Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-7pwfn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T07:37:05.211Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Scaling maximum spreading of droplet impacting on flexible substrates

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  07 March 2023

Yufei Ma
Affiliation:
Department of Modern Mechanics, University of Science and Technology of China, Hefei, Anhui 230026, PR China
Haibo Huang*
Affiliation:
Department of Modern Mechanics, University of Science and Technology of China, Hefei, Anhui 230026, PR China
*
†Email address for correspondence: huanghb@ustc.edu.cn

Abstract

We numerically study the impact of a droplet on superhydrophobic flexible plates, aiming to understand how the flexible substrate influences the maximum spreading of the droplet. Compared with the rigid case, the vertical movement of the flexible substrate due to droplet impact reduces the maximum spreading. Besides, the average acceleration $a$ during droplet spreading changes significantly. Arising from energy conservation, we rescale the acceleration $a$ for cases with different bending stiffness $K_B$ and mass ratio $M_r$. Moreover, through theoretical analysis, we propose a scaling for the droplet's maximum spreading diameter ratio $\beta _{max}$. In the scaling, based on the derived $a$, an effective Weber number $We_m$ is well defined, which accounts for the substrate properties without any adjustable parameters. In the ($\beta _{max}, We_m$) plane, the two-dimensional numerical results of different $K_B$, $M_r$ and rigid cases all collapse into a single curve, as do the experimental and three-dimensional (3-D) results. In particular, the collapsed 3-D data can be well represented by the universal rescaling of $\beta _{max}$ proposed by Lee et al. (J. Fluid Mech., vol. 786, 2016, R4). Furthermore, an a posteriori energy analysis confirms the validation of our a priori scaling law.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2023. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.(a) The physical problem (two dimensional). (b) The three-dimensional (3-D) case. Here, $W$ is the width of the plate.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Snapshots of impacting droplets at the maximum spreading with $We=60$ for rigid (blue) and flexible (red, $K_B=1.0$ and $M_r=0.01$) cases. In (a) the 2-D and (b) the 3-D cases, half and a quarter of the droplets are shown, respectively. Here, $d$ is the deflection of the plate at the centre. For the 3-D flexible case, on the plate, the contours of deflection in the $z$ direction are shown.

Figure 2

Figure 3.The $\beta _{max}$ as a function of $We$ for (a) a rigid substrate, where the black squares represent our 3-D simulation results, and the solid line denotes the scaling of Lee et al. (2016). (b) Results for a flexible substrate, where the red and black symbols denote our results and those from Dorschner, Chikatamarla & Karlin (2018), respectively.

Figure 3

Figure 4.The maximum spreading ratio $\beta _{max}$ as a function of $We$ for cases with different $K_B$ but identical $M_r=0.01$ (a,c), and different $M_r$ but identical $K_B=0.6$ (b,d). (a,b) Two-dimensional cases. (c,d) Three-dimensional cases. The solid curves represent the universal rescalings of Lee et al. (2016) for rigid cases.

Figure 4

Figure 5.Snapshots of an impacting droplet for rigid and flexible cases (two dimensional) at $We=30$, $M_r=0.01$ with different $K_B$: (a) rigid ($K_B=\infty$), (b) $K_B=4.0$, (c) $K_B=0.6$ and (d) $K_B=0.05$. Four typical moments (four columns) $t=0.04$, 0.15, $t_{max}$ and 0.7 are chosen. Here, $t_{max}$ is the moment when the maximum spreading occurs. The blue dotted lines denote the initial locations of the flexible plate. (d) Vertical deflection of the plate. In case (b), the spreading reaches $D_{max}$ after the plate's maximum deflection is achieved, namely, the delayed spreading case. In cases (c,d), the spreading reaches $D_{max}$ before that, namely, early spreading cases.

Figure 5

Figure 6.Local zoom-in view of a droplet impacting on the flexible plate with $We = 100$, $K_B=0.01$ and $M_r = 0.01$ at $t=0.2$. The blue dotted line denotes the initial location of the flexible plate.

Figure 6

Figure 7.The time evolution of $\beta$ (solid lines) and the total energy of plates $E_t$ (dotted lines) for rigid and flexible cases at $We=30$ with (a) different $K_B$ ($M_r=0.01$ is fixed), (b) different $M_r$ ($K_B=0.6$ is fixed). The arrows point in the direction that $K_B$ or $M_r$ decreases. Here, $E_t$ contains the elastic and kinetic energies of the plate, which is zero for rigid cases.

Figure 7

Figure 8.The time evolution of viscous dissipation (solid lines) and the total energy of substrates (dotted lines are identical to those in figure 7a) in cases of $We = 30$, $M_r=0.01$ but different $K_B$ (two dimensional). The viscous dissipation is calculated as $\mu _H (\partial u / \partial y)^2$ (Wildeman et al.2016). The droplet reaches the maximum spreading at $t_{max}=0.45$.

Figure 8

Figure 9.The total energy of plates at the maximum spreading $E_{t, max}$ as a function of (a) the initial kinetic energy $E_k$; and (b) $d_{max} E_k/(D_0+d_{max})$ for cases with different $K_B$ but a fixed $M_r=0.01$ (filled symbols), and those with different $M_r$ but a fixed $K_B=0.6$ (open symbols). The solid black lines denote $E_{t, max}=E_k$ and $E_{t, max}=d_{max} E_k/(D_0+d_{max})$ in (a,b), respectively. The colour of the symbols indicates the dimensionless maximum deflection of the plate $d_{max}/D_0$. Here, $E_{t,max}$ and $d_{max}$ are obtained through our numerical simulations (see the details of $E_{t,max}$ in figure 7).

Figure 9

Figure 10.The $\delta _{max}$ as a function of $We$ for the (a) 2-D and (b) 3-D cases of different $K_B$ ($M_r=0.01$). The symbols represent the numerical results. The solid curve denotes the prediction of (3.4).

Figure 10

Figure 11.The maximum spreading ratio $\beta _{max}$ as a function of $We_m$ in the (a) 2-D and (b) 3-D cases, where all symbols come from figure 4. The solid line is the scaling of Lee et al. (2016) for rigid cases. (c) Original experimental data ($\beta _{max}$ as a function of $We$) for rigid and flexible cases in Vasileiou et al. (2016). (d) Plot of $\beta _{max}$ vs $We_m$ (data are identical to those in c). For black squares (rigid cases), $We_m=We$. For the red disks, $We_m=We/(1+m_d/m_b)$ (Vasileiou et al.2016). For the blue disks, $We_m$ is obtained through (3.3) and (3.4).

Figure 11

Figure 12.The maximum spreading ratio $\beta _{max}$ as a function of $We_e$ in the (a) 2-D and (b) 3-D cases, where all symbols come from figure 4. The solid line denotes the scaling of Lee et al. (2016) for rigid cases.