The provenance of Middle East travel literature goes back to at least the 18th century, but critical studies of it began only relatively recently. On British explorers of Arabia, Three Victorian Travelers (London: Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1963), Thomas Assad's study of Burton, Blunt, and Doughty, and Kathleen Tidrick's Heart-Beguiling Araby (London: I. B. Tauris, 1989), were landmarks of their time. The influence of Said's Orientalism on criticism of the genre in general perhaps only fully emerged with Ali Behdad's Belated Travelers: Orientalism in the Age of Colonial Dissolution (Durham, N.C.: Duke University Press, 1994). Andrew Long's book now joins the list, confirming key words—“Arabia,” “British,” “Orientalism”—while spotlighting a similar period (1880–1930) to Behdad. Here are the standard authors again: Burton and Doughty, who are foundational for Long's argument as the “two tangents of British Orientalism”; and T. E. Lawrence, whose career Tidrick probed as chivalric fantasy and Said as colonial Orientalism. Wilfrid Blunt, integral to Behdad's gendered elaboration of Said, receives fair mention but is not the subject of a chapter as are two less frequently discussed figures: the late-Victorian traveler to North Africa, Robert Cunninghame Graham, and the youthful visitor to Syria and later Edwardian novelist, Marmaduke Pickthall.
The challenge of saying something new, not so much about the latter two, but about the trio of canonical Arabian desert savants—Burton, Doughty, and Lawrence—is attempted in the two tangents of British Orientalism ascribed to the first two, respectively “the dandy and the prophet,” Lawrence's persona turning out to be a sort of amalgam of these. Burton's adoption of the strategy of disguise when traveling feeds into his dandy archetype, but it is his indulgence in sexual fantasy as seen in his notes to his translations of The Arabian Nights and in other Orientalist erotica, that sets up a thread that runs from Victorian gentleman's pornography, through Lawrence's sadomasochism (in real life and in The Seven Pillars of Wisdom), to the early 20th-century popular lustful narratives of the desert epitomized by Edith Hull's The Sheik. Doughty, on the other hand, who by traveling as himself, Tidrick argued (p. 147), was intentionally courting death “at the hands of fanatical Muslims” as “a just punishment for having betrayed the simple faith of his childhood,” is figured by Long as “an ascetic, lone, near martyred traveler.” Nothing new here then, except that in this Doughty is said to “closely parallel . . . the mission of Carlyle's prophet [Muhammad]” (p. 50).
Long's point of departure is the 1880s, when, coinciding with the prominent journalism on the Gordon/Khartoum episode and Kitchener's massacre of the Mahdi's army in 1898, “a new Orientalism emerged as mass culture in print” (p. 97). He proceeds to argue for the convergence of the popular Orientalist novel and the elitist genre of Arabian travel writing, when a new audience emerged in the early 20th century. At this point, the two tangents of dandy and prophet also converged.
What this came to mean for the rest of the century Long modulates and follows through a variety of twists and forms. The argument is diffuse, but sustained, engaging, and persuasive. On reflection, the merging of canonical and popular Orientalism seems obvious—the work of the historian of popular British imperial culture, John MacKenzie, already pointed in this direction in the 1980s. But Long's book is not merely a two-trick act—he has lots to say about other spin-offs into the bargain. For example, he brings Tayeb Salih's postcolonial novella Season of Migration to the North (Boulder, Colo.: Lynne Reinner, 1997) into his discussion of The Sheik, and compares Cunninghame Grahame to his contemporary Joseph Conrad. This is further Saidian territory—the Said of Culture and Imperialism (New York: Vintage, 1994). Long is not afraid to take the master down a peg or two for his, in some ways, conventional indulgence of a modernist writer whose use of derogatory epithets about Africa and Africans, Long concurs with Chinua Achebe, qualifies him as a “thorough-going racist.”
The theoretical approach adopted means the reader should not expect empirical assessment of data—whether Lawrence actually was raped by the Turkish governor, as his account of an incident at Deraa in Seven Pillars claims, is immaterial. This is an investigation of cultural trajectory, not an exercise primarily in historical or socio-anthropological analysis. Inventive literary parallels are drawn between Pickthall's representation of the Oriental mob in his 1902 novel Said the Fisherman and Dickens’ orientalizing of the City of London in Oliver Twist. Pickthall, who is attracting a growing interest as a native British convert to Islam, is astutely measured alongside those other early 20th-century British intellectuals whose fear of the masses John Carey perceptively exposed. Cunninghame Graham, however, is perhaps the least interesting figure, and his comparative neglect understandable.
It would therefore be wrong to leave the impression that Long is opportunistic in his mixing of the elements discussed above. It is true his observations are underpinned by references to vogue postmodern or postcolonial thinkers such as Julia Kristeva, Jacques Lacan, and Gayatri Spivak; feminist cultural critics like Susan Blake and Billie Melman also gain entry alongside the maverick and these days seemingly ubiquitous Slavoj Žižek. Even veteran bogus Middle East “expert,” Said's bête noire Thomas Friedman, makes an appearance. Overall, Long underscores why it is necessary “to understand how this one (social) fantasy among others, that of the Orient, has developed into such a central feature of Western society and Western political consciousness” (p. 213).
There are a few shortcomings—what “the Great Strike of 1921” (p. 193) refers to is unclear—perhaps the British General Strike of 1926. Faysal, who the British installed as king in Iraq, was a complex personality and more than “a weak puppet who would fall within years” (p. 190), as Ali Allawi's new biographical study attests. The continuing decline in print production values is evidenced in the frequent failure to indent new paragraphs. Nonetheless, the writing is fluid and unpretentious, and the book at times reads like a detective novel. In sum, Long has produced a work that looks at Orientalism in a new way by foregrounding the popular over the erudite and the elitist; such a focused reading of the impact of Orientalism on mass culture in general and Arabian travel literature in particular has for some time been overdue.
