The historiography of the Palestinian–Israeli conflict has been parsed and parceled in numerous ways, yet scholars continue to find new avenues of exploration in an effort to fully explain the complexity of the region. Among the more promising developments is the continued dismantling of powerful binaries that exist in the standard narrative, particularly that of Jews and Arabs. Abigail Jacobson and Moshe Naor's Oriental Neighbors: Middle Eastern Jews and Arabs in Mandatory Palestine tackles this trope of the field by focusing attention on Jews of Middle Eastern descent (whom they refer to as Oriental Jews) and their relationship to both non-Jewish Arabs and non-Arab Jews. “Sephardim” was too broad, as it includes Jewish communities from Spain and Italy. The leadership specified that Yehudei Hamizrah or Oriental Jews were a subset of that broader label, and it became the official term used by the Sephardi communities during the Mandate.
Oriental Neighbors explores two important communal interactions. Most prominent is the relationship between “Sephardi and Oriental Jews” on the one hand, and the Ashkenzi-led Zionist leadership on the other. The Zionist leadership was wary of Oriental Jews and their Arab culture, and often discriminated against Jews from Palestine as well as from Arab countries such as Iraq, Yemen, and Egypt who immigrated to Palestine. Much of the book highlights Oriental Jews’ efforts to achieve adequate representation in the mainstream Jewish movement by looking at political and social organizations designed to increase Oriental Jewish visibility. In this way, the authors refuse to accept “Zionist” as one thing, instead proving over and over again that Oriental Jews considered themselves “Eastern” in some sense, but also Zionist. In the early years of the Mandate, at least, holding both identities was a legitimate, if contested, option for some.
Though the title and introduction suggest the Oriental Jew–Palestinian Arab relationship as the focus, it really plays a secondary role to the inter-Jewish dynamic. The first three chapters illuminate a variety of Oriental Jewish actors and their relationships to the Zionist leadership. While such a detailed description of the Oriental Jewish community is essential as a way to bring often ignored figures back into the narrative, such chapters can be tedious for those whose interests lie in Jewish–Arab relations. It is not until Chapters 4 and 5 that Jacobson and Naor add the Arab dimension. And it is here that the narrative becomes more lively and relevant to a broader audience.
The authors’ exploration of “mixed-neighborhoods” as “sites of interaction” is particularly compelling. Newly arrived Oriental Jews usually clustered together on the outskirts of the European-Jewish towns and cities, often bumping up against Arab neighborhoods. Such proximity increased contact between the two groups especially in markets, movie theaters, brothels, and playgrounds. Highlighting such day-to-day interactions between theoretically hostile populations is creative historiography that provides a powerful alternative to a narrative of separate Arab and Jewish communities. Such social history also provides a unique complement to a few books published in recent years that examine elite interactions between Arabs and Jews during this period (such as Michelle U. Campos, Ottoman Brothers: Muslims, Christians, and Jews in Early 20th Century Palestine [Stanford, Calif.: Standford University Press, 2010] and Jonathan Gribetz, Defining Neighbors: Religion, Race, and the Early Zionist-Arab Encounter [Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press]). Instead of an intellectual or ideological connection viewed through the writings of important figures (mostly men), Jacobson and Naor's clever analysis suggests that Oriental Jews, in particular, lived side by side with their Palestinian Arab counterparts as real neighbors.
A recurring theme throughout the book is the Oriental Jewish understanding of their own unique position in Mandate Palestine. Leaders of the community argued that they were perfectly suited to assist the Zionist movement in developing positive relations with the Palestinian Arab population because the two communities spoke the same language, shared similar customs and habits, and often occupied the same socioeconomic category. While the authors provide ample evidence of this belief, it sometimes overshadows what must have been a broader range of feelings among the community. Still, in the early years of the Mandate the Oriental Jewish leadership sought a greater role in mediating between the two nascent national communities and often complained that the European-dominated movement ignored their suggestions and concerns. Instead, the marginalization of voices calling for mediation and compromise meant increased Arab–Jewish conflict and “a road not taken” (Chapter 1). It is always dangerous for historians to lament “what might have been,” and Jacobson and Naor do not fall into that trap. Rather, they catalog the many Oriental Jews who made the argument and leave the “what if” questions unanswered.
Despite this early goal of conflict mediation, as violence grew during the 1920s and 1930s a younger generation of Oriental Jews, who had come of age in Mandate Palestine rather than their ancestral homeland elsewhere in the Middle East, were less likely to seek moderating roles. Instead, partly due to Zionist efforts to conscript Oriental Jewish youth into the mainstream movement, and partly because they were perfectly situated to do so, their role shifted dramatically: instead of acting as mediators, many Oriental Jewish youth joined the Zionist secret service. Their fluent Arabic and fluency with Arab culture and customs enabled them to penetrate Arab political circles and carry out bombing attacks in Arab markets without undue attention. This shift from rapprochement to espionage highlights the unique role played by Oriental Jews who were both Arab and Jewish in a world often divided between those two labels.
Oriental Neighbors is a detailed assessment of an often-overlooked segment of the Jewish population of Mandate Palestine. Its success lies in its ability to situate the Oriental Jewish community both in relation to the dominant Zionist group, but also vis-à-vis Palestinian Arabs. Never does the book rely on simplifications or weak categorizations. Instead, Jacobson and Naor tease out each connection with a combination of extensive research and impressive insight. They offer an important contribution to the field by engaging a number of historiographical tools and approaches, including ethnic, national, socioeconomic, generational, and gender analysis, as well as micro- and broad-scale history.
