Walls of Algiers was published in association with an exhibition by the same title held at the Getty Research Institute (GRI) between 10 May and 18 October 2009 and curated by Zeynep Çelik and Frances Terpak. Similar to the exhibition, the volume's seven essays—authored by historians of society, urbanism, culture, film, and art—guide the reader through visual journeys into the history of the city of Algiers, relying along the way on a compelling selection of 19th- and 20th-century illustrations, photographs, postcards, and maps.
The volume, however, far exceeds the initial parameters of the exhibition. Its combination of scholarly essays and visual sources enhance in meaningful ways our understanding of the successive historical inscriptions upon the urban, social, and ethnic fabric of Algiers. The authors’ investigations into the multifaceted processes by which colonialist (and nationalist) constructs become engraved upon urban spaces are meant to stimulate larger interrogations concerning “the conceptual and theoretical approaches that can help translate the social and spatial biography of the city” (p. 2). In this regard, the volume's broad disciplinary scope and effective use of textual and visual material inspire wide-ranging questions for students of colonial and urban history. Its emphasis on the different forms of “language” (textual or visual, technical or artistic) involved in the representation of urban spaces and the social interactions therein problematizes premises that are central to historical analyses of the colonial city as urban palimpsest. In Walls of Algiers, the city is primarily lived and experienced by its diverse residents; it endows them with local identities and a “sense of place” that will influence fundamentally the complex nature of the struggles and contentions between displaced natives and arrogating Europeans from conquest to independence (as well as the reverse process immediately after 1962).
In their effort to underscore the “triangulations” between the different modes of inquiry in play, the editors have divided the volume into three thematic sections: peoples, images, and places. The essays in the first section reflect upon the interactions between the diverse ethnic and religious communities of Algiers as a means to probe the analytical validity of colonial categories such as “colonizer” and “colonized.” Julia Clancy-Smith does so by examining the underrepresentation of specific “not-quite-European” groups or individuals in the visual culture and travel literature of the colony. In reintegrating these absent groups into the history of Algiers, she convincingly deconstructs prevailing colonial tropes—textual and visual—and draws needed attention to the formative effect of the early decades of colonial rule in Algeria. Likewise, Omar Carlier revises the spatial contexts in which urban Muslim associations emerged at the dawn of the 20th century. In the politically restricted atmosphere of colonial Algiers, Muslim athletic or cultural groups mobilized their followers to break out of the enclosed space of the Arab quarters, or medina, and to engage creatively with the dominant order. He thus liberates the casbah from its stock colonialist portrayals as an outmoded and squalid—yet exoticized—space and instead depicts it as a catalyst for change and innovation. The casbah, according to Carlier, was modern, activist, and connected to wider trends in Algeria. It nurtured within it sociabilities and “forms of associative life” that were key to the gestation of Muslim civil society and to the evolution of nationalist currents in the interwar period.
The second section examines how colonial preoccupations with exclusion and control are translated into textual, visual, and architectural evidence. Frances Terpak draws from the GRI's extensive archive of 19th-century photographs from Algeria to assess the effect of technological innovations in the field of visual imagery, including panoramas and photography, on the French public's consciousness. She demonstrates that while the immediacy of photography promoted noticeable shifts in metropolitan perceptions of Algeria, the new medium also “acted as a double agent” (p. 121), at once enabling change and upholding the colonialist canon. Zeynep Çelik then underscores how colonial discourses and relations of power inscribed themselves upon the Muslim house and how colonial architectural practices echoed Orientalist notions of the status of women and the family in Islam. Finally, Eric Breitbart looks for signs of these relations of power in three films that capture the city of Algiers as subject or backdrop: Pépé le Moko (1937), its Hollywood remake as Algiers (1938), and Gillo Pontecorvo's seminal The Battle of Algiers (1965). Collectively, the three authors offer stimulating and corresponding perspectives on the staying power of colonial imagery and discourse. Terpak and Çelik, however, tend to underplay their otherwise appealing references to the practical implications of the tensions produced by the colonial urge to “assimilate” Algiers, while preserving strict delineations between its European and native realms. The extent to which local sociocultural and architectural traits were preserved by political necessity and by the imperative to authenticate the French origins of the modernizing mission thus remains unclear.
The final section of Walls of Algiers complements the previous one in that it describes how spatial designs and practices are intimately implicated with efforts to modify sociopolitical relations in a particular “place.” Essays by Isabelle Grangaud and Çelik approach systematically, but from dissimilar perspectives, the material impact of high modernism on local urban spaces and social practices. Both bring salient revisions to colonialist and nationalist paradigms and complicate—in the most positive sense of the term—any neat delineation between the precolonial, colonial, and postcolonial eras. They also produce distinctive ground-level analyses of the social and spatial dislocations wrought by the modern state's large-scale regulation of people and land. For Grangaud, the ḥawma, or local neighborhood, is a lens through which to study informal notions of identity as well as the rights and privileges that emanate from social relationships rather than institutional processes or territorial boundaries. Çelik, on the other hand, delves into the long microhistory of an “urban fragment” in the center of Algiers to highlight continuities in the ideologies behind Ottoman, French, and postcolonial architectural designs and urban practices. Her account of the permanent reordering of the center of Algiers’ landscape mirrors Grangaud's description of the dissolution of the networks of the ḥawma under the weight of rationalizing urban grids in the course of the 19th and 20th centuries. In the two accounts, the irrevocable erasure of premodern forms of social and spatial organization epitomizes the indelible legacy of colonialism and exposes the deep imbrications between colonialist and nationalist appropriations of the city—with clear implications for our appreciation of the commonalities between the two programs and narratives.
