Healthcare provision in the United States of America is unique among Western liberal democracies. Unlike many of its European counterparts, the US healthcare system is primarily based upon private rather than public grounds. Nor is the US system designed to provide universal healthcare in the way that most European countries do. Instead, the US healthcare system relies primarily on private insurance as well as free market principles in order to provide healthcare. This has begun to change over the last decade or so in the US, primarily as a result of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (ACA), more commonly known as “Obamacare”.
Understanding the role that the ACA has played in changes within the US healthcare system can be difficult for a European audience, however. The starting point of the US healthcare system and the principles which underlie it are so different that those coming from a European perspective might struggle to appreciate the relevance of what might, on its face, look like a relatively conservative piece of legislation. They might further struggle to comprehend not only the significance of the ACA but also the vitriol and controversy created by the ACA during its passage and subsequently. European audiences, for example, might not understand the repeated attempts of a Republican Congress to overturn, replace or limit the ACA. Other international readers might likewise have similar problems if their healthcare system is not based on a US model. To the aid of those attempting to understand the ACA and US healthcare in general is a new handbook published by Oxford University Press and edited by I Glenn Cohen, Allison K Hoffman and William M Sage, entitled The Oxford Handbook of US Health Law which was published in 2017. This review will explore the benefits of the Handbook for those wishing to better understand the US healthcare system and the role of the ACA.
First, it should be noted that while the title of the book is the Oxford Handbook of US Health Law, it deals primarily with the current state of health law within the US.Footnote 1 This means that most of the focus of the Handbook is on the ACA rather than health law more generally within the US. That does not mean that other legislation is absent from the Handbook Footnote 2 but it does heavily lean into discussions about the ACA. This, though, is to be expected, as the ACA created the most significant changes to the US healthcare system in a long time.
With that caveat in mind, one of the substantial benefits of the Handbook is its breadth. There are 50 chapters, plus a foreword by Kathleen Sebelius (former US Secretary of the Department of Health and Human Services) and an introduction, which means that US health law is covered from a wide variety of approaches. This includes a range of different approaches from theoretical to more practical in addition to a range of topics from medical malpractice to organisational issues to public health concerns. Of particular interest to a non-American audience is likely to be Part One “An Overview of the Legal Governance of Healthcare”. This part contains five chapters and appears designed to provide a basic overview of important aspects of healthcare within the US. It includes chapters about the role of federalism in healthcare,Footnote 3 the role of health reform generallyFootnote 4 and a chapter on relating health law and health policy.Footnote 5 It also includes a chapter on the relationship between health law in the US and bioethics.Footnote 6 Finally, Part One also includes the only explicit comparative chapter, which looks at the ACA from the perspective of Canada.Footnote 7 These chapters then provide a firm foundation for the rest of the collection, especially for someone who does not have a significant understanding of US health law and policy.
From this general start, the Handbook then proceeds to explore more narrow subjects. Part Two is entitled “Caring and Receiving Care”. This part has four subparts and 16 chapters. The subparts comprise “Access to Healthcare”, “Legal Issues in Information Exchange”, “Ethics and Law of Treatments” and “Recourse for Injury”. As such, this part has a significant variety of topics and explores everything from health information lawFootnote 8 to medical privacy and securityFootnote 9 to conscientious refusals of careFootnote 10 to medical malpractice liability.Footnote 11 The third part focuses on “Organizing and Financing the Healthcare System”. This part contains five subsections – “Health Professionals and Healthcare Facilities”, “Competition and Innovation”, “Health Insurance and Finance”, “Healthcare Costs” and “Public Health Law” – and 24 chapters, making it the largest section in the Handbook. This is also the part that will probably provide the most new information to non-US readers, since the overarching focus is on the financial model of the US healthcare system, which is likely to be the most unusual part for those readers. Chapters in this section focus on aspects like the interaction between non-profit healthcare organisations and the law,Footnote 12 antitrust enforcement and healthcare competition,Footnote 13 employment-based healthcare insurance,Footnote 14 the interactions between public and private healthcare insurance,Footnote 15 healthcare rationing,Footnote 16 and approaches to public health.Footnote 17 It also includes chapters on biomedical researchFootnote 18 and, in particular, the legal regulation of drugs, biologics and medical devices in the US.Footnote 19 Part 4 on “The Health Law Frontier” concludes the Handbook. This part, like the first one, does not include any subparts and only contains five chapters. However, it focuses on issues which are likely to be crucial future issues, such as aging populationsFootnote 20 and immigrants and healthcare.Footnote 21 This allows the Handbook to look forward to future issues of importance.
There are thus a number of exceptional characteristics about the Handbook. It has very thoughtful chapters from recognised experts in the field on a range of important legal topics about the US healthcare system. The organisation of the Handbook is very good and it should provide a range of opportunities for those interested in US health law to learn more about its various issues. However, there are also things which might limit the usefulness of the Handbook for readers who do not already understand the US system. First, there is a significant lack of comparative material within the Handbook. There is a chapter comparing the US system and the Canadian system but that may not provide much help to European readers, who may be as unfamiliar with the Canadian system as they are with the US one. There are also occasional references to other jurisdictions but there is no systematic comparison with, for example, the UK or other European healthcare systems such that it would be easy for a reader to understand the similarities and differences. Nor are there any further international comparisons other than the Canadian chapter. To a large extent, this is to be expected. The Handbook does not bill itself as a comparative work, so it makes sense that comparative analysis does not feature heavily in its contents. Moreover, with all that the writers had to do in terms of analysis, adding significant comparative elements would have made the book impractically large.
A more complicated problem is that the Handbook is technically a compendium of the current law as it existed in 2016.Footnote 22 So, while it covers the ACA as it operated under President Obama, it does not include any discussion or analysis of how the ACA might be or has been implemented differently under President Trump. This is a significant concern, as President Trump has, through Executive Orders, made a number of changes which adversely impact the way the ACA functions. These executive orders, in conjunction with the role played by a Republican majority in the House of Representatives and the Senate, have meant that the ACA now operates in a substantially different manner. Readers of this Handbook, then, are not likely to be able to rely on the analysis as being completely accurate. It could have been accurate in terms of 2016, but things have shifted since then, and the analysis no longer is. More critically, unless the reader is already an expert, they are unlikely to know exactly which aspects have changed and which have not. As a consequence, the Handbook, even when published, was probably a little out of date. Again, this is not something for which the editors or contributors are at fault. They are not likely to have been able to predict that President Trump would have won the 2016 election at the time the Handbook was finalised and, even if they were, they would not have been able to predict exactly what changes were likely to occur in the ACA as a result. Nevertheless, it does limit the appeal of the Handbook for an audience who might be unfamiliar with the intricacies of US health law knowing that the Handbook might have more use as a book which captures a period of time in terms of the law of the US rather than its current form.
In conclusion, then, there is much to like about The Oxford Handbook of US Health Law. It covers a range of topics very well and provides a good grounding for understanding the complexities and uniqueness of US law in the area. It may have some limitations for a European or international market, however, as it lacks comparative chapters and does not account for changes post-2016 election. It thus provides a good starting point for those interested in US health law, but those wishing to develop an expertise in the area will have to supplement the readings with more up to date analysis.
