his interview with John Keene about Dancin’ the Down Low, McCune asks why “we assume that the politics of visibility are somehow more healthy than the politics of invisibility, or the politics of discretion” (336). Even though it is at the heart of his show, this question is shocking, particularly given the current climate engendered by Donald Trump's presidency, where being visible has once again become a political act. McCune's question stands in stark relief to Omi Osun Joni L. Jones's essay about Seens in which she credits Booker for “challeng[ing] the disremembering in which Black Queer people are omitted from Black history and Black life” (440). Jones implicitly answers McCune's troubling question, exemplifying how the anthology creates meaning out of a “multiplicity of voices” (8).
The articles and interviews are inconsistent in the kinds of detail they provide, and the lack of production information can be frustrating. For example, in Vershawn Ashanti Young's interview with Paul Outlaw discussing his fascinating solo show Berzerker about Nat Turner and Jeffrey Dahmer, she asks Outlaw, “Why this show? Why now?” (498). Without any production details, we do not know when “now” is, and his response suffers for it. However, the supplemental materials excel when they flesh out details about the actual performances that are not evident in the printed texts. For example, Tamara Roberts's essay about Machos, in which an all-Latina cast performed all-Latino characters, was particularly useful in describing Teatro Luna's creative process involving interviews with Latino men about their attitudes and experiences regarding masculinity. Roberts provides information about how these men performed masculinity during the interview process, which sometimes bolsters and other times contradicts their representations in the play. Then, in Patricia Ybarra's interview with the show's director, Coya Paz, the latter counters the play's representations of machismo as a cultural construction when she reveals that, even though she is a queer woman, she prefers socializing with straight Latino men because they “‘treat a lady like a lady’” by opening doors for her and carrying her bag (172). This is surprising, but it gets to the point of the anthology: multiple subjectivities are rich with “confluences, comparisons, and contradictions” (2).
It is unfortunate that, for all the editors’ hopes to give voice to a diverse group of queer artists, the collection includes more work by men than women, and no trans playwrights are included. As a result, many of the pieces tend to essentialize gender traits. But perhaps Johnson and Rivera-Servera could produce another volume to address that lack—which would be quite welcome because ultimately this collection is very rich, complex, and challenging, as the editors intended. The multiple voices and perspectives from these artists and scholars work together and against each other, which is indeed the point. It is not only that all these voices matter and deserve to be heard but also (and even more so) that, when these voices are heard together in the space of the same printed text, they mean more—and differently—than they would in the small theatre spaces where they were originally performed.
