The Mongols and the Black Sea Trade provides an account of the arrival of the Mongols and the development of their states in the lands bordering the Black Sea, focusing on the significance of trade in this process, and on its impact on the further development of trade. The first three sections of the book provide some context and historical background, considering the relationships of Mongols with merchants and trading, the significance of this for understanding the expansion of Mongol power in the thirteenth century, and its contributory role in the break up of Mongol imperial unity in the latter half of the century. The core of the book, and the section of greatest interest, is the long fourth section (pp. 141–279), on “the Golden Horde and the Black Sea”. The work ends rather abruptly, with a very short conclusion (p. 281) restating some of the points made earlier; there is a useful bibliography, and seven maps aimed at showing the shifting trade routes in the Near East.
Trade is at the centre of this book, with its importance frequently re-emphasised. By trade, the long-distance transit trade primarily in luxury goods (and slaves) is understood – there is very little if any mention of local trade in bulk goods. Trade is seen as the basis of the economy of a variety of states, from the Merovingians to the Mamluks. There is no attempt to assess the significance of income from long-distance commerce relative to other sources of princely income, such as taxes on agricultural produce. In fact, these are not considered at all: international trade is assumed to be the only source of income. The picture that emerges of Near Eastern society is thus rather distorted – there is no reference in the book to the iqṭāʿ, for example. Trade is not only the key element for Near Eastern economies, but also, and as a result, it is the key factor driving historical developments. The thesis of the book is that the Mongol conquests in the region stemmed from a desire to control the Silk Road; and that subsequent conflicts in the region, between the Khans of the Golden Horde, the Ilkhans and the Mamluk Sultans, were similarly driven by a contest for control of trade, in silk, spices and slaves.
It is generally understood that the conflict between the two Chinggisid branches based on either side of the Caucasus had varying causes, but that the excellent pasture land of the southern Caucasus was a key point of contention. For Ciocîltan, the dispute was focused rather on control of the ‘priceless city of Tabriz’, priceless because it was the terminus of the Silk Road. The alternative possibility that Tabriz became the commercial centre we know about from the early fourteenth century because it was an Ilkhanid (summer) capital is not considered – trade drives politics, not the other way around. So: the desire of the Golden Horde Khans for the wealth of the Silk Road led them to attack Tabriz; the failure of this led to their alliance with the Mamluks; “which in turn led to a decisive downturn in Persian [i.e., Ilkhanid] relations with the sultan of Egypt” (p. 89). Showing remarkable foresight, “Hülegü . . . realized that the coalition ranged against him aimed, even before the war began, to choke the Ilkhanate's economy by intercepting its trade routes to the Mediterranean and the Black Sea” (p. 96). Conflict with the Mamluks therefore focused on the Armenian kingdom in Cilicia, and especially the port of Ayas, the ‘vestibule’ or ‘antechamber’ of the Silk Road. Ayas certainly became one of the major entrepôts of the eastern Mediterranean in this period, but it may well be that the frequent Mongol invasions of Syria, and competing imperialist ideologies, also played a role in the Mamluk-Ilkhanid war. (Ciocîltan seems to believe that Cilicia was conquered by the Mamluks in 1285, which affects his reading of events, as he sees Western traders being forced to find new routes; in fact, the Armenian king remained firmly in the Ilkhanid orbit, despite agreeing to pay an annual tribute to the Sultan.) The Golden Horde Khans’ solution to the loss of Tabriz “was simply to divert some of the Silk Road traffic into [their] territory. The old Urgench–Sarai–Soldaia road was upgraded to a major trade artery, which could hold its own against the original Asiatic route” (p. 98); quite what this ‘upgrading’ involved is not clear – throughout there is a firm assumption that the ‘Silk Road’ was a single, well-defined thoroughfare. So, “the Black Sea in and of itself was no more than a subset of the triangle of forces Sarai–Cairo–Tabriz, a triangle which was born of commercial rivalries and alliances; thus the Golden Horde's Black Sea policy cannot be understood without reference to this network of forces” (p. 150). This conclusion is unconvincing. The chronology of events is frequently suspect (as when we learn – p. 77 – that a treaty made in 1285 contributed to a regime change in 1284); material is oddly interpreted (the ‘Fertile Crescent’ is so called – p.68 – ‘due to its position on the convergence of all the great transcontinental trade routes’). The monomaniacal focus on trade results in a blinkered perspective; on occasion there is a sense of events being made to fit an imposed pattern, rather than that pattern emerging from study of the events.
The fourth section, when the focus narrows, contains the most detailed analysis. At first this considers the Golden Horde's ‘Black Sea policy’, especially with regard to the Genoese, and the shifting status of the latter's base at Caffa (on the Crimea). While the account of Genoese activity in the eastern Mediterranean provided earlier is rather confused, this presents a much more consistent survey. The second part of this chapter refocuses on the lands of the lower Danube, in the ‘Carpathian-Balkan’ region, initially discussing the semi-independent khanate established here by Noghai, a major figure in the early history of the Horde. After its demise, Ciocîltan considers the rise of Bulgarian and Romanian powers, in opposition to the kingdoms of Hungary and Serbia and the Byzantine Empire, at first under loose Golden Horde suzerainty, and then, with the constriction of the khan's power from the mid-fourteenth century, towards independence. This last section is a very useful political history, but suddenly, the main theme of the work as a whole – the absolute centrality of trade – is completely absent. While the twin themes of the Black Sea and the Golden Horde seem to justify the inclusion of this section, how well it fits with the preceding 200 or so pages is not at all clear: it is, however, perhaps the most interesting part of the book.
As the author makes clear at the outset, the book is based on a doctoral thesis, which was revised for publication in Romanian in 1998, although it seems the original research dates from rather earlier. This is reflected in the bibliography: while the author had access to material during a Humboldt scholarship, he regrets the difficulty he has had in accessing more recent material after his return to Romania. This is unfortunate, as it is clear throughout that recent work in various fields would have contributed greatly – interpretations are often based on unreliable early works; the historical background frequently seems very dated, and specialists in various areas will be unsatisfied. There are very few non-Romanian works listed in the bibliography published in the last 30 years; it is not always clear that those that have been listed have contributed greatly to the actual text. While the work still has considerable value, drawing together much material from a wide range of sources, it would perhaps be best to view it as the product, for the most part, of an earlier time.
