Elsie Rockwell's dense but illuminating Hacer escuela, hacer estado represents an important addition to the literature on post-revolutionary state formation. While the book's gestation seems long, given the surge of post-revisionist histories of education published in the last 15 years, and while Rockwell deploys the same conceptual apparatus as many post-revisionist historians, superficially adding to a sense of déjà vu, it is worth noting that critical interpretative differences abound, making this a matured and powerfully argued challenge rather than a regional addition to the literature. Most prominently, Hacer escuela, hacer estado revises the influential thesis of Mary Kay Vaughan, which posits the establishment, via the school, of a common discursive framework linking people and regime as the cornerstone of post-revolutionary hegemony. By contrast, Rockwell concludes, this ‘cultural construction’ did not penetrate so deeply (p. 350). Instead, it was the negotiated federalisation of Tlaxcala's state system, the subordination of local school cultures to a federal grid, that was fundamental to the consolidation of federal power. As Rockwell reminds us, the Secretaría de Educación Pública (Secretariat of Public Information, SEP) possessed a coercive impulse, as glimpsed in its conditional supply of educational goods and clientelistic syndicalism. It was on this ‘under-explored terrain’, this inframundo of tactical accommodations, that state power was actually built. The ‘would-be hegemonic ideological tapestry’ of revolutionary inclusivity was comparatively thin, given that the state restricted benefits to those who accepted insertion in a vertical power structure (pp. 350–1).
Rockwell begins with a survey that distinguishes Tlaxcala's south-central and south-western sub-regions, home to concentrations of unacculturated Indians around La Malintzi as well as worker-peasants in the textile mills of central Tlaxcala, and the hacienda-dominated plains of the east and north-west. This subregionalisation becomes important as Rockwell traces the differential relationships between local, state and federal actors. In chap. 2 (‘Configuraciones’), Rockwell introduces a second analytical pivot: the surprisingly robust character of state – ‘official’ as opposed to ‘federal’ – education in Tlaxcala. Rockwell first stresses the role of Porfirian governor Próspero Cahuantzi in running a meaningful, if personalist, state system. After the revolution a process of state-level professionalisation began, eroding autonomous municipal participation. At the same time, control over education was disputed by the SEP, which targeted Tlaxcala as the site of its first federalising convenio, agreed in April 1922. Henceforth came a tug-of-war between state-based and federal centralisers in which the balance slowly tipped in Mexico City's favour: SEP attempts unilaterally to alter the convenio saw the agreement collapse in 1923 and the Tlaxcalans develop their own educational directorate under Ingeniero Aguillón de los Ríos. SEP encroachments resumed in 1925 with the creation of an in-state federal directorate. Thus began the process by which the SEP competed for Tlaxcala's escuelas oficiales, rebranding them escuelas rurales but ignoring the unlettered campesinos and Indians that it was meant to enlighten. By the 1930s, federalisation was advanced: if governor Isidro Candia presided over a state system, it was run by a syndicalised magisterio and no longer had an autonomous project.
Rockwell traces the federalising impulse along diverse axes in central chapters exploring, respectively, school reform, teachers' formation, community responses, school geography and changing meanings of the school. In chap. 3 (‘Reformas’), for instance, she analyses the educational system's legal props, reminding us that the SEP intervened in federal entities before 1934 at the margins of the law, because Vasconcelos' 1921 education law was accompanied by no constitutional reform. This flaw, Rockwell argues, obliged the SEP to engage in tentative negotiations on the ground. Rockwell reports such efforts – sponsorship of pedagogic conferences, for instance – in detail, and convincingly argues that the SEP's slow advances towards an informal consensus among federal and state teachers were significant in the absence of a formal accord between Tlaxcala and Mexico City. Rockwell also paints a sympathetic portrait of SEP officials such as Rafael Ramírez, a talented bureaucrat who liaised with federal and state maestros in order to promote convergence between both systems. Even so, the SEP's ‘capture’ of escuelas oficiales was the salient trend, Rockwell shows: of the 166 federal schools in Tlaxcala open by 1940, only 28 were ‘new’, the remainder being ex-official or hacienda schools. As a result, SEP schools remained scattered, like Porfirian ones, in areas of economic dynamism, despite the federation's incorporationist mantras.
The ‘rural’ school was thus more a symbol of creeping federalisation than of SEP evangelisation in the unschooled countryside. Chap. 5 (‘Comunidades’) explores campesinos' roles in this struggle over rural schools' political resignification. In places, Indians ensured corporate school government by appropriating the community-based juntas de educación sponsored by the state government; others created cooperatives to defray the costs of school building, only to assert proprietorial rights and minimise state control. Thus some indigenous campesinos backed local reforms which allowed them to syncretise traditional politico-religious structures and escuelas oficiales. Elsewhere, campesinos formed SEP-sponsored comités de educación, federal outposts independent of traditional office holders. Federalisation thus created a school/community division that was, according to context, tense or politically useful. A federal school meant reduced local control over education, resulting in appeals to return to the official system. There were also pay-offs, however: a federal maestro countered the influence of overbearing caciques, or facilitated village petitions for elevation to municipal status, while federal teachers had connections in the agrarian bureaucracy. In sum, therefore, communities had to weigh up the advantages of an alliance with the federation, implying costs and benefits. As Rockwell shows well, the SEP advanced or retreated on the back of such parish pump decisions, for instance, in eastern Tlaxcala, where agrarianism spread the word.
Hacer escuela, hacer estado has many strengths, not least the solid empirical base which grounds its argument. Rockwell also has extraordinary knowledge of the workings of Mexico's educational bureaucracies, and presents unusually insightful portraits of the SEP's inspectorates, teaching personnel and diverse pedagogic cultures. Above all, no other study reveals so tellingly the importance of state-level schooling, or nuances so well its subordination to SEP designs. Rockwell's thesis that the SEP stood for a negotiated systemic conquest, one which reproduced the inequalities that were built into the system during Cahuantzi's prosperato, must qualify the myth of the SEP's ‘reconquest’ of the countryside and the notion of a hegemonic cultural compact around 1940. This would be a purely revisionist conclusion, perhaps, were it not for Rockwell's insistence on the opportunities for grassroots decision making, in terms of both ethnic defence and the selective embrace of revolutionary modernities. In this regard, the author deserves congratulations for her simply Herculean searches in Tlaxcala's state archive and the SEP: these travails allow her to flesh out the diverse practices and calculi of popular negotiation, which in some studies can have a theoretical, even vaguely metaphorical, feel, or be reduced to the bloody rejection of SEP secularism. Rockwell shows how microscopic political negotiations, tending towards the association of local and state/federal interests, were central to the success/failure of the SEP's enterprise. There are, of course, some caveats to what is overall a valuable, convincing study. The biggest flaw is that the book ventures no regional comparisons, something for which the analysis cries out; readers are also entitled to ask about typicality, given the author's determination to dissent from state-centred approaches and explore federalisation from the regions. Yet how de-centred is Tlaxcala, the republic's smallest state and one that is relatively close to Mexico City? Some broader discussion here would have been very welcome.
