The performance of theology involves not only theology read and written, but theology lived and done. Soskice's book is precisely an enterprise in such theological performance. She not only thinks from rather than simply towards her interlocutors, but she does so in a way which includes practical and ecclesial life and in a manner that is able to see deeply into what is at issue in her various discussions. Indeed, few authors can move so gracefully from Iris Murdoch, Descartes and Gregory of Nyssa to the practicalities of motherhood and then on to Goethe, Aristotle and Weil. This practical insight in no way undermines the profundity of her argument, but serves rather to underscore it. Soskice is able seamlessly to combine art, philosophy, systematic theology, history, science and literature in order to perform theology creatively and at times even poetically. She takes the tradition seriously, but never so carelessly as to accept it uncritically, preferring instead to press it and listen carefully to it for deep and resonating answers to her questions.
The book is principally a reworking of several of Soskice's earlier essays (with chapters 7 and 9 as newly written pieces). The different essays are introduced helpfully in their relation to the main uniting strand of the book – the kindness of God. By ‘kindness’, however, Soskice is not simply pointing to a general meaning of the adjective ‘kind’. Instead, she points to the fact that in Middle English the words ‘kind’ and ‘kin’ were the same: Jesus’ being ‘our kinde Lord’ bespeaks his being our kin (p. 5). It is kinship imagery that Soskice takes up as she leads the reader through the complex shifting architectonics of different theological themes. These themes are variously focused throughout the nine chapters, covering central loci of Christian theology: theology proper, creation, imago dei and anthropology, christology and incarnation, salvation, the Christian life and eschatology. However, throughout all of her discussions there is a sensitivity to the possible difficulties attached to using kinship imagery, associated principally with matters to do with gender and hierarchy. Thus, Soskice explores kinship in relation to the various doctrinal points of the Christian faith in a way which seeks to dispel such fears from within, finding fruitful resources within the texts of scripture and the classical texts of theology.
A collection of largely previously published essays always runs the risk of reading as a series of disparate articles patched unimaginatively together. Given the range of issues that Soskice addresses in her chapters, and the threading together throughout all of them of her continued and overarching interests in language, theological anthropology, naming God, feminist theory, Christianity's relationship to Judaism and eschatology, one might think that this book faces this danger more than most. However, Soskice overcomes this potential problem admirably. The reworking of the chapters has ensured that kinship is retained as the focus throughout. I particularly found one of the new essays (chapter 7, ‘The Kindness of God’) helpful: in this chapter, which is almost the centrepiece of the book, all of Soskice's themes are drawn together, most fully in her consideration of Julian of Norwich. This is a consideration which leads on to the more focused ethical material in chapter 8 (‘Friendship: Love thy Neighbour’), in which she explores the ‘anthropology of the-at-least-two’ and to the eschatological climax in chapter 9.
This book is a delight to read. The breadth of engagement is astonishing: Soskice is able to dialogue equally well, and with as much originality, with Ricoeur and Schleiermacher as she does with Paul and Augustine; and she is able to combine biblical criticism, philosophy and theology with ease. Moreover, her constructive insights are creative, compelling and new. This is a wonderfully helpful book for anyone who seeks to learn more about theological anthropology and God's relationship to humanity. Karl Barth once said that there was no place in our discipline for ‘[s]ulky faces, morose thoughts and boring ways of speaking’; Soskice's book would not disappoint him. The joy of this book lies not only in its moments of humour and irony and the grounded ecclesial earthiness it presents, but also in its ability to allow the reader genuinely to glimpse something of the ‘kindness of God’. Soskice writes of the end of Augustine's De Trinitate that, having read the book, it is up to the reader to perform it (p. 156). Having read her book, I am inclined to say much the same: being gathered into this performance of theology, it is up to the reader now to perform the book.
