Distance, Theatre, and the Public Voice seems a vague title for Melynda Nuss's detailed and well-written study. Nuss is not interested in distance, theatre or publicity per se, but in the changing relationships between Romantic authors and their publics. Distance indicates the separation between authors and audiences as reading and theatre-going publics expanded and diversified. Theatre suggests not the medium but a metaphor that, Nuss argues, allowed Romantic writers to strive for the ‘physicality of actor and audience’ while embracing ‘the mass distribution of print’ (p. 176). The above point might disappoint theatre scholars seeking insights into how playwrights and performers addressed lessening intimacy as theatres expanded – a question that Nuss elides. Yet in considering theatrical images in the closet drama and poetry of Lord Byron, William Wordsworth and Percy Bysshe Shelley (among others), Nuss makes a compelling case for the importance of theatre as a concept (if not as a reality) in Romantic literature.
The book begins on the stage, where Thomas Dibdin's 1812 pantomime Harlequin and Humpo articulated struggles between the intimacy of the old theatres and the spectacles of the new. In Chapter 2, Nuss examines the contest between imagination and materiality in Elizabeth Inchbald's sole closet drama and a play that Byron intended for the stage. The chapter culminates in an analysis of Byron's closet drama Sardanapalus, in which, Nuss argues, the poet ‘tries to capture the experience of theatrical performance without its material traces’ (p. 57). By Chapter 3, Nuss has left the stage, exploring theatrical metaphors in Wordsworth's play The Borderers and poems ‘The Discharged Soldier’, ‘The Thorn’ and ‘The Prelude’. By combining figures of actor and spectator, Nuss argues, Wordsworth imagines a ‘new kind of self’ that observes his surroundings but remains ‘fundamentally social’ (p. 117). Chapter 4 examines how Shelley uses the image of the broken, opened body in Prometheus Unbound and The Cenci to achieve the theatre's ‘power of presence’ (p. 148) without the inconveniences of embodiment. Chapter 5 examines how theatrical metaphors in essays by Leigh Hunt, Thomas De Quincey and William Hazlitt enabled the formulation of a ‘creative sublime’ capable of uniting diverse spectators without undermining their individualities (p. 153).
Distance, Theatre, and the Public Voice analyses the work of authors whose appeals to diverse, distant publics did not sacrifice the intimacy of an older medium. This has implications for both Romantic and Internet ages. The broad applicability of Nuss's ideas is, however, at times a weakness; it is not always clear why this issue was peculiar to the Romantic period or why Nuss chose these particular works to build her case. Nonetheless, Distance, Theatre, and the Public Voice will prove useful for nineteenth-century scholars examining the place of theatre in some of the most important Romantic works, as well as for new-media scholars seeking precursors to contemporary struggles between live performance's intimacy and the reach of mass culture.
