‘Coterminous with the death of the author, the death of pleasure ensured that no one could or would be enjoying Propertius, at least not in the near future. He, along with his Cynthia, had become a cipher in the landscape of Signs’ (61).
Ralph Johnson wants everyone to read Propertius — and Tibullus and Ovid — with fresh eyes, open hearts, and a broader understanding of the epoch from which they emerged. One purpose of this book is to recover love elegy from the deconstructive gaze of what might be termed senes severiores — or contemporary literary theorists — and restore it to a generation that, if given a chance, might appreciate the literary imaginings of a frustrated but undeterred ‘Mad Lover’, a phrase J. uses to refer to the persona of the lover-poet in the poems of Propertius.
J. claims this is not a book for professors of Classical Studies, but for those with an appreciation for romantic poetry and an interest in its Western roots. But he is being a little bit disingenuous, for in this book there are protractions of literary history, tracings of literary influence, reflections on the late Republican / early Imperial Roman zeitgeist, as well as interpretations of individual poems that will beguile, amuse, and dare I say inform the specialist as well as the novice. But strictly speaking, yes, J. provides more summary than analysis, and he takes liberties with his material; even so, that is no reason to ignore this intriguing study. There is a tongue-in-cheek aspect to this literary exploration, but that does not negate its value. Indeed, there are chapters or sub-chapters of this book with which graduate students probably should engage. Some of his arguments are more plausible than others; J.'s overall thesis — that Propertius merits recovery and re-discovery — is valid and well argued.
In his preface and first chapter, J. restates the fairly well established argument that a growing imperial power such as Rome, with its catastrophic internal power struggles, could not avoid changes in cultural infrastructure that would grant more leisure to the élite, more disenfranchisement among the youth, and more exposure to, by Roman standards, non-traditional modes of thought and expression. J. develops with particular care the notion of a shift toward erotic identification as an alternative to the republican-worthy identity shaped by duty and political participation. He brings forward the figures of Sulla, Antony, and Fulvia as people who embodied this shift, whose love lives were inseparable from their public personae.
Thus emerges Propertius — an inheritor of these erotic modes of expression from predecessors like Catulus, Calvus, Catullus, Gallus and Vergil. Yes, Vergil: in ch. 2, J. demonstrates how Dido is a very different creation from the women in Homeric epic, and this is credited to the new erotic identity. But first he digresses for a bit on Stendhal's work On Love (De l’Amour) published in 1822. One can't help but guess that it is this work that inspired the entire project J. has undertaken, showing his roots in Comparative Literature. There would be nothing wrong with that, except that Stendhal's approach to love is a clear product of Romanticism. The last century of post-modernism has (for better or worse) at least attempted to infuse some reality into and recognize the frailties and inequities of a system that quantifies love on a scale of male passions. Any discussion that renders preferential treatment to love's transformative properties (or crystallization, a process that occurs in Stendhal's concept of amour de passion) tends to ignore the price people, typically women, pay for such love. And to be fair, J. faults Stendhal for ignoring the blessings of committed monogamy — relationships in which women tend to have more power. He also faults Stendhal for making a rather contorted link between European Romanticism and the poems of Moorish Spain to the detriment of the Roman tradition. I am sympathetic with J.'s attempt to restore a romantic sensibility to the poems of Propertius, but there can be considerable regression when Roman-Romantic male notions of love become the focus.
Ch. 3 deals with Cynthia as an icon of the erotic imagination. Particularly good is J.'s explanation for Cynthia's re-emergence into the ‘narrative’ of Book 4. This is worth a read. Ch. 4 features Propertius’ many recusationes in Books 2 and 3 and the process that J. (borrowing a term from La Penna's Properzio e l’Integrazione difficile) calls ‘disgregation’ — namely, ‘the pattern of the poet's ubiquitous self-defense’, and ‘his growing sense of the meaning of his separation from the flock’ (109). His analyses of the relevant poems of Book 3 are useful.
Ch. 5 discusses Ovid as the inheritor of Propertius and the embodiment of the ‘disgregated’ artist. In the process, J. delivers a helpful review of the arguments regarding Ovid's discourse as Augustan or anti-Augustan. J. offers a likely, entertaining, and eminently readable account of the clash between Ovid and Augustus that led to Ovid's eventual relegation to the Black Sea coast (129–36). I suspect students will enjoy reading this before they read Ovid's works. It will serve as a platform for discussion, and cause students to seek out those aspects that challenge or agree with the possibilities that J. offers. Ch. 6 is a brief summary of the arguments and a final tip of the hat to Roman elegy's Mad Lover and his impact on the ages.
Regarding his style, J. relies a bit too often on the parenthetic remark, the triad or tricolon crescendo, the reiteration, and even the cliché. See for example this sentence (26): ‘For various reasons, because some of the brightest and the best young men (and women) had too much money and too much spare time, because their fathers were busy killing each other, because of who and where they were, these Romans (accidentally) caught a glimpse of Love of an un-Roman kind, of a love that transfigures, that takes away the identity you were born with … .’ There are also a couple of errors that merit attention (p. 11, second line from bottom; p. 66: 4.1.38 is translated without accounting for non).
