This collection of four essays acquaints the reader with some of the ways in which John Dewey’s ideas were taken up and transformed as they travelled beyond the borders of the United States of America. The essays in this volume focus in particular on Dewey’s ideas about democracy and education, and how these ideas were adapted to suit a variety of different political, cultural, and religious climates. (3) These essays reveal that “Dewey’s readers were not concerned with maintaining consistency with Dewey’s broader philosophy … .” (4), because their aims were social and political rather than intellectual or scholarly.
The first essay, written by Daniel Tröhler, offers “an analysis of Dewey’s background and his affinity with Protestant ideas” (3), an analysis that sets the stage for each of the three case studies that follows. In this first essay, Tröhler presents a sketch of life in Chicago between 1840 and 1930. During these nine decades, Tröhler explains, Chicago was transformed from a small, mainly agrarian town of about 4,500 residents into a large, industrial city of over 3.3 million residents, most of whom were immigrants. (20) Chicago’s rapid growth created many social, political, and economic problems within the city, problems to which “pragmatism [was] an intellectual response, within the context of specific challenges posed by life conditions, that [tried] to bring these conditions into accord with desires and purposes.” (18) Because it was a response to the specific situation faced by the inhabitants of Chicago at the time in question, Tröhler argues, this “Chicago pragmatism” (36, n.9) could not have arisen at that same time in any other city. (19)
The second essay, written by James Scott Johnston, provides insight into Dewey’s 22-month stay in China, which began just days before the May 4th movement started in Beijing in 1919. (52) Focusing in particular on “Dewey’s discussion of the historical situation in China during the May 4th movement,” (45) Johnston argues that “[t]here are lessons for today in Dewey’s understanding of the May 4th movement in China.” (64) Among these is a lesson about democracy, namely, that democracy cannot come to a people from the outside. (64) In other words, democracy must emerge from within a population as an expression of a people’s own needs and desires. Although many of those who participated in the May 4th movement seemed to understand this Deweyan lesson insofar as they employed democratic means to spread the spirit of democracy throughout the Chinese public, there nevertheless remained a number of important Chinese intellectuals who failed to understand that democracy could not be imported from the West. (64-65) While such intellectuals embraced the idea of democracy, they tended “to make Dewey a spokesperson for a monolithic, even authoritarian, concept of democratic living.” (65)
The third essay, written by Gonzalo Jover, explicates the way the Spanish Free Teaching Institute took up Dewey’s educational thought during the first three decades of the 20th century. In particular, in this essay Jover examines how two of the Institute’s members, namely, Domingo Barnés and Lorenzo Luzuriaga, contributed to the spread of Dewey’s ideas in Spain. (86) The older of the two, Barnés, took his cue from the Swiss psychologist Edouard Claparède’s reading of Dewey, a reading that separated Dewey’s psychology and pedagogy from his pragmatism, and adopted a “transcendentalist reading of Dewey in which growth becomes self-fulfillment.” (92) The younger of the two, Luzuriaga, who may have been influenced by the German pedagogue George Kerschensteiner, initially followed Barnés in his reading of Dewey but eventually adopted a reading of Dewey that was more political than transcendental. (95, 97) Neither Barnés nor Luzuriaga was particularly interested in “Dewey the philosopher”; instead, both were interested in “the Dewey who was more immediately useful for modernizing education, the Dewey of functional psychology and learning by doing.” (110)
The fourth and final essay, written by Rosa Bruno-Jofré, examines some of the work of an interdenominational Committee on Cooperation in Latin America that was created at a conference in New York City in 1913. (132) In particular, in this essay Bruno-Jofré “[analyzes] the discourses narrated in the two major congresses organized by the Committee: the Panama Congress of 1916 and the Montevideo Congress of 1925.” (135) These discourses, which took place among missionaries, social gospellers, and educators, “embodied a synthetic configuration of democracy and education understood in relation to spiritual redemption, both individual and social, that was a core component of the proposed reconstruction of the Latin American polity.” (135) Looking at these discourses, one sees how “Dewey’s notion of democracy as a form of life became spiritualized to the point that democracy became synonymous with Protestant liberal Christianity.” (162)
The essays in this book may be of some historical interest to Dewey scholars, as well as to anyone who would like to learn about some specific developments within the American, Chinese, Spanish, and Latin American cultures of the late 19th century and the early 20th century. There is also material in these essays that might speak to those with historical interest in democratic, educational, or religious ideas. However, potential readers should be aware that it may not be easy to engage with this book. This book contains more typographical and grammatical errors, as well as problems of clarity and flow, than one would hope for in and expect from a scholarly publication, which undermines the overall readability of the book. Moreover, if one reads the introduction to the book before moving onto the individual essays, one may lose interest in reading the book, particularly if one is a Dewey scholar. The authors claim, for example, that their “studies demonstrate that the understanding of democratic means becomes embedded in the cultural dynamics of relations in specific situations.” (8) Such a claim is banal in the world of Dewey scholarship, so one might wonder what the point would be of reading this book. The authors also claim, for example, to have introduced themes that “help us to see where license is established to deviate from Dewey’s thoughts and writings.” (13) In this case, it does not seem that license would be needed to take from Dewey’s thoughts and writings what one finds relevant to and useful for achieving particular, practical ends, so again, one might wonder what the point would be of reading this book. Thus, although it is true that the authors also make some claims about their work that might encourage the reader to continue reading, such as the claim, for example, that they “tried to answer the question of why Dewey’s ideas travelled the way they did” (11), the reader who hopes to learn something from the essays in this book might be well advised to read the introduction last.
